How wrong is this design?
Doug Reynolds in Seattle
>How wrong would it be to have rails that are on top of stiles instead of between for a frame and panel side of a cabinet? My stile stock is a little too short to go the distance I want.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
How wrong is this design?
Doug Reynolds in Seattle
>How wrong would it be to have rails that are on top of stiles instead of between for a frame and panel side of a cabinet? My stile stock is a little too short to go the distance I want.
Re: How wrong is this design?
John E in SC
>Only you can decide how "wrong" it would be, but if it were me, I know I would regret it everytime I looked at that piece of furniture. Personally, I'd spend a few extra bucks and/or a little extra time and do it "right".
My 2 cents.
John
Re: How wrong is this design?
Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX
>It all depends on the rest of the design. I have done it where I wanted to carry a strong horizontal line through a project, but if you are doing something that has a more traditional feel, you may be better off just getting more material.
It's not
Lee Grindinger
>James Krenov did it all the time.
Lee
Re: It's not
Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)
>Not wrong at all, maybe unconventional though.
As mentioned, James Krenov probably pioneered this method and I've used it once so far.. I'm using it in a piece I'm currently building.
If you're interested, you can have a look at what the door frame would look like here.
http://refinededge.blogspot.com
Norman
Re: How wrong is this design?
Jesse Cloud
>No problem, but you would want to move the tenon so the groove won't show.
Re: How wrong is this design?
Paul Waddle
>Don't know much about cabinets,but old in homes the doorways were always framed this way,got away from the 45* angles and as the wood shrunk,didn't look that bad either. pw
Re: Haunched tenon
Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)
>This is taken care of with a haunched tenon. A stub part of the tenon equal to the thickness and depth of the groove fits in the groove on the outside edge, so the gap is filled.
Norman
Our own HC Sakman does it...
Pat Evans
>it can't be wrong