Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Belt Sander Recommendations

Posts

Belt Sander Recommendations

#1

Belt Sander Recommendations

Steve Bellner

>I am looking for a belt sander. The primary purpose of the sander will be to repair some water-damaged hardwood flooring that has curled at the edges after I got it dried out. But I would also like to purchase a tool that will get some use in the shop once its primary use is complete. I have a big stack of barnwood, and it would seem prudent to hit the wood with a belt sander before sending it through the planer. And, I would also like a tool that would help me with the process of flattening wide panels.

So my questions are:

1. 3x21 or 4x24?

2. Variable speed or on/off?

I'll leave the manufacturer as an open-ended question. Most of us know who makes good stuff, and who makes junk. But if a particular manufacturer has a feature you find unique, useful, or troublesome, feel free to comment.

Thanks everyone for your continued great advice.

Steve in East Tennessee

Re: Belt Sander Recommendations

#2

Re: Belt Sander Recommendations

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I've had a Ryobi 3x21 in-line for 10 years of trusty service with excellant dust collection using a shop vac. Whatever your buy, I strongly suggest you get an adjustable sanding frame for it. This makes the tool both controlable and precise; a must for panel work unless you're looking for the antique look with digs and lines cut into the surface. As far and your planer plan goes, if you don't have a jointer, you'd better figure on making a carrier sled and shimming your stock; I doubt a belt sander's going to do you much good. Also, before planing barn wood, I'd invest in a small metal detector; will save a lot on planer blades.

Good luck

mm

Re: Belt Sander Recommendations

#3

Re: Belt Sander Recommendations

Steve Bellner

>Thanks Mark. I agree, the availability of a sanding frame is a good suggestion. As far as the barnwood goes, I've already run all of it through a handheld metal detector. Embedded nails were the easy ones. I was amazed how many staples and what looked like the legs of staples or brad nails without heads were just barely below the surface. I would like to "touch up" the surface with the belt sander so I knock off the top layer of dirt and grit before further processing. For the boards I have used so far, I have used a hand scraper and some 60-grit sandpaper. I'm all for using hand tools, but that job will take the wind out of your sails in a hurry! And you're right, the jointer is the first piece of machinery that the wood sees after I get it cleaned up.

This wood is from a barn a friend of mine tore down a couple of years ago. He was going to burn it! As far as we can tell, he thinks the barn was built around 150 years ago.

Steve in East Tennessee.

Re: Belt Sander Recommendations

#4

BTW

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Sander frames are a bit hard to find. The Ryobi's is part No. 6081842, and should cost about $50 if you can find them. I know HD sells Ryobi, but don't know about the frame.

PC used to make a frame for their belters, but that was "pre-acquisition".

Good Luck

Re: Belt Sander Recommendations

#5

Re: Belt Sander Recommendations

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>Whatever brand you choose, get the variable-speed option. The first time you get gerked around by a machine set at top speed with 40-grit, you'll be glad to have the option to run slower. Another factor to look for is balance. The machine should set squarly on it's platen without your assistance.

Re: Belt Sander Recommendations

#6

Re: Belt Sander Recommendations

Larry Clinton

>I bought a Porter Cable 3 X 24 Whisper Variable speed unit a couple of years ago. I found it used often but when needed it is almost indispensable. Although it was pretty expensive, I really like the unit but don't know if they are still made in USA. If not, I wouldn't recommend one. The only thing I added to mine was the graphite slip plate. It did seem to make the sander belt run much cooler. I use mine with the built in dust collection system - which by the way works well in my opinion. I have filled up the bag a few times - don't work well at all then.

Re: Belt Sander Recommendations

#7

Re: Belt Sander Recommendations

Jim Dillon

>Steve,

I've had the Bosch 4x24 for about 7 years and it is holding up fine. It is a real workhorse IMHO. I got it as a tool to first sand hardwood flooring (locust, pine, oak) then use in the shop. For the flooring job, I bought the Bosch sanding frame and it works very well and attaches easily. For shop use, I built a fixture (see below) based on the one in Sandor Nagyszalanczy's book to hold the sander horizontally and have used it a LOT in that capacity. For durable sanding belts, you might want to look at the ceramic coated ones from Klingspor(they are blue in color) in 36 grit. Regarding variable speed, I can't say I have used it much. Several drawbacks are poor dust collection and it is heavy so vertical work would be tiring. Hope this helps.

Jim


img

Re: Belt Sander Recommendations

#8

Re: Belt Sander Recommendations

Kneale Brownson awaiting snow in N. MI

>I've had both 3-inch and 4-inch belt sanders. Much prefer the 4-inch for stability. The 3-inchers like to tip and gouge your panel. I've been running a PC 4-inch for the last 10 years or so. I've worn out two sets of brushes and one switch, and I've had to take the dust port side off a couple times to clean it out, but it's otherwise been a great workhorse. A variable speed would be nice.

Re: Belt Sander Recommendations

#9

Re: Belt Sander Recommendations

del schisler

>i have the PC 3x21 which is loud And the 4x24 Both real good the 4x24 is heavy and sands off wood real quick the 4x24 is quiter other than that both are good

Re: Belt Sander Recommendations

#10

Re: Belt Sander Recommendations

del schisler

>forgot to mention i bought the 4x24 New with case for $89.00 close out at HD couldn't pass that up

Re: Belt Sander Recommendations

#11

Re: Belt Sander Recommendations

NickB

>I've got a 3x21 Bosch vs that I quite like. 3 things I like about it: 1)flat top, so you can put it on your bench to sand small workpieces, 2)flush sides for getting into tight spaces, and 3) light weight-you can use it one handed without too much trouble.

I'd second the advice on getting vs-that couple of times you really need it, you really need it.

Hope this helps,

Nick