>I've added a workshop addition to the house - and we've extended the forced-air HVAC system (minus returns) from the house to the shop. The problem is, like most residential systems, our house isn't setup with zones -- it's either on or off for the whole house. While the shop is attached to the house, there is intentionally no direct access to the living space...the only entrances are via the back patio and the garage.
In order to warm the shop up into the mid/upper 50's this weekend, I had to basically crank the heat up and turn the blower to "ON" instead of auto. It was comfortable in the shop, but my family was sweating it out in the mid-70's in the main house. Additionally, I have pretty good cross ventilation and will prefer not to waste AC in the shop in the summertime.
I'm assuming there are "blast gates" for residential HVAC systems that I could purchase at the local HD...but not having any knowledge/experience with working on HVAC systems I was looking to see if anyone had solved this problem or similar and/or had any recommendations/cautions for me. Is this something I can do myself or should I definitely call in the pros?
Thanks!
Re: Adding Zones to Home HVAC for Attached Workshop
Re: Adding Zones to Home HVAC for Attached Worksho
Barry Irby
>There are zoning systems for residential ducts. I have only seen a few and none of them worked as well as expected or even worked properly. I believe Carrier manufactured or at least sold the ones I saw.
It was a computerized system with a bunch of motorized dampers and up to four zones. Each zone had its own thermostat. The way it works is each damper reverts to the open position when the system is off. Then when one zone calls for heat, the others close, causing the heat to go to the one that is calling. Apparently something of a mind bender to set up. As I said, I have never seen one that worked right. Just too complicated for the guys they are putting in the field these days.
This is further complicated by the fact that you must maintain minimum air flow for proper performance and to prevent the system from over heating if only one zone is on, so it is setup so that when only one zone is calling the others open about twenty percent and occasionally the system will open them all and "dump" heat into the house.
Your situation is complicated by the fact that you don't have a return in the shop. Any air blown into the shop must escape without returning to the system. If that is true, then the same amount of air must be leaking back into the house from somewhere to go to the return and compensate for the lost air. Chances are, there are air leaks from the shop to the house. The shop is under positive pressure when the system is on and house is under negative pressure. If there is air leaking back, so is dust. This has got to be a wasteful system. There is also the possibility that undesirable air such as from the crawl space is being drawn into the house along with mold and moisture and soil gasses.
There are manual as well as automatic dampers that you can use to balance the airflow better. They are much simpler than the system I mentioned above. Ask an HVAC contractor about a "balancing" damper. What you are trying to do is balance the air flow between the house and shop so that each is at a pleasant temp. If you are turning off the heat in the shop when you are not there, it will be more complicated, because you would be asking the system to heat the shop form cold to pleasant without affecting the house. If the shop is heated all the time it would be easier. I still don't know what to say about the lack of a return in the shop. Very difficult to get a system to perform properly with out proper returns. All of this is based on Air Flow and the recirculation of air. Your is not recirculating.
Re: Adding Zones to Home HVAC for Attached Workshop
Re: Adding Zones to Home HVAC for Attached Worksho
TJ
>I did the same thing in my attached garage shop. The HVAC guy extended one of my two systems to the garage without a return. He put in a damper that is operated by a switch.
When I am ready to cool the shop, I switch open the damper and get air in the shop. The only issue I have is that I have to lower the thermostat to force the system on to get the shop cooled to a comfortable temperature. Then I return the thermostat to normal and both the house and the shop remain cool.
I haven't needed any heat yet - I live in the Dallas Texas area and we are having mostly spring like weather up until this week.
No problem with dust. I try to open the damper a while before I plan to be in the shop to allow the system to catch up.
The guy who did the work for me was the guy who installed the original system in the home.
Hope that helps.
TJ
Re: Adding Zones to Home HVAC for Attached Workshop
I'm not an HVAC guy but unless you have the door to your shop open to the house, with no return, there's no significant amounts of climate controlled air getting in there. Zoning is your answer to keeping the rest of the house sequestered from shop dust and odors but it's a big job best left to someone other than me!
Re: Adding Zones to Home HVAC for Attached Workshop
Re: Adding Zones to Home HVAC for Attached Worksho
Don Evans
>I'm really surprised any HVAC guy would do this work! Without a return you are really wasting your time and money.
The idea way to do what you want is to take the money you'll waste overtime and never get this to work and put that money into a smaller HVAC system for just the shop.
Zone systems are NOT cheap and it will work the present system to an early death. Go ahead and spend that money on a unit just for the shop and be done with it and you'll have a comfortable shop and home.
Plus happier family.
I've got the same thing here, I had a 1.5 ton Trane heat pump put in the shop and haven't looked back.
Don
Re: Adding Zones to Home HVAC for Attached Workshop
Re: Adding Zones to Home HVAC for Attached Worksho *LINK*
Patrick Jaromin
>Thanks, Barry and TJ! Very helpful...as I suspected, zoning is more complicated than I would have thought. Glad I asked!
I found the automatic dampers at smarthome.com -- I've outfitted the house, and now the shop with Insteon keypads, so I'm thinking I could assign one of the switches to the damper.
A better thought (I think) is that instead of the damper I see they have inline blowers. Perhaps what I could do is install an inline fan that I could activate remotely to draw more heated air into the shop during the "warm up" period, thus reducing the amount of time needed to heat up the shop to comfortable levels allowing me to restore the thermostat setting to normal more quickly. This would also mean that the shop wouldn't ever be completely without heat...so even on the coldest days I would expect it to maintain upper 40's, lower 50's (I hope).
I would probably install a manual damper at the same time so that in the summer I could drastically limit the amount of A/C from escaping out the shop since I'd typically have the doors open anyway.
Re: Adding Zones to Home HVAC for Attached Worksho
Patrick Jaromin
>There was quite a discussion re: "no return" during the inspection...but ultimately the inspectors agreed that to return fume-laden, dusty air into the house was not a good idea.
I do understand what you're saying -- and realize that air won't flow properly if the pressure can't equalize. My first thought when it turned colder was that perhaps I wouldn't be able to get any forced-air heat into the shop due to this pressure situation. There's a crawl space under the shop that connects to the main house crawl -- with a 6" (or so) gap through which I'm guessing the air is currently flowing back into the house. As you say...this isn't really desirable.
I didn't think of installing a separate HVAC unit dedicated to the shop...but I do think you're right -- that's probably the sanest, if not cheapest/easiest/most effective solution overall.
My temporary fall-back solution to get me through the winter may be to move the ceiling-mounted electric heater from the "old shop" (read: 2-car garage) into the new addition to "jump start" the heating process when I'm out working. I'd prefer to keep it in my new "assembly area" if possible, however. Side note: my wife doesn't know about the assembly area yet. She thinks it's for car storage. ;)
Re: Adding Zones to Home HVAC for Attached Workshop
>When I designed my shop here, which is adjacent to the home, atached through a 8 ft. wall, I decided to tap into the HVAC home system.
That particular wall is beefed up with 2 back to back rows of studs, noise insulation, 2 layers of drywall, and special noise abatement stuff ( acoustic channels) of which I can't remember now.
The issue of air return to the home furnace area was addressed in the following way. I had a port put in in the lower level of the shop which is the size of a standard furnace filter 16X25. This was framed in with trim applied, etc. so it looks like it belongs there :) The idea was to install a furnace filter to filter the return air.
The square inches of the return port are equivalent to 2 standard return ducts in area. Furnace filters pop right in and can be quickly exchanged when necessary. If you do it right and build a small ledge up on the shop side, the filter is actually secured into the frmae from simple air pressure.
7 years later and it works well. No dust at all in the main home furnace area, and it is effective as a air return. Any positive pressure in the shop area is balanced, maybe not instantly, but within seconds. I call this a "passive" air return.
Norman
Re: Adding Zones to Home HVAC for Attached Workshop
>That's a cool idea. Had I thought of this, I would have been concerned that the filter wouldn't do a sufficient job of handling fumes.
I don't really have the wall space to implement your exact solution -- however I betcha I could convert one of the floor vents into a return and then build/install a box in the crawlspace just below it fitted with a replaceable filter. I'm fairly certain that the vent I'm thinking of is no more than a couple feet from the main return duct.
The inspector originally suggested converting this one floor vent into a return before allowing the "no return" situation to stand.
Had I requested/received your advice before final inspection, I could have likely made the contractor do this for me. Sigh.
Thanks!
Re: Adding Zones to Home HVAC for Attached Workshop
>If you are talking about solvent fumes from oil based stains and topcoats, you're into a whole new ball game. You should seriously consider a separate system. You will never get adequete heating and cooling without the return to the generalized system and you will never sequester the house from fumes if you mix air. Furthermore, any kind of open flame heat is out of the question with solvent laden air.
I would suggest radiant heat of some type...perhaps a hot water baseboard system...and low VOC waterborne finishes to minimize your problems. IMHO, with the incredible advances in these finishing products, there's no need to stink yourself out of the shop.
Re: Adding Zones to Home HVAC for Attached Workshop
>Further to my post, I don't spray any longer, just hand applied finishes here..
If I do need to occasionally spray again, I'll seriously look into water based sprays as Chris mentioned. When I did spray I sealed the "passive" return duct to contain any airborne VOC particulates within the shop area., at least until they settled.
Norman
Re: Adding Zones to Home HVAC for Attached Workshop
>For most work I use water-based stains and poly. These are applied by hand. When I spray (paint/poly), I plan to use the garage (as I've done before the addition) with the door open and backed by a window fan behind the work -- again, water-based only. I'm not setup to spray oil-based stuff.
I do sometimes use oil-based "tung oil" finishes, hand rubbed.
To vent the shop, I had a 300CFM (~300+sq. ft of shop, 8-12' cathedral ceiling) vent fan installed...although this was primarily designed for evacuating any smaller dust particles not captured by the DC or air filtration system. I have double doors in the front and a single in the back designed to promote good cross-ventilation when working with any VOCs.
I don't intend to do use any oil-based finishes in the colder months when the doors will remain shut tight.
Re: Adding Zones to Home HVAC for Attached Workshop
Re: Adding Zones to Home HVAC for Attached Worksho
Barry Irby
>Patrick, I don't think I explained the problem very well. Because the volumes are huge and air is invisible, I think may people don't "get" what is going on with their heat/AC.
Visualize your heating system as a heating unit with one supply duct and one return duct and your house as one room. There are no air leaks. Everything is perfectly tight. Lets say 1000 CFM of air flows through the furnace when the fan is running. So, the unit comes on and 1000CFM flows out of the supply side, into your house, back through the Return and back through the furnace. In this perfect little system without leaks the air just travels round and round with no losses. That's the goal. Leaks make it much more complicated.
Now lets say you have a bunch of supply ducts in the attic and the return duct travels through the crawl space. One of the supply ducts comes loose and starts blowing about a 100CFM into the attic. The furnace is still moving 1000 CFM, but 100 is being lost to the attic, (outside the heated space). The unit is sucking 1000 CFM into the return but only 900 CFM are coming back through the remaining supply ducts. The system is 100 Feet short. That air must come back into the house form some where. The house is under negative pressure. Air will leak in through the path of least resistance. If there is a hole in the return duct it will suck air out of the crawl space. IF the duct is tight, air will flow back into the house around windows and doors and through any other holes it can find.
Your shop represents the broken duct in the attic. You are intentionally blowing hundreds of CFM into the shop. The shop is under positive pressure. The extra air must leak out. In fact, if the shop were perfectly leak proof, you could not blow the air in. It would be like trying to blow air into a bottle. Wrap your lips around the mouth of a bottle and try. Unless you compress the air, you can't blow any in unless and equal amount flows out. (A friend says "you must have goes outta to have goes into"). So, if you are heating your shop with out letting the air return to the system, its leaking out somewhere and the same amount of air is leaking back into the house from somewhere else.
There are several important points here. In the first example, the air went round and round. The furnace blows it out and 130 and pulls it back at 65 degrees. When the air comes back to the furnace it is only 5 degrees below the desired room temp. If there are leaks and the air is coming in from outside, you are letting air at room temp escape and air come back at outdoor temps. So, it could be coming back at 50, or 30, or whatever the temp is where you live. So if you live in a cold climate the heat loss could be huge.
And there are other problems. If the air is leaking in from the
crawl space, you will be drawing in soil gases, maybe Radon, and maybe mold.
If your house has flues one of the easiest sources for the make up air is a flue. If you are exhausting 500 CFM out of the shop and you have the damper on your fireplace open it would be surprising if some of the air were not coming back down the flue. This is a mechanically induced form of back drafting or spillage. Also a possibility on any other natural draft device like a gas water heater. You can test for this with a smoke pencil or any thing that produces a stream of smoke. (a match, a smokey candle, or a cigarette, etc.) hold the stream of smoke near the FP or the flue for the WH and watch, when the system is OFF and then again when it is ON. It may take several seconds, but you may see the direction of the smoke reverse. This is potentially very dangerous. You have a small wood fire going with dieing embers. Producing lots of CO and not much off a draft. The wife is napping on the sofa in front of the FP and you go to the shop. A couple of hours later, the wife won't wake up.
This is much more complex than it seems. Be careful. Get a CO detector and soem good advice from an HVAC contractor or a Energy Auditor.