Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Cross Grain connection Question?

Posts

Cross Grain connection Question?

#1

Cross Grain connection Question?

Barry Irby

>I have been working on doll cradles as Christmas Gifts. I think I have made a mistake. I wanted the stretcher between the legs to serve a double purpose. To brace the uprights to stop them from racking and to prevent the little cradle from doing a loop the loop. I had an epiphany and decided to use a sliding dovetail for the joint. (We discussed tusked tennons that would allow for disassembly and wedged through tennons as good options here on WC, but I am set up to do sliding dovetails). So I went with what I knew and what I could do easily. Just as I finished gluing the last one it dawned on me that this is a cross grained connection aobut 7 1/2" long in walnut. How badly have I screwed up?

Re: Cross Grain connection Question?

#2

Re: Cross Grain connection Question? *LINK*

Virgil Johnson

>7 1/2" should not be a problem. 28 yrs ago in high school I built three pieces of furniture full of cross grain construction. We did not know any better. Draw something and build it....aahhh the good ol days.. The desk in the pic is holding up well despite having frame panels glued cross grain to 18" wide sides.


http://www.woodcentral.com/shots/shot136.shtml

Re: Cross Grain connection Question?

#3

Re: Cross Grain connection Question?

Chris Knob

>Agreed. Norm has us all paranoid about "cross grain situations". Anything under 10-12 inches isn't worth the extra joinery milling time to insure stability in 150 years.

I have some end tables I glued and nailed the breadboard edges to 15 years ago and there's not a sign of a problem. I'm not saying this is a good thing to do on an 18" wide tabletop but our phobias about furniture blowing apart because of seasonal movement and imoble cross grained joints are blown out of proportion. Poorly seasoned wood is a far more frequent culprit in joinery failures than cross grain situations.

Re: Cross Grain connection Question?

#4

Re: Cross Grain connection Question?

Virgil Johnson

>I would never build another piece of furniture with the same construction as the high school items now that I have a bit more education about wood movement. What I was trying to point out is what's done is done and most likely it will last a long time.