Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

router table inserts

Posts

router table inserts

#1

router table inserts

mike paulson

>Hey, I am going to build a new router table, but the insert is a question for me. Aluminum, polycarbonate... which is better?

Any thoughts would be appreciated.

Mike Paulson

Re: router table inserts

#2

Re: router table inserts

Bob Hicks

>Mike:

In May of this year, after doing the SAME research as yourself,I built an awesome router table from plans in Woodshop Magazine. The router insert/plate combo I purchased is made from polycarbonate -- my choice from experience. I previously owned a purchased router table, made entirely from aluminum. The problem I had, after owning it for about 6 years, Even if your careful, it can scratch easily and being a soft metal, some scratches in the "routing path" area were actually deep enough to abraise some hardwoods (ie; maple or cherry). I use the table quite regularly with my PC 690 series 3-1/4 hp router as the dedicated workhorse and the scratches in the poly are minimal. It's definitely tougher going than aluminum. Thus, my bang for the buck choice is polycarbonate. I ordered the top, with assorted inserts, guide pin, and clear instructions from MLCS Woodworking (mlcs.com)for a mere 34 bucks. Shipping is "free" in the U.S. with any of their products and their prices/quality is unbeatable in my opinion. I buy all of my router bits/accessories from them and have ordered several times even before my polytop purchase -- with satisfaction. The kit they offer fits just about any router out there. (and they do have a toll free tech-line, minimal wait time, real voices who actually help you with a problem.)They do offer a template to rout out the top for 15 bucks, but I passed. I simply made my own from a 1/4" sheet of masonite and made the outside dimensions exactly 1/2" larger than the insert measurement. I then used a 1/2" straight bit and a guide bushing to create the needed recess and cut out the final center portion with a jig saw. By the way,the recess depth is "somewhat" forgiving with this insert because the the top comes with allen screw levelers. It's really a reasonably-priced outfit -- and if you still want the aluminum, I believe they offer the same kit in that material-- for more money though.... Hope this helps.

Re: router table inserts

#3

Re: router table inserts

Bruce, a MN galoot

>I put a phenolic resin laminate plate in my router table. It's very stiff, machines well, etc. Have had no problems, going on about 10 years. The only slight difficulty is that it is very hard on tools.

Bruce

Re: router table inserts

#4

Re: router table inserts

john lucas

>I agree with Bruce. I tried several alternatives and finally purchased some laminate from Highland Hardware in Atlanta. It is so much stiffer that other things I tried and it's practically indestructable. I've been using mine for 10 to 12 years and it looks newer than the table which is cover with formica.

Re: router table inserts

#5

Re: router table inserts

Bill White

>You did not tell us what router you plan to use. I have a PC 690 in my shop-made table, and used the Lee Valley round phenolic insert. Least expensive kit I could find, and it has served me well for 8 years. Full and concise instructions. I got it set correctly the first try (that'a a plus in my mind). Check it out.

Bill

Re: router table inserts

#6

Re: router table inserts

David Charters (Durham, NC)

>That's a great deal, but the site is www.mlcswoodworking.com the one you listed was kind of a fake site.

Might have to build a new router table knowing that the plate is so cheap!

dc

Re: router table inserts

#7

Coupla thoughts…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>I've long liked the Rousseau insert (RM3509, I think, and which I believe is polycarbonate—plastic of some sort, anyway), particularly as it has removable inserts to clear various sized bits. The smallest insert is also rabbeted to the industry standard Porter-Cable sized bushings/template guides. I have three of them—each permanently attached to one of my stable of table routers. Someone in another group once claimed that they sag, but I had my router table stored for over five years with one of my Hitachi M12Vs hanging from its Rousseau and it wasn't any less flat when it came out of storage than it was when it went in.

Pat Warner and I once had a spirited debate over on the wreck (rec.woodworking newsgroup on usenet) regarding table routing. His position is that insert shouldn't be used at all—that the router should be attached directly to the table. In many operations, he may be right. However, if you cut deep, use bits with a >1" or so diameter, or need to multitask your router, a removable insert is a more than acceptable compromise. In fact, it's probably the defacto standard arrangement.

Regardless of what you choose, when it comes time to cut a hole in your top to accommodate it, you are assured of an easy job and a good fit if you follow the instructions in an article I wrote on the subject cleverly titled How to Cut a Snug Fitting Hole in Your Table Top for Your Router Insert right here in the Articles section of WoodCentral.

Rod

Re: router table inserts

#8

Re: Pat's right about a lot, but...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>When you're using a plunge router, like my big Freud, it's easier to get to the router, when you can pull it out of the table from the top. A fixed base router, with a base, may be different.

And, to the OP's first responder: MY PC 690 comes no where close to 3+ hp. I like it anyway.

Re: router table inserts

#9

I agree

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I have the Rousseau insert (RM3509) insert as well and really like it. My Freud FT 2000 hangs on it all the time and is hasn't sagged yet (over 4 years) I like the removeable insert feature and adaptability to the Freud brass inserts.

I tried a 1/4" piece of lexan and it sagged under the weight of my router. I also like being able to take the router out of the tble so I don't have to stand on my head while changing bits and making adjustments.

Lee

Re: router table inserts

#10

Re: Coupla thoughts�

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Mike,

I also use the Rousseau plate in my table. I have it drilled out to accept both my P+C 690 and P+C 7518 routers. I've had it in use for three years and it doesn't sag. It comes equipped with snuggers to insure a tight fit, and also a starting pin for small stuff. Its a good plate.

George

Re: router table inserts

#11

Bit opening reducers

Bill Hylton

>The fact that you mount a router directly to the tabletop--without a mounting plate or insert plate--doesn't mean you have to work with a fixed-size opening for the bit. I built a table with a 3/4" MDF tabletop (supported by an edge frame). A 2 hp router is mounted directly to the tabletop. I reamed out the bit opening with a router bit approximately 2" diameter, then routed a 1/8" wide, 1/4" deep rabbet around the opening. I've got a selection of 1/4" MDF inserts to tailor the opening to the bit in use.

Bill


img

Re: router table inserts

#12

Another vote for the Rousseau insert .

Jim Dillon

>

Re: router table inserts

#13

Direct-mounted plunge router...

Bill Hylton

>Okay, okay, this router isn't mounted directly to the tabletop, but I think it makes the point. If you hinge the tabletop so you can tilt it up, the router is held at a very convenient height and attitude for changing bits. This plunge router is fitted with a crank from Woodhaven that winds the motor up and down the plunge posts. I haven't removed this router from the table in a couple of years.

Bill


img

Re: router table inserts

#14

Re: If you love it, that's great

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I'd still rather pull mine up out of the table and work on reloading the bit, and setting the depth of cut...

Re: router table inserts

#15

Re: router table inserts

Chuck Lenz

>I bought a Woodpeckers aluminum insert with the ring set. I did alot of searching before I bought it, and felt it was the most solid, less prone to warp plate out there. The locking ring system is another thing I like.