Electrical tale long
Randy Johnson Connersville, IN
>A few months ago there was an electrical discussion of some kind and I said I�d post this sometime. Since I seem to be in a situation where typing is the hardest work I can do for a few days, here is a good electrical story problem. Or maybe it�s an electrical problem story. In over thirty years of troubleshooting residential wiring it remains the strangest thing I�ve ever run across. It happened in 1992, and since then I�ve discussed it with everyone from electricians far more experienced than myself to people with double Es. To date, nobody has come up with an explanation that covers all the bases. I hereby submit the tale to the good people of Woodcentral.
Da Story
I was working for a local plumbing/electrical contractor when a man called one day and said his wife was painting the garage and kept getting shocked. (Sounds kinda like the start of the old Dragnet doesn�t it?) The job was handed to me. I drove out there expecting to find a metal sided pole building with a place on a run of Romex that had either been rubbed down to the bare wire by building movement or had the insulation chewed away by a rodent.
The first assumption proved wrong in that the building in question was an all-wood weatherboard sided garage. The lady pointed out the places where she had been shocked. It�s been a long time but I think there were maybe three or four. My first thought (revised assumption) was that maybe it was some kind of nerve twinge and she only thought she was being shocked. I asked how bad she�d been shocked. Her answer was, �YOU touch it and find out�. There was something in her tone of voice that made me think it might be a good idea to do the touching with a voltmeter. It was.
On a few VERY small selected areas of the building I was able to get a reading of just over 100 volts to ground. By moving the probe as little as a quarter inch or less in any direction the reading would go to zero. I killed the power to the building and dug into the siding of the building expecting to find the head of a nail. When maybe an eighth of an inch or so of digging found no nail I got smart and did some measuring using the frame of the entry door as a reference. The location I was gouging was not even close to one of the studs (exposed since this was just an unattached garage) and there was no nail protruding through the siding near where I was probing, so a nail under the hot spot was eliminated. Wiring in the building was all the older woven cover Romex, and although I don�t remember specifically it was probably without a bare ground.
There was a junction box where I was able to eliminate power to everything but an overhead light. I could have eliminated it as well but the owner didn�t want to lose the light. After this was done, I was able to stand on the ladder outside and tell the owner when he turned the light on and off by watching the needle on my voltmeter go back and forth between zero (light off) and about 25 volts (light on). When I left, the garage was paintable as long as the light remained off. The owner said he would have the entire building rewired.
Part of the problem would seem to be that for some reason the insulation on the wire was no longer doing its job. The amount of wire in the entire garage was less than fifty feet and I checked every inch of it for damage without finding any. The lower reading when the only thing on the circuit was the overhead light would mean that while there was some degree of insulation loss in the lighting circuit, it wasn�t as severe as in other parts of the wiring. As I write this, I can�t remember exactly how the JB was fed but I�m thinking it was with newer wire which would account for the zero reading when the switch was in the off position.
The really puzzling part was that only a few areas on the building showed current to ground. For the sake of argument let�s say I missed a spot and a bare conductor was actually in contact with part of the building. Wood, particularly wood in the form of dried building siding, is a poor conductor. I would think (and even after wiring a few dozen homes, countless remodeling jobs, and a few commercial buildings I do not consider myself an expert by any use of the word) that even if there was a bare conductor touching the building somewhere it would be undetectable within a very short distance. Like inches. When I was there, only one side and part of another had been painted. There were hot places on both of the two sides painted up to that point and there may well have been others yet undiscovered by the paintbrush. There was considerable distance between the first place the lady got shocked and the one that prompted them to call the place I worked. How could there be places yards apart that showed voltage when almost all the building showed none at all? I haven�t a clue. It couldn�t have been something in an individual piece of siding because the hot spots were in different pieces. None of the wire in the building was close to the places showing voltage. It was one of the times that I was able to solve the problem without knowing how it was happening. The only thing I can say for sure is that there were no nails where I was getting a reading of 100 volts. And yes, I checked all the places where she had been shocked.



