Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Finishing pine

Posts

Finishing pine

#1

Finishing pine

John E in SC

>I think I've read before about using shellac as a wood conditioner prior to staining pine so it won't be as "blotchy" - is this correct? If so, how is it done? I was thinking of trying a fairly thin coat of shellac prior to staining and seeing how that works, but I thought I'd check with the collective wisdoem of the board before potentially wasting my time. I'm planning on using an oil-based stain, and will probably seal over the top of this with shellac, followed by water-based poly, if any of that matters.

Thanks,

John

(who's sorta getting used to the new format)

Re: Finishing pine

#2

Do you want that "orangy" honey pine?

Chris Knob

>Here's my formula (everyone has one!)that gets raves from customers.

Mix together equal parts of Minwax Puritan pine and Minwax Antique maple gel stain. Flood the piece to be stained with mineral spirits so it is good and wet. While it's still wet, liberally wipe on the staining mix. Repeat the application of stain without the pre-treatment if you want more color but this is usually a single application. Let it dry and top-coat with finish of your choice.

I've tried shellac pre treatments, pecan tinted polys, exotic stain controller applications etc. For convience and results, this method works best for me.

Re: Finishing pine

#3

Re: Finishing pine

David Yoho

>You could just keep it real simple and use a gel stain followed by whatever topcoat you choose.

David

Re: Finishing pine

#4

Agree With Chris and Dave

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Finishing pine

#5

Re: Finishing pine

John Pappas

>When pine is stained you get a color reversal. What that means is that what is naturally lighter in pine absorbs more stain than that part which is naturally darker, so the stained wood is a reverse of what we normally see in pine. Once I learned about this, I can't help but focus on the effect and, I don't particularly like that look.

Jeff Jewitt and others have shown samples of pine finished in this manner. Seal the wood with a thin topcoat. Apply a glaze to add color. Start with a thin coat, let it dry, and apply additional coats if a darker color is desired. No splotching, no color reversal and a nice subtle amount of color.

There are glazes available from finishing supply houses. Any stain can be used as a glaze, but gel stains might work better.

Experiment a bit with this and the other suggestions and see what you like best.

Re: Finishing pine

#6

Re: Finishing pine

geary from nj

>Hey Colonel,It's me again,asking a question,AFTER my impatience got the best of me! I rebuilt/overhauled a large chunk toy built back in the 70's, useing white oak because of it's durability. The original wood used was loplolly yellow pine ,my dad recycled from shipping crates.(don't even begin to know where to find that species after 30 some years) ANYWAY,I stained the monster,and the results are an UGLYYYYYYY match. Is there any hope of getting a better match to this piece now that the oil based Minwax is dried? I wish I'd asked before I did. Geary from NJ

Re: Finishing pine

#7

Re: Finishing pine

Rod Rentz

>Actually the loblolly pine (along with slash pine) is one of the more commonly used pines on tree farms here in south Georgia. You should be able to get replacements at your lumber yard. For finishing purposes the loblolly and slash pines are almost interchangeable. One of the previous posts talked about the "reverse" absorb-rates of the stain and this is very likely with the loblolly pine. Most pines will do this, except maybe the longleaf pine (this is where heart pine comes from) which has much closer growth rings and is harder than the more modern species. Unfortunately this variety is hard to find and expensive. The reason that tree farmers grow the loblolly and slash pines is that they grow to a harvestable size in 20-25 years, where longleaf pines take about 40-45 years.