Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recommendat

Posts

Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recommendat

#1

Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recommendat

Dave Huber

>I have a Delta Hollow Chisel Mortiser.

It has come time to replace at least the 3/8" bit and chisel that came with it.

Does anyone have any thoughts about good replacements? Thanks.

Dave

Re: Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recommendat

#2

Re: Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recomme

McKay Sleight

>I am not sure who did the review, but it was found that the cheap chisels did almost as well as the expensive ones. I always have my cone shaped stone handy and sharpen my inexpensive chisels. They have done duty in my industrial mortiser at the school shop with out replacement for two years now. (now watch! It will break with some student tomorrow.)

Re: Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recommendat

#3

Re: Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recomme

David Yoho

>I've still got two Clicos that I like. If I were to replace them tomorrow, I'd probably look at Fisch first.

David

Re: Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recommendat

#4

Re: Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recomme

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Buy the Delta ones that come in the blue and white boxes - you can get them from HD. And no, these are not the same ones that came with the machine - they're better.

Rob

Re: Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recommendat

#5

Re: Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recomme

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>Be sure to check the length. Some are longer than others.

Re: Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recommendat

#6

Re: Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recomme

Barry Irby

>Mt friend did a LOT of mortising years ago and ended up buy Grizzly Chisels. At the time, they were about half what Delta's were and he thought they were as good or better. But be careful, If I recall correctly he had to make a bushing to make them work in his machine. this is a vague memory, so if you are interested, I will call him and ask.

Re: Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recommendat

#7

Re: Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recomme

DP

>Woodworking Magazine had the review. Sorry I don't recall the issue and don't have access to them to check right now.

Re: Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recommendat

#8

Re: Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recomme *LINK*

Bob Lang

>It was indeed "Woodworking", Spring 2007. The gist of it is that the least expensive bits, if given a little care work about as good as any. If you do a cost/benefit analysis it's hard to justify spending $70-$100 per chisel/bit combination vs. $10 and 15 minutes of effort to sharpen the bit. There wasn't anything wrong with the expensive ones, some performed marginally better, but not 10 times better. The only way I think you could justify using Clicos would be if you were running a mortiser all day every day. We didn't do a long-term test, so that is speculation, we're still using the cheap ones from a year ago.

Lee Valley has an nice set priced in between the cheap and the overpriced. They arrived in better shape than any of the others we tested, and required less effort to sharpen and tune. If time=money to you, I think they're a good choice without spending way too much.

What we found necessary was a bit of tweaking to the chisel, which is described on the PopWood blog (see the link below). We also found no benefit to trying to improve the bit.

Bob Lang


Hollow Chisel Tuneup

Re: Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recommendat

#9

Go "Fisching"

Chris Knob

>Most bang for the buck but you will have to learn how to sharpen thise items no matter what you buy.

Re: Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recommendat

#10

Re: Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recomme

Dave Huber

>Thank you very much everybody.

I will run off and do a little reading.

I really appreciate teh input.

Dave

Re: Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recommendat

#11

Re: Hollow Chisel Mortiser replacement bit recomme

Larry Clinton

>I have the Fisch 3/4 Hp benchtop mortiser. It came with a 3 piece set of Guildcraft mortising bits. I really like these bits - although I did "bend" the 1/4" bit. (I straightened it out and it still works well). I was going to replace them with a "better" brand when I bought the unit. However they work so well I have put it off. I looked at the Fisch brand bits - they are not polished and sharpened as are the Guildcraft. I do sharpen my bits with the cone shaped diamond sharpener when required. I touched up the 1/4" bit after about 80 to 100 mortises. These were all cut into White oak and Locust and were all at least 1 1/4 deep, usually 2 to 2 1/2 long. The Guildcraft are quite inexpensive, and are ready to use as received with a high polished exterior and very sharp edges.