Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Tropical Hardwood article in AAW Mag????

Posts

Tropical Hardwood article in AAW Mag????

#1

Tropical Hardwood article in AAW Mag????

Barry Irby

>Has anyone read the article about the tropical hardwoods in the AAW Magazine? The Author is claiming it is difficult to get accurate stats on which species are really endangered and which are not. That here is a lot of fraud in the milling of the lumber and no way to tell if Illegally or disreputably harvested lumber is mixed with plantation grown stuff.

I read (here) that something like 35 to 40% is harvested for local use, some of which is burning it for fuel. Another 35 or 40% is burned just to get it off the land so they have room for agriculture. That leaves 20 to 30% that is cut for export. If this is true, would it make more sense for us to import more? That is, the part they burn to get it off the land? I know they use the ashes to fertilize the soil, so perhaps we could trade them some fertilizer for that and some coal for the part they use for fuel.

I am just wondering how much of the deforestation is driven by wood workers in the rest of the world. I spend exactly no time in furniture stores, but on the last few trips I took, I saw nothing made of exotic hardwoods. I do see stuff made form rubber trees, but my understanding of those is that they are plantation grown and tapped for rubber and then cut and replanted when they are too old.

If the rest of the world stopped buying exotic hardwood wouldn't they just continue to deforest anyway?

Re: Tropical Hardwood article in AAW Mag????

#2

Re: Tropical Hardwood article in AAW Mag????  *LINK*

Ron in Drums PA

>


AAW Thread on this article

Re: Tropical Hardwood article in AAW Mag????

#3

Re: Tropical Hardwood article in AAW Mag????

ScottS

>Unfortunately, Barry, I don't think that buying more tropical hardwoods will help.

I'm not cognizant of the larger economic issues, but I've traveled extensively (compared to most Americans) in south and east Africa and been exposed to the subsistence-level farming that goes on there. It's typically of the "slash and burn" variety and goes something like this: You're out of work or having difficulty feeding your family. A relative is doing "well" farming in some area of the country, so you move there. Of course you need a field, so you immediately cut down everything that can be cut, burn the rest, and plow it under. Now you've got a field, but no knowledge of modern agriculture (e.g. crop rotation), no irrigation, no pesticides, and no fertilizer. You borrow some money to buy seed and make a go of it for a couple of years. At some point, things will start to go downhill. There will be a drought, the nutrients in the soil will become depleted, or something else will make it harder for your farm to be successful. So what do you do? Blame the problems on the land, move elsewhere, and start the whole cycle over again!

Of course, there's a bit of an exaggeration in my description but not as much as you might think. The places I've visited didn't have any valuable hardwoods, but I suspect the situation is much the same everywhere. What happens if we start buying more tropical hardwoods? Imagine you had a choice between farming for an entire year to make $250 or cutting down trees and selling them for $0.50/bf. Which would you choose? If it were me, I'd be cutting down every tree I could find and damn the farming!

The problem is obviously a complex one and I don't think there's any easy solution. I'm fairly certain, however, that if we start buying lumber without requiring sustainable harvesting that we'll see endangered trees disappearing at an alarming rate...

Re: Tropical Hardwood article in AAW Mag????

#4

Re: Tropical Hardwood article in AAW Mag????

Ron in Drums PA

>Very good points Scott.

Consider this, a farmer that decides to cut and sell wood instead of farming still has to get the timber to market. Question is, can he afford the equipment for logging?

Re: Tropical Hardwood article in AAW Mag????

#5

There are still places on the planet where the ...

Art Silva

>cost of getting to the mill is measured in bales/mile.

Re: Tropical Hardwood article in AAW Mag????

#6

Re: Tropical Hardwood article in AAW Mag????

ScottS

>Axes were certainly available in the places I've visited in Africa and that's about all you'd need to start felling trees. Getting them to a market or sawmill is a different story. Cars were very expensive in most of the countries I've visited; I once walked past a Mazda dealership in Pretoria and was surprised to find a US$40,000 sticker on a Mazda 323! Roads and infrastructure in many areas are poor, which would increase the challenge. So, at least in the places I've visited, it wouldn't be practical for an individual farmer to harvest large amounts of timber.

Still, capitalism moves quickly, especially when there aren't any legislated restrictions: if there were a market for hardwood lumber, my guess is that someone with a truck would manage to buy logs from local farmers (probably paying only pennies per board foot) and haul them to a saw mill. And as soon as one person started making money from logging, more people would start cutting down trees, more trucks would appear to haul them to saw mills, etc.

I heard about a somewhat analogous situation while traveling through the Okavango Delta in Botswana. "Guides" could make quite a bit of money paddling tourists through the Delta in dugout canoes. So people started moving to the area, cutting down trees, and trying to make canoes. They'd cut down any tree they could find and start hallowing it out in the hopes of ending up with a canoe. Of course, half the people didn't know what they were doing or how to select a proper tree, so many of the trees went to waste. If you cut down a tree and your canoe didn't work out, you'd just cut down another and try again. At some point, it got so bad that the government had to ban felling of trees in the national park and insisted that guides could only use metal canoes! Or at least that's what I was told...

Re: Tropical Hardwood article in AAW Mag????

#7

Re: Tropical Hardwood article in AAW Mag????

Barry Irby

>I'm not a global or strategic thinker either. My point it exactly that the driving force is the slash and burn subsistence farming, not the furniture industry or the hobbyist wood worker/wood turner market.

They are cutting the trees because they are in their way and they want to farm. Don't blame me because I made a tool handle out of cocobolo. And even if they bane the import of the wood to the US or the entire rest of the world, the trees will still be cut and burned. They will probably burn the part they would have sold us to make stuff out of, after all, its in their way.

I come from a long line of farmers. I know a thing or two abut subsistence farming just from living in the same house with my Dad and Grandfather. And yes, we made more money selling the trees than we did farming. In fact, I am farming trees as I type this. I'm growing pine. In a year or two I will sell you some pulp wood. In a few more years I will sell you some poles or in them more years you can buy some timber.

Somehow there needs to be a solution that supports the people while the trees grow so they don't have to burn them and none of us gets much out of them.