Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

New tools vs old

Posts

New tools vs old

#1

New tools vs old

Basil Biberdorf

>What's the general consensus on buying old power tools versus new, particularly the larger items (table saws, band saws, etc.)? It seems that many of the older American- and Canadian-made tools command prices rivaling the new ones from the Far East.

Is the older stuff really that much better, or is it sentimental, or...something else?

Re: New tools vs old

#2

Re: New tools vs old

McKay

>Generally, the castings will have better machining, heavier castings, usually a better motor, and smoother 3 belt drive system. The newer machines are very good if they come from a major manufacturer. I would take an original Oliver or Delta over what is on the market any day.

Re: New tools vs old

#3

Re: New tools vs old

David Yoho

>It seems that many of the older American- and Canadian-made tools command prices rivaling the new ones

The prices are a telling sign. "Old iron" is every bit as good, and many times, better than what is available today. It's hard to beat some of the old Rockwell-Delta machines, Walker Turner, etc. If you don't mind tinkering and have the skills to rehab old machinery, they can be a good bargain and provide much satisfaction in knowing you have rock solid equipment.

David

Re: New tools vs old

#4

Re: New tools vs old

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Basil,

The old and new tools are all pretty much of the same basic design. So long as the basic function is not impaired in any way, the old stuff works as well as the new stuff, and has been doing it longer. New stuff has innovations which add to utility. I'd druther have an old iron tool which is "upgradable" with after market accessories. Frequently you can get a wonderful old tool from Craig's list and save a bundle.

George

Re: New tools vs old

#5

Re: New tools vs old

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Old machines may be beefier than new ones, but I believe that for many it is a sentimental thing.

The thing is that in many cases you don't know what you're getting. Kinda like used cars.

Robert Vaughn had a very good article on used machinery in FWW many years ago. In a nutshell, where the machine comes from (home/hobby shop, factory, school system) has great relevance as to the machine's expected general condition. Also, is the machine a known brand, and can parts be purchased to refurbish the machine? Belts and bearings are easy enough to replace, but machine-specific parts can be either very expensive or impossible to find.

Then there's the issue of guards and other safety devices, which may never have been made for a given machine (or have long disappeared), one might want to (and should) retrofit replacements, another expense.

To each his/her own, but IMHO between a '40s Unisaw (in good condition) and let's say a new Powermatic PM2000, for me to buy the Unisaw it would have to be less than half the price of a new saw, considering the cost of getting a decent fence to replace the original Jet-Lock fence, put a decent guard (and a splitter) on, replace belts and bearings as needed, the time spent, etc. And you get no warranty on the old saw...

It's not to say that there aren't some good deals to be made on old machinery, but I personally think that very often it's not worth it.

DC

Re: New tools vs old

#6

Tricky question . . .

Steve Mackay

>I agree with all of the above. While trolling Craftsman the other day for bench sander I noticed, to my horror, the housings are now plastic. Same-same with about everything. I don't doubt the durability of modern plastics I think I prefer a cast iron. On the other hand one must look at re-habing an older machine before you buy it. Can you still get parts etc. Hunting motors and the like turn into a quest while belts, chucks and pullies are a snap. All told, I like old iron . . . it gives me a warm fuzzy feeling.

Re: New tools vs old

#7

Re: New tools vs old

Basil Biberdorf

>To clarify, I'm not really speaking of getting an older piece for a lot less than new, but rather an older piece at somewhere near new prices.

As an example, I see classic Delta/Rockwell 14" band saws selling for $400 or more. (Had a rebuilt one offered to me for $500 earlier this week.) A brand new Grizzly G0555 is currently $449 INCLUDING SHIPPING within the U.S. That includes a 1 HP motor, fence, miter gauge, and ball-bearing guides. The Rikon 10-320 ("non-Deluxe" model with the 1 HP motor, 6 inch cutting height, no fence or miter gauge but with a lovely large table) is $449.99 at the Woodcraft store I visited today.

So, is there any benefit to paying $400 - $500 for a great condition (but still used) saw versus one of these new ones?

Re: New tools vs old

#8

Re: New tools vs old

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Well Basil,

I'd personally be inclined to buy the new saw and fall in love with its extra features and warranty.

George

Re: New tools vs old

#9

Re: New tools vs old

wilbur

>Hi Basil,

I asked exactly this question several months back, when I was trying to decide between a new or used bandsaw. There are some things about the old machinery that current machines can't compete with -- it's just that these are things that don't show up in spec sheets.

This is what I learned after seeing 1940-50's bandsaws up close.

Many parts on the older bandsaws are made to greater thicknesses than current bandsaws. This is not something that will necessarily show up in a spec sheet. For example, a spec sheet will say that the table is, say, 14" x 14" in the case of the Grizzly 0555, but it won't show you that a 1940's bandsaw table will be a heavier duty casting, resulting in a thicker and more reinforced table than the Grizzly. Likewise, in the old bandsaws, the sheet metal used for the bandsaw wheel covers and stand will be thicker, you'll have beefier trunnions on the table, the casting for the frame will be thicker and better reinforced, and in some cases you'll get cast iron bandsaw wheels instead of an aluminum one, and so on. All of this added mass helps to improve the smoothness of the bandsaw when it is running.

As far as the motor goes, there's something about an older motor that seems to make it run better than newer ones of the same HP. My bandsaw motor is only 1/2 HP, but it can do pretty good work, as I'll get to in a bit.

Some of the other extras you point out may not be completely necessary. I don't know how much experience you have with a bandsaw, but when I was shopping for one, I had almost none, and was worried about finding a fence, miter gauge, and ball bearing guides as well if I was to get an older machine. Guess what happened. I've been able to saw 3/32" thick veneers from domestic hardwoods freehand, thanks to a good blade. No fence, and no ball bearing guides. Also, I only have a 1/2 HP motor on my bandsaw.

Whether you get a new bandsaw or old, I'd see what you can do without those items before putting them to use.

As far as the downsides to going with a used older piece of machinery, if you need service, you're going to be pretty much on your own. If you find an old Delta, many of the parts are still available, although they may take some hunting to find them. However, it really doesn't take that much mechanical know-how to get one of these things running. I managed to do that with my bandsaw and lathe, both of which date back to the 1940's, and I'm no mechanical genius. In fact, my day job is being a pediatrician, and my lathe required a teardown of the headstock and spindle, while my bandsaw required disassembly of the lower wheel and axle, and I lived to tell about it.

Finally, if you find a good condition used Delta bandsaw and decide it isn't for you, you'll be able to sell it for pretty much what you paid for it. This won't be the case with buying a new Grizzly or Rikon.

As for me, I started off convinced that I was going to get either a new Delta X5 14" bandsaw or maybe the Powermatic 14", and ended up finding a 16" Walker-Turner bandsaw instead for much less than either of the first two. I just love this thing. I had to do some work to get it into top shape, but I'm very happy that I did.

The best thing to do is to find someone that has a older piece of machinery and look at it up close to see what I'm talking about. In the meantime, my 2 cents would be that if you see an older Delta bandsaw in good shape for $400, go for it.

Hope this helps!

Re: New tools vs old

#10

My Experience is Old is Better

Scott Banbury

>I started my woodworking business with a complement of new professional grade Grizzly and Delta tools. They've served me well and were the most efficient way of fitting out my new shop.

Over the years, I've had the opportunity to add some larger older (1900's-1950's) machines and find that I musch prefer and enjoy working with them. I have an American 36" bandsaw and an American 12" jointer taht wer made in 1907. I also have a 1945 Delta Unisaw and a 1948 20" DeWalt radial arm saw.

All of these older tools are much heavier than modern versions, have quieter and more powerful motors and vibrate much less. These qulities allow me to pay less attention to the machine and more attrention to what I'm machining.

Old tools are like cars in that you need to look for those that have proved themselves and by extension created their own aftermarket parts and tooling markets. They also require more periodic maintenance in regards to lubrication and cleaning due to oiled/greased bearing and open motors.

Someday I would love to have all of my stationary machines replaced with 1950s or older vintage. Of course, this is coming from a guy that has 600,000+ miles on a VW Westfalia and will keep rebuilding a 1995 Toyoya 4x4 truck and a 1996 Subaru wagon until their frames fall apart. ;-)