Re: Staining Alder
Rob Stokes in North Vancouver
>Alder, like birch (and some maples), will generally blotch when you stain it using a regular oil based stain and no pre-conditioner. To get an even finish I'd suggest using a sanding sealer (Zinsser Sealcoat) first or use a gel stain. I'd also strongly suggest practicing - a lot. Alder is a wonderful wood to work with but can be a real pain to finish with coloured stains. I generally use an oil based poly on it and call it a day (I've used water based poly on alder as well but never been happy with the resulting "colour". It's not a warm look).
But even if (when) you do get an even colour using stain, the alder chair will never look like an oak desk. The grain patterns are just too different. Alder's a "bland" wood, even when flat sawn where as oak has magnificent cathedral grain when flat sawn and a completely different look when quarter sawn. As with when repairing a coloured surface, unless you can match it exactly, sometimes it's best to oppose a colour instead.
With this in mind, you may want to re-visit how you'd like this chair and desk to compliment each other. I'd suggest a simple clear finish or...paint. Yup, paint. there's no shame in painting alder and the wood itself takes paint extremely well. If the chair is "big boned", use a light colour and if it's fine boned, use a darker colour. You may be surprised with how it looks if you do this.
Good luck!
Rob