Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

How wrong is this design?

Posts

How wrong is this design?

#1

How wrong is this design?

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

>How wrong would it be to have rails that are on top of stiles instead of between for a frame and panel side of a cabinet? My stile stock is a little too short to go the distance I want.

Re: How wrong is this design?

#2

Re: How wrong is this design?

John E in SC

>Only you can decide how "wrong" it would be, but if it were me, I know I would regret it everytime I looked at that piece of furniture. Personally, I'd spend a few extra bucks and/or a little extra time and do it "right".

My 2 cents.

John

Re: How wrong is this design?

#3

Re: How wrong is this design?

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX

>It all depends on the rest of the design. I have done it where I wanted to carry a strong horizontal line through a project, but if you are doing something that has a more traditional feel, you may be better off just getting more material.

Re: How wrong is this design?

#4

Lee Grindinger

It's not

Lee Grindinger

>James Krenov did it all the time.

Lee

Re: How wrong is this design?

#5

Re: It's not

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

>Not wrong at all, maybe unconventional though.

As mentioned, James Krenov probably pioneered this method and I've used it once so far.. I'm using it in a piece I'm currently building.

If you're interested, you can have a look at what the door frame would look like here.

http://refinededge.blogspot.com

Norman

Re: How wrong is this design?

#6

Re: How wrong is this design?

Jesse Cloud

>No problem, but you would want to move the tenon so the groove won't show.

Re: How wrong is this design?

#7

Re: How wrong is this design?

Paul Waddle

>Don't know much about cabinets,but old in homes the doorways were always framed this way,got away from the 45* angles and as the wood shrunk,didn't look that bad either. pw

Re: How wrong is this design?

#8

Re: Haunched tenon

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

>This is taken care of with a haunched tenon. A stub part of the tenon equal to the thickness and depth of the groove fits in the groove on the outside edge, so the gap is filled.

Norman

Re: How wrong is this design?

#9

Our own HC Sakman does it...

Pat Evans

>it can't be wrong