Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

OT - GPS for Car

Posts

OT - GPS for Car

#1

OT - GPS for Car

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Sorry about the off-topic post, but I'm visiting my Son in Utah, and he wants to get his Wife one of these GPS units for her car. There are a lot of them on sale right now, but I really don't know anything about them. Which brands and models should we be looking at? We will need one that is simple to operate. I have heard of Garmin and Magellan. What would you suggest? Thanks in advance!

Scott.

Re: OT - GPS for Car

#2

Re: OT - GPS for Car

Garrett in Victoria

>I believe TomTom is the world's largest automobile GPS provider. Garmin, owned by Jeppesen, is more broadly based with a huge range of marine products and hand-helds. You can't go wrong with either. The real choice is about"features". All basic GPS units have good maps, point-to-point navigation usually with at least one intermediate stop en route, voice prompts for turns, a million 'points of interest' such as gas stations, hotels, restaurants etc., most of which pay the mapmaker for inclusion, and the ability to save favorite destinations. These units are now available for about $150 on sale.

For increasing amounts of money, you get bigger screens, more way-points (the ability to plot a trip with several stops), driver voice commands instead of screen taps to set destination info or access other feature, bluetooth connectivity which, with a monthly subscription, provides on-line traffic and weather info, and so on.

I've been using an in-car GPS for about 6 years. Of the additional features, the one I'd most like to have is the driver voice command.

Cheers, Garrett

Re: OT - GPS for Car

#3

Re: OT - GPS for Car

David Yoho

>We've been using a Garmin Nuvi-350 for a while and like it a lot. The difference between the Nuvi-350 and the 360 is the 360 has Bluetooth, which we didn't need.

David

Re: OT - GPS for Car

#4

Re: OT - GPS for Car

Howard Norman

>I would suggest one of the Garmin units, which one would be determined by the features you desire. Voice commands are essential in my opinion.

Howard

Re: OT - GPS for Car

#5

Re: OT - GPS for Car

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I purchased one about 4 months ago. I looked at the Garmin, TomTom and Magellan systems. I bought the Magellan Maestro 4000. It had a fairly large screen and all the features I wanted. Audio prompts, auto-rerouting, Detour, and a complete set of USA maps programmed in the unit. I have used it all around Indiana. My son has borrowed it several times. I am amazed at the detail of the maps included. Several times I have used it on small country roads and housing additions. It has always known the street addresses. Programming is very intuitive and user friendly. I found one discounted on Buy.com. I went to a nearby Circuit City store and they matched the price (think I paid about $230). We left the store, my son was playing with the unit and had it programmed for my house (without reading the manual), in less than 5 minutes. As this is my first GPS system, I can't compare it against the competition, but I am very satisfied with the unit.

Re: OT - GPS for Car

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT - GPS for Car

Jesper, Denmark

>Garmin is the most intuitive to use.

I have a Garmin N�vi 660 because the larger screen is easier on the old eyes. I like the bluetooth, as a phone call comes in and can be handled with just the phone in my pocket.

It also transfers all the phone lists from the PC via cable, so making calls on the road is a snap.

The maps here inEurope need a l�ittle updating, but work OK 99% of the time - some places they build traffic circles faster than the maps are updated.

Re: OT - GPS for Car

#7

Re: OT - GPS for Car

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hi Scott,

I just bought a TomTom One 3rd Edition and love it. It's simple to use and has all the features I wanted without being loaded down with stuff I'd never use. It's on sale for $149 at Dell.com.

Jen

Re: OT - GPS for Car

#8

Garmin

Dustmaker Mike

>I have both the Garmin and Tom Tom. I like the Garmin better because when I have rached my destantion it says on the right or left. The Tom Tom I use in Europe and some around the states I like it but, it just says you have reached your destnation but not what side of the road it is on.

Re: OT - GPS for Car

#9

Re: OT - GPS for Car

John E in SC

>I have a Magellan Roadmate (2000 - I think). If you're looking for simple and inexpensive, it's a great option. This is my second unit, but both were Magellan, so I can't comment on the others. Our last one died after about 4-5 years, and about that time, Consumer Reports came out with a ranking for GPS, and the Magellan Roadmate was a "best buy". It's only a few hundred bucks, and comes with preloaded maps, so all you have to do literally is plug it in to the cigarette lighter and you're ready to go. It will occasionally give you a "screwy" direction, but I think they all do that from what I've heard. Once you get one, you won't ever want to be without one.

John

Re: OT - GPS for Car

#10

Re: Garmin

Brian

>This may not be an issue for all but the Garmin can come with a sandbag for dash mounting instead of the suction cup. The latter do not always work. The sandbag mount is very easy to use.

Re: OT - GPS for Car

#11

Re: OT - GPS for Car

M. McNamee

>You might find this information useful:

http://www.gpsmagazine.com/2007/11/dont_buy_the_wrong_gps_on_blac.php

Re: OT - GPS for Car

#13

Re: OT - GPS for Car

Tom

>It'll depend on your budget. There are many price-points with gps units. Features I appreciate are text-to-speech (instead of just turn by turn directions) and as large a screen as possible. We have two, an LG LN740 and a Garmin 650. My brother has a Mio c310x. The LG ($280, 4" screen) is very functional, with TTS, and simple to operate. It doesn't do latitude/longitude though (most people wouldn't care about that). The Mio ($150 maybe) does just about everything, and has many features, but the software is sort of confusing. The Garmin is my favorite. $310 shipped at Amazon or Costco, 4.3" widescreen, 2008 maps, TTS, quick recalculating (the LG is fast too) and a very good routing algorithm (the LG is good too, the Mio is sometimes odd in the routes it chooses). It also does many other things too (including coordinates). The friction mount (sandbag/beanbag) can be had for about $20 and makes it very easy to move from one car to another without glues, screws or adhesives. Surprising, it does a real good job of not moving.

Re: OT - GPS for Car

#14

Thank You!

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Great Information! I now feel like my Son might be able to get a decent unit, based on the information here. My friends at Wood Central have done it again! Thank you so much!

Scott.

Re: OT - GPS for Car

#15

Re: Thank You!

Dave Bonde - Iowa

>Scott, I'm in the discussion a little late on this but I just went through a lot of research on GPS's and ended up ordering a Garmin 200W seemed to fit my needs the best. Lots of good choices out there now in the $150 to $250 range. Good luck Dave

Re: OT - GPS for Car

#16

Re: Follow-up

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>I just heard from my Son that he bought a Garmin Nuvi 360 because of the combination of features it had. He got it from Amazon for about $320. When we were talking to him about it, my Wife surprised me by saying she might want one as well!

Thanks again! You guys are great!

Scott.

Re: OT - GPS for Car

#17

Re: Follow-up

JohnKJordan in East TN

>You won't be sorry with a Garmin - I've had five over the years. The wonderful thing is the way the prices keep dropping. The one I carry today in the woods was over $500 and the one I usually use in the car with a color screen was almost $1000 a few years back!

And the accuracy these days is amazing, compared to what you could get with the Selective Availabiliy fiasco a few years ago, but even that blew my mind what with graphical map display and everything.

Before GPS, I think I was the only one on my street who carried around a portable Loran receiver in the car and airplane. (I fit it with a neck strap so I could carry it in the woods, resting on my chest). The output was in coordinates only, and due to the way long waves followed the ground over the mountains, I had to manually correct each coordinate by approximately 1/2 mile in East TN before locating it on a paper map. Made me appreciate GPS all the more!

JKJ