Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

how do I fix this?

Posts

how do I fix this?

#1

how do I fix this?

lee beeden

>Ok so I have built 10 of these to sell at a local craft fair, they are lap desks for kids. I brought them in from the shop this morning and all the tops have warped.arghhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!The tops are about 7/16 thick...made of Birch. Is there anything I can do?

Any suggestions would be appreciated.

Lee


img

Re: how do I fix this?

#2

pic 2 

lee beeden

>


img

Re: how do I fix this?

#3

Re: pic 3 

lee beeden

>


img

Re: how do I fix this?

#4

Re: pic 2

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Lee,

Can you glue or screw a cleat to the underside top and bottom of the desk lid? It may draw it straight and keep it stable.

George

Re: how do I fix this?

#5

Re: pic 2

lee beeden

>I thought about that George, however there isn't a lot of room underneath as it is, I would be loosing valuable storage space.

How thick should the cleat be?

Lee

Re: how do I fix this?

#6

Re: pic 2

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>I just looked at it again, Lee. I guess you are warped along the sides to the desk lids. Why not screw cleats there? It looks like the cross grain situation may preclude gluing.

George

Re: how do I fix this?

#7

Hey Lee

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>You have some depth to work with, but I can't tell how much. I would "write" off a small amount of storage space in favor of cleats. How big thecleats? I dunno, maybe an inch. Experiment. Use a central screw to draw the top flat, and put a little glue there. Let the cleat ends be secured with screws alone. Before all that, remove the tops and try to get the warp out. Once flat, use the cleats.

George

Re: how do I fix this?

#8

Re: how do I fix this?

Ron Hildreth

>Lee,

Do you think it's humidity or another form of moisture that caused it? If so;

Let it be for a couple days without doing anything! After that, you might not have to do anything, or very minimal. I had a wide poplar board I left laying in the garage, so my wife's car would straddle it. It rained, and therefore water dripped off the car and onto this board. It caused it to warp terribly, with the grain. I took it into the basement where it's dry, and a few days later it had lost the surface moisture and had nearly straightened itself back out. Didn't take much to fix it after that, and I was again a happy camper!

I'd be patient, and see what happens.

Ron in Iowa

Re: how do I fix this?

#9

Solid wood love it or leave it

Chris Knob

>Cleats are probably the best solution but you are going to loose desk space. One solution is to run cross grain dados where you intend to attach the cleats so you can sink the cleats a little.

Re: how do I fix this?

#10

Or

Larry Marker in Alabama

>if you don't want to use cleats, you could shorten the lids and use breadboard edges.

Larry

Re: how do I fix this?

#11

JL

Re: 2nd Larry's suggestion...

JL

>Most of the lap desks I have seen have had breadboard ends to prevent this from occurring. You could get some nice maple.

Re: how do I fix this?

#12

Are they unfinished?

Warren in Lancaster, Pa

>It looks as though you brought them into an area of lower humidity (your heated house), and the difference in humidity between the inside of the case and the outside of the case caused the warping. A finish on the lid would have slowed this drying considerably and your warping would be much less.

If you leave the case open tonight so that the inside of the lid dries also, the situation should improve somewhat. Tomorrow you might take the lid off and dampen the outer (concave) side and lay it on a table damp side down to make it curl the other way. Check on it periodically.

Generally when we work with thin stuff it is good to get it glued up or finished right away. If you cannot do this, at least let air get to both sides.

Re: how do I fix this?

#13

Re: Are they unfinished?

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Warren nailed it and please don't use cleats! At least not now, there's no need to force things. Open the lids and wait a few days and as Warren suggested, you can wipe the top surface with a damp cloth to hasten the moisture content equalization.

What's happened is that the top "skin" of the piece was exposed to a lower humidity environment than the lower "skin" was once you completed assembly. The outer skin has shrunk in comparison to the inner one which means the actual measurement across the top is less than when you started. The wood is attempting to equalize now, and because the lid is closed the environment inside the box will not allow the humidity (escaping moisture from all the internal "skins" of all the pieces) to escape so the inside skins stay at their previous moisture content. The only thing the wood can do is react and you see this occurring in the form of a warp.

Did you let the stock rest n the shop for a few weeks before you used it?

I built a few chess boards a while back where the board itself is a lid to a box (http://www.robswoodworking.com/images/chess.jpg) the lids cupped quite a bit for the first year and even now, when the seasons change I'll leave the lid open for a few days to flatten it. And this occurs with a good finish (poly).

Good luck and don't worry - it's reversible!

Rob

Re: how do I fix this?

#14

Why not route a groove

Dustmaker Mike

>in the underside of the lid use a different color wood to inlay in it then glue and screw it down. You would not loose the storage then.

Just passing a thought

Re: how do I fix this?

#15

Re: how do I fix this?

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>If they were mine, I would remove the lid and route sliding dovetail slots across the grain on the under side not quite to exposed edge. Make a dovetailed rib to slide into the slots so that half the height of the rib is in the slot and the other half sticks out. Use at least two ribs about 1/4 of the distance in from each edge. I would use the same wood as the top and only glue the blind end on about the first inch or so of length. It should straighten out the top and look nice too. Round over the exposed edges of the rib if you want.

Also if a kid should stand on the lid it won't be as likely to crack either.

Lee

Re: how do I fix this?

#16

Thanks for all your responses.........

lee beeden

>they are almost completely flat. I wet the top sides with a damp cloth and left the lids open, its been two days now. Two of them are still a little more then I would like but I think I can live with them.

If I finish them equally on both sides they shouldn't warp any further.....right?

Thanks for all your help.

Lee

Re: how do I fix this?

#17

Finish on 2 sides

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Finishing on two sides is a good practice. Yes there are lots of old pieces with only finish on the outside that are 100 years old. Still I like to put the same amout of layers of finish on all sides and inside the items I make. It takes a bit more time and costs a bit more, but it is cheap insurance against most warping.

Re: how do I fix this?

#18

Re: Thanks for all your responses.........

Warren in Lancaster, Pa

>In traditional work the insides are left unfinished. The concept of finishing both sides is a 20th century idea- even factory furniture made 50 years ago usually was unfinished on the inside. For a table where the bottom is exposed to the air as much as the top, finishing on both sides is a good idea. However, as your experience of the last several days shows, the outside surface is much more vulnerable to humidity changes than the inside and finish on the inside is not really necessary.