Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

***Messageboard Status Report***

Posts

***Messageboard Status Report***

#1

***Messageboard Status Report***

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Good morning, folks. I appreciate your patience as we try to address all the issues that you have brought to our attention in the past three days regarding the changes to our messageboard format. Your feedback has been very helpful and I thank you for it. I am sorry that some of you have had such strong reactions. Rest assured, we're only doing this in the interests of improving the existing board system. I admit that some of these changes could have been tested more thoroughly in advance, but many of them simply needed to be put out there for you to critique, and you have done that.

We did a detailed survey of all the comments that were offered on the Messages and Turning boards (the Hand Tools comments were in a similar vein) and found some interesting things:

- Of 149 comments, 56 were negative, 42 positive and 51 neutral (primarily advice, without a judgement one way or the other)

- Of the negative comments, 31 were about the speed of the new setup. Interestingly, we made numerous changes on Thursday that improved the speed of loading, primarily of the index page, and after Thursday there were only 2 negative comments about the loading speed. The speed issue is primarily a result of setting the sort-order default to UBB order instead of Mixed order. This change forces our server to go through an additional process each time you reload your message index. We are now planning to revert the default to the Mixed order, and those of you who really like the UBB order (and are willing to wait a little longer for the index page to refresh each time) can choose the UBB order in your preferences page. The google ads and the major sponsor ads in the left column only marginally increase the loading time, but we're continuing to work on them as well.

- There were 11 negative comments about navigating back and forth between messages and the index page. Those of you who didn't use the horizontal frames option before found very little difference. Those who did prefer the frames view before found yourselves having to explore new ways to navigate. The best suggestions offered so far are to open messages in either a new window or a new tab, and then to close that tab or window when you have finished reading a particular thread. I hope that those of you who complained have now had a chance to try one of these methods. (Hold either the SHIFT or CTRL key when clicking a message title.)

- Six negative comments were about the guestbook format, which really had nothing to do with the major changes, but we have removed the red boxes as requested.

- Nine negative comments were in regard to the Google ads overlapping the pictures and/or text in the message view. This only occurs when a picture larger than the available space is included in a message. Since the photo cannot be resized on the fly by our server, it simply dives under the Google text. When this happens, any accompanying text also dives under there. To fix this situation, we are about to introduce another innovation: thumbnailed photos. When you click on a thumbnail, the message frame will dim and the photo will open in a large dedicated window that you can close when you are done viewing the photo. I think you will like this innovation, but, asl ever, your feedback is appreciated.

Among other changes that have been going on largely unannounced here (I am on the road and unable to be in here 24/7 again until next Tuesday), we have "floated" the navigation box so that it stays visible as you scroll down the screen. We will be making a few more minor changes to this feature in coming days.

Later today, you will notice still more changes, including the thumbnail photos that I mentioned above. We have also shortened the long URLs that some of you mentioned, although it will cause all your messages titles to revert to blue (unread) the first time you visit the boards after we upload this change. We have also reformatted the Google ads to make them less obtrusive. Next week, we will address another of your concerns by substituting static "major sponsor" ads for the ones that are currently animated. We have also removed all the browser errors you reported, none of which had to do with tracking cookies.

So, as you can see, your comments are not being taken lightly. My concern is to come up with a new board format that fixes a lot of the problems we used to have with the old framed approach, notably unreadable pages, poor search engine visibility, clumsy navigation, and a host of other drawbacks inherent in this 15 year old software. Sooner or later, as soon as we can find the right package, we will consider moving yet another notch into the 21st century by adopting a PHP-based messageboard system, similar to those used by other forums you might visit. No promises on this, as I still have a lot of problems with those systems.

Meanwhile, I think we have now incorporated solutions to most (if not quite all) the issues you have raised. We couldn't have done it without you. I hope you will continue getting accustomed to the new setup. I think it will grow on you.

Thanks again for your indulgence.

Best,

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#2

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

Gary Camp Bend, Oregon

>What is a PHP-based messageboard system. I rarely, if ever visit other message boards. One of the biggest reasons is I don't like how they feel. At least part of the feel is the format, Well, OK the biggest reasons are this is far and away the best Group of folks there is on the net. That starts at the top. As some others have mentioned I have very little clue what the buzzwords mean, so a bit more explanation of the terms might help me. There have been so god explanations already and thnkas to all who provided those. Onec again Tahnk you Ellis forall your hard work

glc

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#3

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

Howard Norman

>Thanks Ellis, I really feel that the new format is better and with the changes that are currently underway will be even better. Thanks to all of your efforts. This forum continues to be my favorite on the net.

Regards,

Howard

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#4

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Keep going Ellis - the new format is starting to work for me (and I was a former frames user!).

Rob

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#5

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

Rod Peterson -*- Ormond Beach, FL

>Ellis,

All things considered, I'm mostly okay with the new look, particularly since it seems to most closely conform to how I had been using WC (as opposed to the major paradigm shift for the frames users). The sidebar is relatively unobtrusive and gives me ready access to some areas that I didn't have using the “backdoor”.

As a backdoor user, the one thing I got used to was clicking on a message and having it automatically open a new tab, which remained the default message tab from that point on. I was able to switch back and forth from the main index to the individual messages selected (regardless of thread) by moving from one static tab to another. In other words, WoodCentral was a two tab operation for me.

Right now, the system isn't quite as usable to me as it was (although still pretty good), but I wonder if it isn't so close to what I was doing that a relatively simple code change somewhere (like a "target=_blank") might produce the same result as described, which, in my experience, would probably resolve issues of cumbersomeness described by the frames folks.

You haven't driven me away yet (I couldn't stand to be banned from two forums in one week!). Keep up the good work. Look forward to your full time return.

Rod

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#6

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>- There were 11 negative comments about navigating back and forth between messages and the index page. Those of you who didn't use the horizontal frames option before found very little difference. Those who did prefer the frames view before found yourselves having to explore new ways to navigate. The best suggestions offered so far are to open messages in either a new window or a new tab, and then to close that tab or window when you have finished reading a particular thread. I hope that those of you who complained have now had a chance to try one of these methods. (Hold either the SHIFT or CTRL key when clicking a message title.)

Ellis,

I don't mind at all opening a message thread in a new window (right click and select "Open in a New Window" with AOL 7.0, reading all the messages and then closing the new window to return to the index screen. The problem with using that method is that read messages remain blue rather than changing to green, making it tough to distingush the unread from read messages. Anything you can do about that?

Al

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#7

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

Rod Peterson -*- Ormond Beach, FL

>I believe if you "refresh" the index screen all the read threads will show up as blue. I noticed in Firefox, before the WC changes, that the threads would turn blue in the index screen even as I was reading them in the "new" window. But <CTRL> R, or Reload or Refresh should render the index screen up to date.

Rod

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#8

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

Dan Donaldson

>Using Firefox, I get exactly that behavior if I right click on the message and open in either a new or foreground tab. (control-click also works) The whole message thread is in the new tab, I can work through it, then close the tab to be back to the index where I left off.

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#9

Re: ***Thumbnails

Kneale Brownson awaiting snow in N. MI

>Neatoooo on the automatic thumbnailing.

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#10

Hmmm.........

Dan Donaldson

>If I read them in a different tab, they still change color for me. Do they still stay blue even if you refresh the page?

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#11

All Messages Showing Unread

Rick Christopherson

>I just noticed that all messages are showing unread, even the ones I read earlier today.

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#12

I mentioned that this would happen -- only once...

Ellis Walentine, Host

>We implemented a new piece of code today that caused this behavior, Rick. From here on, it should retain the read status.

Ellis

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#13

Re: ***Thumbnails

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>Yep, dig it

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#14

Ellis,You impress me /master of wood& computer

geary from nj

>

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#15

nice! (and some comments) *LINK*

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Very nice, the messages are quite easy to read in the new format!

I very much like the thumbnail pictures.

It may save some mouse movement for a few people if the "press x to close" simply read "click to close" (as in the tool tip). I might even leave that prompt out since I suspect nearly every computer user now is familiar with the function of an "x" in the corner of a window.

I'm not sure it's intended, but I notice a picture is resized to meet the thumbnail width, even it if it much smaller than the thumbnail, as here:

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/messages.pl?frames;read=341886&v1=e2vrt43&v2=festool&v4=Danish+oil&v5=ver2dy7#341886

Also, small bug perhaps: the message in the link below begins the same thread but when clicked, it alone appears for me. To see the entire thread I must click on one of the other messages in that thread. The message I noticed is: 5 inches of Global Warning . . . *PIC* (views: 211) -- Steve Mackay -- Saturday, 24 November 2007, at 3:28 p.m. I haven't checked for others. I'm using Threaded List, Guestbook, UBB Order, IE6, W2K.

JKJ


this link does not show entire thread

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#16

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

John Ballance

>I'll second Rod's observations. It's not a big deal, but having to right click to open the second tab, then close to tab when you're done reading that thread is slightly less convenient and less efficient for me than the old message board (click a message link, and a new tab opens once in Firefox for all subsequent messages displayed). Also, the list of messages in a topic (displayed below the open message) are now being displayed on two short lines, rather than a single line for each message title -- this means much more scrolling to find the next unread message. Can this be changed to show each message title on a single line, like before?

Ellis, thanks for responding to all the comments.

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#17

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

Dan Donaldson

>When you click on a message try holding down the control key when you click. This will open the message in a new tab. Saves the right click and when you are done, just close the tab. You can also switch back and forth between the index and the new tab. I have my mouse programmed to do most of the common stuff. Besides the normal left and right click, I have a button that is the back button, one that puts me in the expo mode (I posted a picture of that earlier), Two that rotate between desktops in opposite directions, one that does a control click, and one that closes the active tab. That makes it pretty easy to navigate around almost any webpage.

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#18

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

Angus Barclay, in New Zealand

>Thank you for all the work you and the rest of the team are putting in to Wood Central. While there have been a few grumbles from some people, you can count me as one of the many who are very pleased with what you're doing to improve Wood Central.

regards

Angus Barclay

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#19

Re: Hmmm.........

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Rod, Dan,

As the Wood Central page was loading this morning I wondered about opening a message in a new window and then refreshing (reloading) the index page. Sure enough the read message change color. Thanks for the help.

AOL,s browser doesn't provide for a new tab, at least in version 7.0.

Al

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#20

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

Mike Baratta

>Ellis,

I like the changes and they are working well for me. Thanks for all the time and passion you put into this site for us. It's a great online community!

Mike

West Chester, PA

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#21

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

Stuart Hough

>Just figured out the right-click thing. It works great! My jury was out for a while, then waited for the inevitable re-reading of the testimony, but I'm fairly pleased now. It is nowhere near as cumbersome as the first few days.

One thing about progress, for any that will listen, is that it always causes pain for some, but in the end, everyone we all can't figure out how we got along witout it!

As Spock said..."the good of the many outweigh the good of the few."

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#22

You've changed my mind...

John E in SC

>Didn't really like the new format at first (actually, I think I still prefer the frames over hitting the back button all the time or opening in a new window, but that's pretty minor), but you've won me over. I was very worried about the speed, but that has definitely been fixed, even with dial up. It may even be faster than before. I really like the thumbnail pics. Overall, it's been a positive change, and the thing that I find most impressive is that Ellis took the time to read / tally all of the comments, and took them to heart!

Thanks,

John

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#23

Nicely done Ellis

Craig

>My only complaint was speed and it is way faster now. It is nice to come to a place where the powers that be listen so much to the little people. We should all remember that this doesn't happen many other places.

Craig

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#24

Ellis Walentine

Duly noted. Thanks

Ellis Walentine

>

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report***

#25

Re: ***Messageboard Status Report*** BONUS

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Last year I bought a relatively expensive wireless keyboard* and mouse to replace a cheaper but very no-name generic unreliable model.

Discovered my new fancy ergonomic mouse has programmable buttons under my thumb. Don't know why I never noticed them before. ;)

Anyhoo, I programmed the larger one for 'ctl' and the smaller one for 'back.'

Hah! Now I log on, press the larger button (programmed for 'ctl'), click on the thread and it opens in a new tab. The cherries tell me what I haven't read yet. When I finish I close the tab and I am back to the index. One-handed operation! Love it!

However, some posts within a thread open only that post and the rest of the thread disappears. Then I need the back button to restore the thread. Sometimes the post is deeper in the hierarchy of the thread and sometimes it is not. Why is that?

Other than that I am happy with the changes and navigation is easy.

*MS 6000. I know. I know. Adding to Bill Gate's millions, but I love the tactile touch of that keyboard and I spend a lot of time at the keyboard.