Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Negative charge to prevent rust corrosion? *LINK*

Posts

Negative charge to prevent rust corrosion? *LINK*

#1

Negative charge to prevent rust corrosion? *LINK*

Ron Hildreth

>Anyone familiar with this technology of wiring an electrostatic negative charge through something that's metal, preventing corrosion, such as an automobile or a table saw? I ran across a web site of a company called "Counter-Act", located in Australia. They manufacture many different sizes, and advertise on their web site of having systems for everything from cars to the huge coal mine dump trucks. Wonder if this type of system could be used on our woodworking machines, especially you guys who have your shops in garages close to the coasts where salt in the air and high humidity is a fact of life?

Here's a link that explains it's function;

Thoughts?

Ron in Iowa


Counter-Act

Re: Negative charge to prevent rust corrosion? *LINK*

#2

My gut reaction....

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>My first impression after reading through their website was:

Wasn't there something really similar that used magnets to increase a car's gas mileage?

That's just the impression I got from their website. The only think missing was the "As Seen On TV" red logo in the top right of the screen.

There may be some scientific validity of their product and claims, but I sure don't get that from their website.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Negative charge to prevent rust corrosion? *LINK*

#3

I have my doubts

Garrett in Victoria

>As a salt-water boater, I'm familiar with galvanic corrosion which is caused by the leakage of stray electric current into the sea from a boat or boats in the marina. Modern salt-water vessels have all their immersed metals centrally grounded. Stray current in the water goes to that ground and attacks and erodes the "least noble" of the grounded metals. Hence, salt-water boats have 'sacrificial' zinc plates at strategic locations, because zinc is right at the bottom of the nobility scale. I replace mine annually, but in some marinas that are "hot", people replace much more often or find their bronze props and seacocks disappearing. In a worst case scenario, a seacock fails and the boat sinks. Another defence is the installation of a 'galvanic isolater', a solid state device that recognizes tiny current flows and effectively opens the circuit to prevent current flow.

Rust is the chemical combination of oxygen and iron to produce iron oxide. Even though the process involves the combination of electrons and protons, I simply cannot see how an electronic device could prevent this chemical reaction.

Cheers, Garrett

Re: Negative charge to prevent rust corrosion? *LINK*

#4

some basis in fact

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If you have a ship floating in sea water and stick an anode in the water and polarize the ship with the same polarity used for derusting iron either by using a zinc anode or a power supply, corrosion of the ship will be retarded, if not eliminated. How one achieves this same principal with a table saw sitting in the air (a non conductor) is not obvious to me. I think it is bogus

Re: Negative charge to prevent rust corrosion? *LINK*

#5

rusting is the same process as boats dissolving

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>When iron rusts the oxygen does not directly combine with the iron. In fact batteries are established, often on the micro scale where the iron gives up electrons (and dissolves) which flow through the conducting metal to some other spot on the metal where they combine with oxygen. There must be a conducting path between these spots on the surface and this conductivity is provided by water. Salt water in your case, but adsorbed water in the case of a saw in the garage. Which is why iron does not rust in a dry atmosphere or when it has a layer of oil or paint on it.

In the case of your boat a current is provided that is the opposite of the "battery" current that would cause dissolving, and the iron or bronze does not dissolve. Works for boats in salt water but I don't see how to accomplish the same task in air to stop rusting table saws or cars.

Re: Negative charge to prevent rust corrosion? *LINK*

#6

Re: Negative charge to prevent rust corrosion?

Barry Irby

>It is my understanding that the highway Dept. is using small solar panels to create current to charge batteries to provide current to protect the steel in bridges from corrosion. I do not KNOW this to be true, or even if it works, but I thought they were trying it.

Anodes are used as mentioned by others in boats and also in things like water heaters. but again, my impression is that they only work int he presence of water. Not sure they would work at all in air, even humid air.

The combination of two different metals does indeed create a small electric charge similar to that in a battery, but tiny. It may be possible to reverse the potential of that current and protect steel. Think of electroplating. Metal molecules are moved around by electric current. Not hard to believe oxidation could be affected.

OTOH, still sounds like snake oil to me.

Re: Negative charge to prevent rust corrosion? *LINK*

#7

Jesper, Denmark

If it smells like snake oil.......

Jesper, Denmark

>Sounds like snake oil, walks like snake oil, sells like snake oil, it probably is - snake oil.

Re: Negative charge to prevent rust corrosion? *LINK*

#8

Re: Negative charge to prevent rust corrosion? *LINK*

Roy Anderson

>I don't know anything about this company's product, but cathodic protection is a real thing, either using a sacrificial anode or an impressed current. Used a lot in the oil and natural gas pipeline industry.

See attached.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cathodic_protection

Re: Negative charge to prevent rust corrosion? *LINK*

#9

Re: Negative charge to prevent rust corrosion?

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>It's been a long time since I had chemistry, but I think we are talking apples and oranges here. The corrosion that occurs in salt water and even on highways and bridges is galvanic. The process of rust forming on a table saw is oxidation. Even though the two reactions involve electrons at the atomic level, I don't think they are the same. Oxidation doesn't require an electrolite to take place. If you could remove the oxygen from the air in your shop then rust would be virtually eliminated despite the humidity; however, it does get a bit harder to actually use the equipment. The oils waxes and paint on out saws creates a barrier that prevents or at least slows down teh exposure of the surface to oxigen.

The auotmotive industry still has not figured out (maybe they have) that mixing aluminum, brass and steel components on a car that will get wet and in many cases see exposure to road salt becomes a battery on wheels whenever it gets wet.

Lee

Re: Negative charge to prevent rust corrosion? *LINK*

#10

not correct- corrosion theory explained

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The generally accepted mechanism for corrosion is indeed galvanic, that is, corrosion occurs because the metal involved can establish the equivalent of short circuited batteries on its surface. The metal, say iron, looses electrons and dissolves and at some other part of the metal these electrons combine with something else, usually water, oxygen or hydrogen ion. The surface of the metal must transport ions for corrosion to occur (to complete the circuit, like the water in the car battery) and this is accomplished by a layer of water at the surface which may or may not be visible to the naked eye.

It is easy to see that this mechanism is true. Iron does not rust in Arizona. (I have an otherwise biodegradable 1960 AZ Chevy truck bed-trailer to prove it). Clearly Arizona has the same amount of oxygen as Florida, yet the outdoor corrosion rate is vastly different between these places as a result of humidity. Yes, iron in AZ will acquire a few atom deep layer of oxide by direct combination with oxygen but this reaction soon stops and the iron does not rust further because there is not water at the surface to conduct ions. In a damp shop iron rusts overnight and the corrosion continues so long as the environment is damp enough to enable the corrosion cells to function.

Surface coatings work not because they exclude oxygen. Most of the coatings are poor oxygen barriers. In fact on a painted surface it is the metal UNDER the paint that corrodes when the continuity of the paint filmis breached by a chip that exposes bare metal. The bare metal (cathode) is exposed to oxygen that accepts the electrons from the dissolving iron beneath the paint(anode). Water enables the circuit to be completed. It is this sort of corrosion that destroys cars, not the fact that there is a brass fitting somewhere.

Re: Negative charge to prevent rust corrosion? *LINK*

#11

Jeeze, thought it was like cheese

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I just thought rust grew on metal just like moss grows on rocks and trees, algea grows in the seas, and mold grows on cheese. ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Negative charge to prevent rust corrosion? *LINK*

#12

There are several approaches to rust prevention.

Forrest Addy

>There are several approaches to rust prevention.

Lower temperature AND humidity.

Surface passivation

Barrier coatings

Active corrosion inhibitors

Sacrificial metals (zinc galvanizing

Prevention of condensaton.

Lower local enviromental temperature AND humidity may be energy intensive because it involves AC or at least dehumidification. This is the most comfortable and intrusive to the home shop worker. If the shop area is sealed up and a mechanical refrigeration dehumidifier employed rust on power tools can be made a dim memory. Dessicant wirk only so long as they are recharged and replentished as needed. Their most practical use is when the machine is stored in a heat welded 100% sealed envelope. Their application in an open shop is all but futile. You need dessicant container big as hay bales to make a dent in the humidity profile of the average home garage workshop.

Surface passivation is not a viable option for the home shop and it doesn't have lasting effect on cast iron. Briefly it involves a chemical treatment that renders the metal surface to a Ph that prevents oxygen. When chemically cleaned iron castings are dunked in a hot caustic at the very end and dried quickly they may not rust for weeks. Can't do that with an assembled table saw.

Barrier coatings like waxes, oils, and preservatives have varying effect. Most general purpose waxes are nearly useless for preventing rust in a humid environment particularly in a marine coastal climate. Oils can be very effective and preventing rust but are not welcome on woodworking machinery table because it has to be cleaned off before the machine can be used. Preservative come in several guises, some more effective than others. A home shop owner should experiment to see what works best for his environment.

Active corrosion inhibitors like vapor phase impregnated paper works only if the machine is sealed off in an impervious envelope. The inhibitor goodies soon disperse in open air and the peper they were once impregnated in beccomes just paper.

Sacrificial metals (zinc galvanizing) not practical in the home shop. Neither is cathodinc protection suggested by the article referred to in the original post - but there may be some wrinkle.

Prevention of condensaton on the machinery not in active use is simply sccomplished by slightly warming from underneath and covering with a breathable fabric like an old blanket. Condensation and consequent corrosion can all but be prevented. You do have to remove the covers and the heaters etc when you want to work but this is a small price.

Boeshield is popular but it doesn't last very long in the Pacific Northwest so I don't use it. I use to use dehumidifiers but I had trouble with them icing up in cool weather. Now I blanket my machinery and use gentle heat from a light bulb. With the overhead lights off my shop looks like an elve's village. Works good and it's simple.

If I have to store a machine for some time I spray all bare metal with LPS3. While its a minor pain to remove it's very effective and works for years in open shelter.

What works for your particular climate and shop conditions is variable. A Montanan in a drafty home shop has little problem with rust and can get by with wax alone all winter but someone on the east coast of Florida has to resort to heroic efforts to contol rust from day to day.

Re: Negative charge to prevent rust corrosion? *LINK*

#13

Re: Negative charge to prevent rust corrosion?

Bill in IN

>Check here. Everything known about cathodic protection of just about naything

Re: Negative charge to prevent rust corrosion? *LINK*

#14

everything except the link, that is... *LINK*

Bill in IN

>http://www.nace.org/nace/index.asp


link