Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

My furnace is running (OT)

Posts

My furnace is running (OT)

#1

My furnace is running (OT)

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I got time, I might as well write the whole thing. It will be another couple hours before the girls get up and we need to get ready for church. Meanwhile I will go grind some Starbucks beans and get a fresh pot of some of the best coffee in the world. The question is whether you want to read the whole thing.

I am thankful for heat this morning. The saga begins about 3 years ago when I made the decision that cutting firewood was not something I really wanted to spend a bunch of time doing. Then carrying it into the house, and keeping the fire going. And trying to keep the insects like carpenter ants out. Plus the fact that I help cut my dad's firewood. Our cost for heating the whole house with propane is about $100 per month on the equal payment plan, so it really isn't worth my time. So we nixed the wood stove and it is going to be moved into the shop. I am not sure if it was from using the furnace more or if it was just a cheap furnace, but the existing furnace we had 3 years ago just would not burn right. I think one of the repair guys actually made it worse when he tried to fix it. So the existing furnace and the wood stove are both out.

When we got quotes for a new furance we also got quotes for adding on central air. Three HVAC companies came out. They all pretty much agreed. We were told that our ductwork was inadequate for central air and it would take extensive work to add ductwork downstairs, so the quotes for adding AC were upwards of $6000, which would include the furnace, revising the ductwork, and central air. So the AC was nixed and we just replaced the new furnace. I don't normally go with the lowest bidder; I go with the middle of the road, and I am pretty familiar with how people operate and consider myself to be a reasonable judge of character. We bought a new furnace from a local guy in Middlebury, IN. I thought he would need to revise the ductwork some to install the new furnace, but I am not a furnace guy. I thought I had hired an expert who would know the job and would make sure it was done right and we would just pay whatever it took to have it done right. We are not wealthy and we don't live in a big fancy house but we do okay and this is my life and I love it. We could easily have paid $1000 more to have the furnace installed.

Three years after having a new furnace installed we are laying in bed listening to the furnace running and not shutting off. We got out of bed and investigated and found it was not putting out any heat. I assumed one of the controls was bad and our furnace guy would fix it. This happened on Thursday November 8th. Friday morning Megan called the furnace man, and they came out Friday evening, around 6 pm. After they were working on the furnace about an hour I walked into the furnace room and asked if they knew what was wrong with it, and they said "We have some ideas, but we're still investigating". They had the top of the furnace open and knew exactly what was wrong with it at that very instant, because if you are a furnace repair man you know that the heat exchanger should not have a great big hole in it. This is a major problem in a furnace and the furnace has a safety on it that will put it into a shut down if the hole is big enough. This is why it wasn't lighting. They told us there were 3 reasons why the heat exchanger burned a hole into itself; 1) Inadequate ductwork for the furnace (Shouldn't they have known this when they installed it?) 2) A clogged chimney that needed a liner and a cap (the chimney does have a liner and a cap; they were looking at the chimney for the wood stove and thought the furnace was hooked up to that chimney; the chimney was not clogged although it was dirty; I assumed when we had that furnace serviced that the chimney was cleand out and it was not; also learned that the furnace was never serviced in '06 because my wife had called them and they never called back) 3) A clogged furnace filter. This was my fault for not realizing how important it is to keep the furnace filter clean. I knew it would affect the efficiency of the furnace but had no idea it would ruin it. My thoughts on blaming the failure of the furnace on the filter is that a) It was difficult and awkward to remove the filter, which was never installed properly; when they installed the furnace they simply cut a slot in the ductwork on the air intake and set a filter in it; it leaned one way or another and I knew it was not right and so I just put it out of sight and out of mind, and b) the way the furnace was installed there was enough air leaking around the intake that there was plenty of air to intake.

After the new furnace was installed and I looked it over in '04 I knew that the ductwork was not hooked up adequately and I would eventually have to have someone fix it. Shoulda coulda woulda. If I knew the furnace would burn up because of it, woulda. Hind sight's 20/20 and a thousand other cliches (along with some choice curse words). I also put on my list of things to do "Remodel the furnace room" because it looked terrible. Loose wires just poked through the drywall to the water heater and furnace, holes in the drywall, etc. I added some holes in the room when I installed an over the range microwave, to run the wires for it. Now that the furnace was disconnected and not running anyway I saw my opportunity and Saturday November 10th I tore everything except the water heater out of the furnace room. I left the existing drywall on. I went to Lowes and bought Armstrong snap lock flooring (the fake wood type in knotty pine pattern), paneling for the walls (clear maple for the back walls where it won't be seen much and a knotty cedar pattern for the visible walls) and some ceiling tiles. Monday 11/12/07 I called the furnace guy and told him that when they came back to install the furnace it would require some additional work to hook back up since I was remodeling the room. I assumed the furnace would be reinstalled around the middle of the week, since all they had to do was get the new heat exchanger (replaced free of charge by Maytag) and install it. Seems pretty simple for a furnace company to install a furnace. On Friday 11/23 ( a week after they ordered the exchanger) I called and he said he should have it in the shop on Monday. I told him we were leaving for a trip on Friday morning after Thanksgiving and would like to have the furnace installed before we leave. He replied that he would let me know on Monday when they were scheduling the install. No call on Monday. I called when I arrived at my somewhat cool home and much cooler wife and was told that he was out on an emergency call and would call me later that evening to schedule the install. No call. I called Tuesday evening and spoke to the secretary once again who told me that Bob had called me back Monday night to schedule the install and I told her that I would think I would remember that because this is a pretty big deal for me not to have a furnace in the middle of November in Michigan. We did have electric space heaters going throughout the house and we were blessed with mild weather throughout the ordeal so there was never any danger of freezing. Just burning the house down, a minor detail. She said that she would schedule us for a tentative appointment on Wednesday and I thought that was some pretty respectable dancing on her part and respected her efforts at calming the client while at the same time not promising anything so I let it go at that.

Wednesday morning they called and said they were coming to fix the furnace. Megan was overjoyed; she assumed they meant install the furnace. When one guy showed up with a van with no tools in it and said he was taking the furnace back to the shop and replacing the heat exchanger but he had plans for the weekend so they did not have time to install the furnace Megan was underjoyed. She actually cried, which I guess is not as big a deal for a woman as it is for a man. Women must have leaky washers on their tear ducts. My emotions were in check because this is the kind of service I assumed we would get from this company after dealing with them for several weeks on the issue. Although I did have an odd inclination to go smash something. No idea where that came from. They returned the furnace 1-1/2 hours after taking it and charged us $500 for labor for replacing the heat exchanger. I think I will file to get a restraining order placed on my furnace company. That is the last time they will be in my house.

Someone had to install the furnace, and it was now Wednesday before Thanksgiving day. We went to Lowes and saw a woefully inadequate supply of ductwork and I decided to look at Menards. I breathed a sigh of relief when I found they had pretty much everything I would need. Thursday I finished installing the rest of the flooring and some molding around the back of the room where the furnace was to be installed. Fortunately I had Friday off as well and would have plenty of time to get the furnace running. Friday morning I went to town for materials, and Friday afternoon I went for more parts, and Saturday I went for more parts. Right now I have more parts and tools scattered throughout the furnace room and shop than what it would take to fly to the moon but my furnace is running.

In assessing the way the ductwork was hooked up to the furnace I made up my mind to change the orientation of the furnace. Suffice it to say that the furnace had never worked as well as it does now. It moves a lot of heat in a hurry. Plus, there is an actual fitting on the side of the furnace which is specifically made for a 16 x 25 furnace filter; it holds the filter just the way it�s supposed to. Meanwhile I am looking for a new furnace company. There are a number of them in the yellow pages. One of them is called �Church� and advertises on our local Christian radio station. It seems that a company called Church would be honest. I will call them next week to look over the work I have done. If they look at me wrong, I now know how to get the restraining order for their butts. I will have to move the water heater now and then also add our new water softener and finish some of the molding and install the dog gate and re-install the drain on the upstairs vanity (disconnected to remodel the furnace room ) and clean up the shop. Then I can get back to work.

Re: My furnace is running (OT)

#2

Re: My furnace is running (OT)

Ken Oakley-SUNNY St. Cloud, Fla

>After reading your saga, I am sure I made the right decision 21 years ago when I left Long Island, N.Y., which doesn't get nearly as cold as Mich. most of the time and moved to Florida. Example- today expected high will be in low 80's. Mid week we could peak at 85. Of course we have alligators, snakes, bugs and summer heat but maybe once or twice a year the electric heat comes on to take the morning chill out of the house. When nothern friends tell us their heating cost I cringe. Hope you enjoyed your coffee.

Re: My furnace is running (OT)

#3

WHEW ! The joys of home ownership !

Steve Mackay

>

Re: My furnace is running (OT)

#4

Re: My furnace is running (OT)

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Moses,

Wow, that's quite a story. I thought I had troubles trying to get someone to install a propane regulator to a garage heater. Meaningless compared to what you and your family have been through.

Take care and stay warm,

Al

Re: My furnace is running (OT)

#5

Re: My furnace is running (OT)

Barry Irby

>Moses, what a saga.

A couple of things. As a Home Inspector I am not an Expert on furnaces but I do know a couple of things.

You mentioned that this is Propane, right? You said it was not Ont he flue with the wood stove. It has a separate flue. What used that flue before? If it were an oil fired device there could be issues. At the very least you want to get he flue clean and be sure the liner is suitable for gas and sound. There are "chemistry issues" using fuels in flues. Oil tends to be hot and hat sulfur in it, gas tends to be cooler and have moisture. The combination generates sulfuric acid. And, you never mix gas and solid fuel devices.

You said the furnace was 3 years old. Never heard of a furnace that did not come with at least a five year parts and labor warranty on the heat exchanger.

Changing a heat exchanger is a fairly easy job. That's why it only took and hour or so. If you have room to work, it would take about thirty minutes or less and only a few tools. They probaly took it away to change it becasue hey did not want you to have the "evidence", and becasue they did not wnat you to knwo how easy it was to chnge it.

Poorly designed duct work can restrict the air flow and cause the unit to over heat. Also, ducts in attics and crawl spaces must be insulated for Air Conditioning. (If they are inside the conditioned space, its not necessary to insulate them.) Also, AC dominates the design. AC uses Higher Volumes of Air than heat and requires larger ducts as a generality.

A really dirty filter will restrict air flow also. Poor ducts and a dirty filter both restrict the air flow, which has the effect of raising the operating temp of the furnace/heat exchanger. You can imagine that a 1000 CFM would do a better job of cooling the heat exchanger than 500 CFM. So a furnace that operates with restricted airflow heats up very hot and then cools down on each cycle. This causes the Heat Exchanger to endure thermal tresses much greater than normal. This could crack it or cause welds or rivets to fail. There should be an "upper limit" switch that turns off the fire if the unit gets too hot. (And a "lower limit" that does not allow the fan to run if it is not hot enough.) If the unit were severely over heating it should have protected itself by cycling the fire on and off. If you had observed this, you could have improved the ducts or set the fan to a higher speed or installed a clean filter to improve the air flow. The installer should have watched the unit run long enough to be sure it had proper air flow.

If the heat exchanger rusted out, it is likely to be from water dripping back down the flue. In a gas fire, about 18% of what goes up the flue is moisture vapor in the form of steam. You can actually calculate it. The gas company can give you figure that is how many cubic feet or pounds of steam are generated from each unit of gas. This is a new furnace and should have a draft fan on it. A small fan that blows the flue gases up the flue. There should be a condensate drain. Some of these units are so efficient they actually condense some or most of the flue gases to get the heat out of them. If your unit is below 90% efficient it sends most of the gases up the flue. (Unless you paid for a "condensing gas furnace", you did not get one.) The point is....flues are very tricky. Older flues operated under negative pressure and "drew" the gases out of the furnace. Newer ones with the draft fans operate under positive pressure. If the flue is larger than it needs to be, it has too much interior surface area and the flue gases condense in the flue and drool back down and may fall onto the heat exchanger. Flue gases are mildly acidic (Think Acid Rain) even if the flue did not have other fuels in it. If the soot in it were from wood or oil, it will be even more acidic.

So, A good furnace installer examines the ducts to be sure they will have the correct air flow. And examines the flue to be sure it is suitable for Gas. Unfortunately, when he says "I need another $1000 to fix the ducts and another $500 to line the flue" Many homeowners Say, "you are ripping me off". And the go to old Dudley Doright who slaps in a furnace and ignores the ducts and flue, hoping they can rip you off again later or that you will never know the difference. And, If the Carbon Monoxide had killed you and your family before you noticed the problem, you would not have complained.

Have reputable chimney sweep or gas mechanic check your flue. Ask Maytag if your furnace needs a flue lined with impervious material and how large it should be.

You can check your air flow/temp by putting a thermometer at your return. Take the temp with the unit running, then take the temp and one of the supplies near the furnace. On the label of the furnace it will say what the Temperature rise should be. 30 to 50 degrees or 40 to 75 degrees or whatever. You should be in the middle of that range. If you are near or above the upper end, you still don't have enough air flow. It may also list a max. temp. Clearly you don't want to be above that.

Re: My furnace is running (OT)

#6

Re: My furnace is running (OT)

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>Years ago I was working for a HVAC/ electrical contractor when I needed to replace the furnace in my trailer. I knew how my employer operated (it�s why I left at the first opportunity) and never even considered having the company I worked for do the job. I was there as an electrician, not a furnace installer, so doing it myself was out. I got three bids. Two were within $100 of each other, around $1500, and the third came in at under $800. I didn�t figure the two higher bids were trying to screw me but I thought the lowest one just might be. At half price I imagined a brand Z furnace and installers that were unable to figure out which end of a screwdriver they were supposed to hold. I went with one of the higher bids. The guys showed up on time and had the job finished in less than half a day. Sometime afterward I helped my company�s lead furnace man do pretty much the same job somewhere else and it took a day and a half with some of it being a little on the cobbled side. I was glad I followed my instincts.

There is another local contractor that gets a lot of work because he underbids everyone. He is able to do this for two reasons, shoddy work and unqualified workers. A lady I used to work with had him install a complete HVAC system for her even after the other maintenance man and I had both told her to not even consider him. I was doing some work for her later and looked at the job he�d done. There was a lot of it I thought was sloppy, but what really struck me was the drain from the A coil. He had run a plastic tube to a 1 � PVC drainpipe that was about the same height as the pan under the coil, and connected it by drilling a hole in the pipe and caulking around it. On another job of his that I saw, an opening on top of the furnace that apparently wasn�t needed was closed off by placing a board on top of it.

Although I wasn�t there to hear it personally, here is a good story on my former employer mentioned in the first paragraph.

He ran two one-half inch pipes to something that needed a one inch pipe. When the guy that told me the story told him that wasn�t going to work my ex-boss told him, �two halves make a whole�. I ain�t sure, but I think that in this case two halves don�t even make three-quarters.

Anyway, the moral to the story is that an add in the Yellow Pages is available to anyone who will pay for it. In addition, how long a contractor has been in business is not necessarily an indication of how good of a job he will do for you. Before hiring anyone, do the homework. Ask them for references, but more importantly try to find people that they did work for that are not on the reference list. Also talk to contractors who are not in the business of doing what you want done. Even New York City is comprised of small neighborhoods and the guy who does the plumbing knows the carpenter and the electrician. If they are good at what they do they recognize shoddy work when someone else does it even if it is in a field other than the one they work in. In small towns and rural areas where the problem is most likely to exist, all of the different contractors are even better in tune with the quality of work the �other� guy does.

Re: My furnace is running (OT)

#7

PS, Get a CO detector.

Barry Irby

>

Re: My furnace is running (OT)

#8

Re: My furnace is running (OT)

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Still having some problems with the messageboards but trying to work through them - did want to respond to your problems. As a former furnace installer (several brands mostly sears) (I also serviced many units on an annual basis for some rental unit customers.) - I would contact Maytag directly. If there isn't a minimum of 5 year part AND LABOR warranty on your heat exchanger I would be very surprised. As I remember all the brands I installed had at least that much coverage. No matter how the furnace is installed you should not be able to damage the heat exchanger. ALL gas furnaces prevent any condensation from "dripping" on the heat exchanger. The low efficiency have the vent attached to the front of the furnace with an OPEN bottom If condensate drips from the vent it will fall down the front of the furnace. This is true even with the units with an automatic damper in the flue. The later high efficiency units have a forced vent fan and have a drip leg which accumulates the condensation and allows it to drain. If the "drip leg" doesn't drain, a pressure switch in the vent blower prevents the furnace from operating. If the air flow is inadequate, due to poor ductwork or blocked filters, the high temperature limit will prevent ANY damage to the heat exchanger. NOTE: In my opinion, you would have a red hot heat exchanger and probably a fire before you could damage a normal heat exchanger. In other words the heat exchanger was defective when the furnace was installed - PERIOD. As I said I would contact Maytag directly. It may be the guy who is trying to take you for $500 has already received the labor money from Maytag. I don't believe there is a furnace made that would require me more than 45 minutes to an hour to replace the heat exchanger. - You may want to talk to a couple of other furnace men and take this guy to small claims court.

Re: My furnace is running (OT)

#9

Re: CO detector

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I had posted previously about the furnace problem and recieved good advice on the co detector. I now have a brand new one with battery backup, digital readout, and the Nighthawk technology made by Kidde. Cost about $50. Thanks for the suggestion on checking the variation in temperature between the intake and the output; I will do that.