Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Plank floor- rosin paper underlayment necessary?

Posts

Plank floor- rosin paper underlayment necessary?

#1

Plank floor- rosin paper underlayment necessary?

gd

>I am laying a random width 3/4" hemlock plank floor over an OSB subfloor. The board widths range from 8-12" and will be face nailed to the subfloor. Is it necessary to use a rosin paper underlayment?

I have heard the claim that the rosin acts as a vapor barrier, but in my case that is unnecessary as this installation is on the 2nd floor (in addition, the subfloor has been painted with porch floor paint).

Another reason I have heard is that it eliminates squeaks due to wood/wood contact... I guess that might be a good reason although I wonder if the fact that the floor was painted eliminates the direct wood contact.

Your comments are welcome. Thank you.

Re: Plank floor- rosin paper underlayment necessary?

#2

Re: Plank floor- rosin paper underlayment necessar

Barry Irby

>This is my personal opinion, YMMV

I believe putting paper under the flooring came from the days of board subfloors. It was put down as and air barrier. To keep the wind from blowing through. It may have been thought that it kept dampness out as well, but this was unlikely to have been effective as neither of them is impermeable or vapor proof.

Floors squeak because something moves. Either the edges of the flooring are rubbing together or the flooring is rubbing on the nails or fasteners, chirping. I don't see how adding either rosin paper or felt could do anything to make the floor move less and in fact it may provide a cushion allowing it to move more.

Wider flooring, no matter the species is more likely to squeak than narrower flooring. WE (now) think wide flooring is elegant and desirable. In colonial days THEY thought narrow flooring was the cat's meow. They knew as much about wood as we do now and knew that it would squeak if it moved. Narrow boards were tedious and difficult to make, but easy to nail down securely and the shrinkage was divided down into smaller increments because the board were smaller. Wider boards were about as difficult to make as they had huge trees so big boards were the plywood of the day, but wide boards shrink more and the cracks are wider. Also, if you nail the edges, there are more nails per square foot with narrow boards than wide ones. If you nailed a 2 1/4"board every 8", you would have to nail a ten inch board every 2" to get the same number of nails per square foot of floor. If you nail it every 2" the edge will split off and fail.

So it is my opinion you do not need the paper in your circumstances. I have narrow oak flooring I installed with staples about ten years ago without paper under it and don't have a single squeak.

You can get more information form sites like the National Oak Flooring Manufacturers Association (NOFMA) (I think). There are several such groups. Google them to get the official info on this.

Re: Plank floor- rosin paper underlayment necessary?

#3

Re: Plank floor- rosin paper underlayment necessar

Larry Clinton

>For what it's worth, I built a home in about 1963. This was conventional construction in that time (1 X 12 X 3/4 diagonal fir sub-floor) and hardwood flooring (oak). The gentleman that helped me construct the house was a retired pattern-maker for a major railroad. He stated the rosin paper would prevent the squeaking over the years. The rosin in his opinion added "lubrication" allowing movement without squeaks. As the cost is very minimal, I installed the rosin paper. Floors had NO squeaks after installation. I can't tell you how long it worked as due to a subsequent divorce, I only lived there a couple years. I do believe if the occasion arose again I would use the paper.

Re: Plank floor- rosin paper underlayment necessary?

#4

Re: Plank floor- rosin paper underlayment necessar

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>gd,

In my limited experience, floor squeeks are almost always caused by the flooring and subfloor moving up and down on the nails. My house was built is '86 by visually impaired amputees whose medication was out of adjustment. The floors, whether wood or tile, play a Japanese symphony such that I can tell the approximate weight and location of anybody in the house just from the noise; except for those floors that I have REPLACED. When I did so, as many of the old subfloor nails as possible were pulled and repaced with screws every 16". Those floor sections are now dead quiet. The only place I used membrane was under the ceramic tile to isolate that floor from cracking.

I suggest you forego the paper as unnecessary, but put some work into your subfloor by screwing it down to prevent any lift. I'd also be inclined to rough up that painted surface with some course paper; if nothing else it will allow the subfloor wood the "breath" more naturally. While you've chosen to face-nail the planks, I suggest you angle your fasteners off of vertical to reduce up/down movement along the nail shafts that will cause squeeks.

As Barry said, YMMV

mm

Re: Plank floor- rosin paper underlayment necessary?

#5

Re: Plank floor- rosin paper underlayment necessar

Andy Halterman: Don't taze me bro

>15# felt would be a better choice for an underlayment. It has better vapor retarding capabilities than rosin paper. (neither of them is a barrier) There is also a newer product out that is a wood flooring specific unerlayment. I haven't used it yet so I can't comment on how it works but it's out there.

How about some pics when you are done?

Andy Halterman

Got the crew nailing down some antique pinus palustris in Hendersonville, NC�