Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Survey--Sorta

Posts

Survey--Sorta

#1

Survey--Sorta

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>I am making a snowman cut out for a lady friend and am using 1/2" MDF at her request. It measures 32" by 28" and to make it easier to cut I decided to make it in two pieces. This means edge gluing the parts together. Not wanting to trust just glue to hold it together I dug out my plate joiner,(bisquit joiner), and slotted for bisquits and then glued it together. I bought the joiner 10 years ago, when they were the hottest new gizmo on the market, and probably have used it 2 dozen times in all those years. Question- how many of you bought one because you just had to have one and then found it to be a pain to use and just rely on straight glue up now?

Re: Survey--Sorta

#2

Re: Survey--Sorta

Howard Norman

>Count me in the group that bought a biscuit joiner and rarely use it. In fact I can't remember the last time I used it.

Howard

Re: Survey--Sorta

#3

Re: Survey--Sorta

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Ken,

I rarely use mine. I bought it because the ads were so slick! However, I am glad I have it, and I DO use it---sometimes.

George

Re: Survey--Sorta

#4

Ditto

Winnemucca Lynn

>

Re: Survey--Sorta

#5

JL

Re: Survey--Sorta

JL

>When you have to align things, it is great. I use it for aligning 5/4 boards for table tops. I don't use it for aligning 8/4 boards for seats.

Re: Survey--Sorta

#6

Re: Survey--Sorta

Kneale Brownson awaiting snow in N. MI

>I have the PC version that I use more frequently to cut slots for Z-ties for table tops than for biscuits, but still employ for them in some assemblies like attaching face frames. I have the Delta table biscuit joiner that I used to use religiously for glueup alignments but I don't think I've fired it up in three or four years.

Re: Survey--Sorta

#7

Ellis Walentine

I wouldn't be without one

Ellis Walentine

>...but that doesn't mean that I use it for edge gluing, at least not usually. (How's that for a slippery answer?)

I routinely reach for my biscuit joiner for picture frame miters, face frames (where a standard biscuit can fit within the width of the rail member), cabinet doors (ditto), mitered plywood joints, and -- most of all-- case construction.

These tools were made for joining flakeboard/plywood/melamine cabinet components to each other, usually at right angles. That's why the blade is centered 3/8" +/- above the base. The idea is to simply measure to where you want a vertical piece to join to a horizontal piece, lay the vertical piece down with the mating edges adjoining, draw a line and a few centerlines across the width, then biscuit joint on the centerlines. This is a particularly effective way to join cabinets that will be built in because they don't need to rely on traditional through M&T joints and such for structural strength. The room provides the missing structural strength.

Another place biscuits are really great is for aligning the sides of hollow porch posts. That's very hard to do any other way. Edge-to-edge joints are not worthy candidates for biscuit joining. A dead blow mallet is all you really need to coerce adjacent edges into alignment. If your boards are any wackier than that, you'll probably appreciate the three-dimensional nature of the finished product. :-)

Above all, do yourself a favor and build a simple jig for biscuit joining picture frames. A corollary to this is don't try to biscuit narrow miters while holding the piece with your other hand. These tools can do some serious damage if you have a senior moment. (Don't ask my brother how I know this.)

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Survey--Sorta

#8

Re: Survey--Sorta

Jim Moore

>I'm sure we all have tools that fit this catagory. I have the PC model and while I don't use it often, I'm glad I have it when I need it. What frustrates me is when I come across a tool that I forgot I own. Does that mean I now have too many tools?

Re: Survey--Sorta

#9

I think the criteria is worse...

HC Sakman

>Which is:

Not only you forgot you own that tool, but going to the store and buying another one!

Whoever has done that may have some issues which are in need of serious sorting out.

Mark Goodall...aka "Tooljunkie" With a name like this, you're naturally "the" usual suspect Mark. So, have you ever done this? ;-)

Chico...

Re: Survey--Sorta

#10

Per Ellis, I use mine all the time also.

Bri in Mtl

>

Re: Survey--Sorta

#11

Re: Survey--Sorta

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Too many tools? Never!!

But maybe the shop needs cleaning. :)

Re: Survey--Sorta

#12

Re: Survey--Sorta

John McGaw

>I use mine frequently although not for the long-grain to long-grain panel glueups. Well, that isn't quite true. If the joint is one that seems to have a mind of its own I might stick a couple of biscuits in to maintain alignment. But when it comes to building cabinets with melamine-coated particle board or plywood, biscuits are hard to beat. I've also found that it can be really beneficial for building structural elements -- the 18-foot soffit that spans the library downstairs was made using 2X2s and scores of biscuits. It is strong, straight, and perfectly aligned thanks to them.

Re: Survey--Sorta

#13

Re: I wouldn't be without one

Barry Irby

>As is often the case, I agree with Ellis. (And when I don't I usually keep out of it, he's the boss)

I seldom use my PC plate jointer for edge to edge stuff. I sometimes throw in two or three in long pieces to speed up the alignment and clamping to get to the part with the dead blow. But for all those other things, it accels. Its great for putting face frames on case work.

And I just found a new (to me) use for it. Does a good job as a jamb saw cutting off the bottoms of door trim to allow the installation of laminate flooring.

Yes, it spends a lot of time sitting in its case on the shelf, but it still has some Wow Factor when I pull it out.

Re: Survey--Sorta

#14

Alan Young

Mitered Frames

Alan Young

>I don't use the BJ much but it is a handy device for certain situations.

Just last night I wanted to fix a mitered frame to the top of a small bench. I did not want to use splines that showed or nails or dowels or any other method where the joinery showed-the solution was the biscuit joiner..

I do not use the tool for table glue-ups or even face frame glue ups to cabinets.

Alan

Re: Survey--Sorta

#15

Me!

Tony - Memphis

>I thought the concept was great and I guess the talk/marketing got me. I rarely use mine. Don't like it. But, that being said, there are a few times when it is a great solution for a problem joint. Last time I used it was to align some pilasters on a chest I built. Helped out quite a bit. Sure, there were other ways I could have done it, but the biscuit jointer made it quick and easy.

Tony

Re: Survey--Sorta

#16

Re: Me!

lee beeden

>I mainly use mine for attaching face frames.

thanks

Lee

Re: Survey--Sorta

#17

picture?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>Above all, do yourself a favor and build a simple

>jig for biscuit joining picture frames.

Do you have a picture of this jig? I think I know what you mean but it might help to see one.

JKJ

Re: Survey--Sorta

#18

Re: I wouldn't be without one

NickB

>Sad to say, I know to avoid holding narrow workpieces by hand. It was about 7 years ago, and at the time, I couldn't think of a better way to hold the workpiece (of course, sitting in the waiting room at the local ER gave me plenty of time to come up with an alternative). It only took an instant, but my middle and ring fingers on my left hand have ugly, lumpy scars along the line of the distal (furthest out) joint. I've got about 90% sensation back in those finger tips (I don't think it will ever get better than that), and pretty much fully range of motion, but I'll never hold the workpiece for biscuit jointing with my hand again.

Nick

Re: Survey--Sorta

#19

Re: I wouldn't be without one

NickB

>I should have also said that I use mine for mainly for case construction, and it's been getting a reasonable amount of use. I've gone to pocket screws for things like face frames.

Nick

Re: Survey--Sorta

#20

Re: Survey--Sorta

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>I typically use mine to aid in alignment during assembly. I also use biscuits when I knock together quick cabinets for the shop or some other quick and dirty storage application. My method now is to use a combo of a biscuit and pocket hole so I don't even need clamps. The biscuits keep the pocket hole screws from pulling the part a little. After assembly that way, I really don't even need to wait for the glue to dry to put on the face frames and/or doors etc.