Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Shock-collar for pooches, OT

Posts

Shock-collar for pooches, OT

#1

Dale Lenz

Shock-collar for pooches, OT

Dale Lenz

>Been wanting, thinking about get a shock-collar for my dog, mainly for training the dog not to go outside certain boundaries. Don't think the anchor pin things would work on my property to many corners and ends and outs. Would like to hear from folks that have tried them and the results, brands, model# etc.

TIA

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

#2

I need to wear one at meal times.

Forrest Addy

>

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

#3

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

john lucas

>I bought contain-a-pet. It was the perfect solution for me. Fences were simply too expensive. The people who installed it were nice and did a good job but I have not been able to get in touch with them again to buy batteries etc. Fortunately I simply go to radio shack and buy 2 batteries and put them together with tape.

The people at their headquarters are good to deal with. I had a problem where the fence stopped working. I suspected the neighbors dog had dug through it and I was right. It was very easy to fix. The headquarters people helped by giving me the proper instructions on fixing the wire to keep it waterproof.

Follow the training method in their book, not what the installers tell you. The training method in the book is less traumatic for the dog and works extremely well.

With the collar on my dog will not leave the yard. It's now been about a year and I can let her out without the collar most of the time. Every once in a while she will go across the fence when she doesn't have the collar on but most of the time stays in the yard.

The downsides. First is that it isn't buried deep. maybe 2 to 3 inches average. So it is important to know where it's buried and don't do anything stupid in those areas. My meighbors dog was digging for moles and dug through mine. I don't now if you could go deeper and be OK. I paid to have it installed and it was worth it.

It doesn't keep other animals out. This is good and bad. It's bad because other dogs, wolfes, etc can get at your animal. It works out great for me because when the neighbors dogs are out they can come over and play with mine. That reduces the problem of my dog barking at them trying to get them to come over. She will not leave the yard even when running full speed while playing with them.

The power can go off due to power outages or broken line. If the dog is well trained they won't go near the fence so they don't know it's off. The field isn't powerful enough to reach through cars so if I forget to take the collar off and we go for a ride it's not problem.

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

#4

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>We have an Innotek system and it has worked quite well for our Brittany. He no goes most of the time now without the collar and still respects the boundaries. The only way he will cross the boundaries is on a leash with us. He won't chase a ball, birds, the cat or other dogs across the line. Installation was simple. I fenced over an acre in three evenings of work (1 to 1-1/2 hours per night). I would not recommend their contain and train remote control which is the system I have if you want to train the dog off leash off property. The remote doesn't go nearly the distance advertised and it eats batteries. Otherwise their system is good. Their zones transmitters work great for indoor areas as well.

Note: Your electronic fence won't keep other animals out.

Lee

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

#5

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

Barry Irby

>I had/have an Invisible Fence brand one at my property. I just have a rectangular lot, so that part was pretty straight forward. Worked well keeping the dog in the yard. A not so funny story. My wife told me "I don't understand, the dog used to love to ride in the car, now she won't go and when I load her up and take her, she yipes and howls." I asked her if she was taking the collar off. Somehow it never occurred to her it would work in the car too. After that, if we took the dog's collar off, she went and got in the car.

With a different dog, I put the wire inside the house and "fenced" off most of the house so the dog could not go into any room except the kitchen, breakfast room, hall and our bedroom. Made the dog mad. About six months alter she figured out the batteries were dead and went in the living room and took a huge poop in the middle of the floor. When I found her, she was standing beside it as if she were proud and had really shown me a thing or two. I took the collar and put fresh batteries in it. She hung her head and went back to her bed and laid down. From then one she was no longer a Cocker, she was a Crapper Spaniel.

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

#6

Dale Lenz

Re: Actually....

Dale Lenz

>I'm looking at the hand held device to buzz Fido, if need be. Anyone tried one of those. Once again make and model. How did this work after taking the shock-collar off for awhile.

Thanks for the past responses and for any future ones. Dale

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

#7

Re: Actually....

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hey Dale,

I just saw a unique approach to the handheld. When you push the button the collar sprays something strong smelling in front of the dog's nose. Supposed to be more humane than the shock collar.

We have the brochure here someplace. I'll look for it if you want.

Gary

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

#8

Re: Actually....

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Dale,

I live on a large property in a rural area. I never let my dogs out without supervision but still lost one dog which ran off chasing a deer. I invested in shock training collars. The first I bought (~$100, off the shelf at Walmart) was practically worthless at the distance I needed. I replaced it with a professional unit made to use with two dogs at once. I believe it has an advertised range of 1000 yards which I didn't measure but it will certainly stop a dog running out of sight in the woods. It's a Innotek ADV-1002 which was about $300 but works quite well.

I used these to teach my dogs to stop, sit, and come on command, even at a distance. This took a long time.

The problem with using a device like this for your purpose is in the training. To teach the dog to stop at certain boundaries, you will have to be physically present day after day, catch the dog approaching each boundary, apply the correction at the proper time, and repeat, perhaps many times. Any inconsistency and the dog will learn nothing. Proper training may take weeks or months for some dogs.

With consistency, most dogs can learn anything. My mother once taught our german shepard the boundaries of our property with nothing but a leash and verbal commands. I remember the dog stoping short at the boundary while chasing a rabbit!

If your use indends to control a dog left out unattended, I wonder if one of the radio area units would work better. I have a neighbor who uses one although he only dog-sits occasionally for his daughter. It uses a transmitter inside the house. He placed little white flags to mark the approximate boundary. He said it works well - I've seen the two dogs run up to the boundary and stop and bark while I rode by on horseback - the dogs were really wanting to get closer but didn't dare.

However, if you only let the dog outside when you are present, the hand-held trasmitter type should work very well. Some will vibrate and/or make an audible tone to warn the dog to stop before the shock. The cheap models should work fine if you need only a limited control distance.

JKJ

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

#9

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT *LINK*

Ron Hildreth

>Good Morning, Dale,

About 12 years ago, I borrowed a close friends shock collar for my Lab. I can't even begin to remember what the brand name was. It really got her attention! It worked like a charm, using it in conjunction with voice commands at the same time. We had the same problem - trying to keep her within our yard and not wandering through the neighborhood.

About 10 months ago we bought our own for our Rat Terrier. It has worked, somewhat, but we're finding out that it does depend on the disposition of the dog.

You need to size the collar for the dog two different ways- neck size, and amount of shock needed to control the size of dog. We went to "PetSmart" website and ordered according to dog size and the quality of collar we wanted. I bought their top of the line collar made by Radio Systems Corp. You get what you pay for, and because you don't use it everyday, it's better to buy a good one.

Here's PetSmart's link, but there are others available.

Ron in Iowa


PetSmart

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

#10

Long range Shock-collar for pooches

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Since the small hand held transmitter that came with the "Contain and Train" system had an effective range of about 100 feet (advertised at 150 yards) which was basically ineffective for field training a Brittany, I bought a Gun Dog GS-6000 Training Collar from Cabelas (made by Innotek) that has a 1 mile range. I know it works out to 500 yards, but I've never let my dog get farther than that from me.

As others have said. Even with the electronic collar it takes time and consistency to get the dog to obey. You can't just put up the fence or start zapping the dog if he doesn't know what to do. The trining videos that came with the Innotek systems I have are excellent. You still need to train to obey basic commands like come, stay, sit and the most versitile command is Whoa, which means stop where you are and don't move until released. Whoa can stop a dog that is about to cross a road in front of a vehicle in its tracks. Also use a word like "release" instead of "Okay" to terminate all commands as most people use the word Okay too much in ordinary speech.

Lee

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

#11

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

Lee Ohmart

>I have the Innotek collar but have never used it to manage boundries. I used it to keep the Jack Russell from chasing the cat. After two zaps, she got the message. When I used it to keep my Swissie from jumping the 3-foot fence, it didn't take long for him to realize that it didn't zap him when I wasn't around. I was looking at an invisible fence set up when my daughter got bit by the Gordon Setter down the street whose masters had installed an invisible fence. Intalking to my daughter and her brother about how the dog behaved, I relized that the invisible fence had inadvertantly taught the dog that whenever anybody walks by, he got zapped and they were responsible. The vet confirmed that devices of this type frequently caused more problems than they solved. I just installed a taller 4-foot fence. The old one was due for replacement anyway. That kept in the Swissie and his replacement, a Border Collie-Chocolate Lab mix. My advice, unless you're going to be out with the dog everytime it's in the yard, is put up a fence tall enough to contain it.

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

#12

Re: Actually....

ScottS

>I have heard from people who own them that the collars which spray citronella in the dog's nose aren't especially effective.

When I went to the local dog park regularly, I used to see a guy that owned a deaf dog. The dog was very obedient, but could only respond to commands when it could see the person giving them. The owner had previously used a citronella collar and found that the dog would often ignore it. As a result, he switched to a shock collar. He only used it when he really needed to get the dog's attention. The example he gave was if the dog were chasing something (ex: squirrel) and oblivious to the fact that it was headed for the street. One zap from the collar and the dog would instantly stop what it was doing and look around for him. He only used the collar in emergency situations, so he was more concerned with it working effectively than whether it caused the dog some momentary discomfort.

I also knew several people with dogs that barked incessantly. They also tried citronella collars and found them to be mostly ineffective. The dogs might stop barking for a few seconds, but would soon start back up again. One gentleman had a noise-activated citronella collar. He said the only thing it taught his dog to do was bark at a slightly reduced volume, so that the collar wouldn't spray! His dog was a particularly problematic barker, and he too switched to a manually-triggered shock collar eventually.

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

#13

Dale Lenz

Re: Wish...

Dale Lenz

>to thank everyone that responded to my request. I will check out the shock collars, especially the Innotek brand. I like the Whoa command, beats the NOOOOOOOOOOO!!! Yosiiiiiiii! command/plea, : ' >. The only thing the dog knows at this point is to sit and back. Back is when I'm walking her on the leach, I like Yosi near the back of my heels, not in front of me so I say back and she will normally slow down. Yosi is a 7 month old boxer, my first pure breed dog in my life. I was told after I got Yosi, that pure-breed dogs are more prone to get sick, since their gene-pool is smaller. So far, I will agree, she has had the mange and a staph infection. I'm thinking about getting a health insurance policy on her, : ' >.

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

#14

Re: Wish...

Johanna

>There are lots of caveats in buying pure bred dogs. Generally speaking, the best source is a breeder who is active in either obedience or agility competitions. Dogs who participate in those sports have to be both mentally and physically sound.

A good breeder carefully tests his breeding stock for hereditary defects. All that adds up to dogs that are expensive to purchase as puppies, but who are not likely to run up horrendous vet bills over their lifetime.

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

#15

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>My wife is a serious animal lover, and so we would never use a shock collar on a dog. How about if your mother put a shock collar on you to potty train you? Not trying to start an argument, I am just pointing out the various view points. One point is it's just an animal, the other point is that the animal feels pain. One of our best investmens as the owners of six dogs currently is a fenced dog run and dog crates. During nice weather the dogs can be outside most of the day. At night the dogs are used to sleeping in their crates and will go in when told to go to bed. (Mostly). When we go away during the day the dogs are crated. The dogs can be let out into the dog run through the back door of the house, and there is no way for them to get loose.

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

#16

Re: Shock-collar for pooches, OT

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Moses,

I understand your concern, but don't be mislead entirely by the word shock. You might want to know that the "shocks" used do not cause pain unless the user cranks up the power on purpose. (My training collars have 15 levels of power.) It is a big mistake to shock the dog into fearful behavior or in general train with pain.

I hold the contacts against my skin to test them and feel just a slight tingling. This is enough to get the dog's attention when trained along with verbal and other commands. Some collars even have a two-phase approach, they will issue an audible tone and/or vibration as a reminder, then follow that with an electrical tingle if needed.

Like other devices such as choke collars and leashes, the collars can be used or abused.

BTW, I fenced in spot for my dogs as well - 5' chain link around a very large wooded lot with a connected 10'x10'fenced kennel with a wooden floor and doghouse. Whenever possible, they hang out with me around the farm but they love their fenced area - just say KENNEL and they will race each other up the hill to get inside the fence!

JKJ