Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Glue test results on plyboo....

Posts

Glue test results on plyboo....

#1

Glue test results on plyboo....

Link Van Cleave

>I did a test. I took samples of my edging and glued it to my plyboo no splines, nothing but a straight edge joint. I did 4 different combos. 2 with poly, 2 with yellow. On each I did a different edge orientation as far as the plyboo was concerned. I made sure the end grain on the plyboo was well saturated. Glued up samples and let them dry 7 hours in a nice warm place. I took the samples and tried to break them. Couldn't do it. Took a deadblow hammer and wacked them. Both glues were strong enough however the yellow glue samples were stronger. Tore big pieces off the Wenge. Interestingly the end grain area of the bamboo seems to glue better. I noticed small areas were the poly didn't glue the side grain area completly. Your mileage may vary but emperical tests in real conditions are invaluable.

My edging ended up being a fat 1" so I didn't add anything to the plyboo to build up the edge. I used a 1/8" spline to line things up, yellow glue and "Bob's your uncle".

Link

Re: Glue test results on plyboo....

#2

..and what did I say?

HC Sakman

>PVA....PVA....PVA...

Bamboo would lack the necessary moisture for poly glue.

Good luck Link,

Chico...

Re: Glue test results on plyboo....

#3

Re: ..and what did I say?

Thomas S Stockton

>Chico,

Not sure if it is the moisture content or what but in my experiances poly glues are the most overrated glues out there. I think it is a testement to the power of advertising.

Tom

Re: Glue test results on plyboo....

#4

I agree with that Tom.

HC Sakman

>Poly glue is indeed overrated, though lack of moisture and glazed, unlike wood, surface of bamboo would not help poly, hence its little more porous end grain glues better with either poly and PVA.

Chico...

PS:I found Gorilla Glue the weakest, most foaming glue of all poly glues, despite their strong claims about its strength. Oregon made (If I recall correctly) "System Three" I found the strongest with minimal foam.

Re: Glue test results on plyboo....

#5

Re: I agree with that Tom.

Link Van Cleave

>Chico,

I tend to think poly sucks also but I just used it for a test. The two glue choices were yellow or epoxy. I was a bit surprised at how well the yellow grabed the bamboo endgrain. The endgrain was my concern but it actually grabed better on the endgrain than the side grain. Epoxy would not be bothered by the endgrain, but the test showed me the yellow is fine. Obviously bamboo is a grass and while similar to wood it is not the same. Hence the hesitation with the yellow and the need for a test.

But Ok, dude you were right !

Link

Re: Glue test results on plyboo....

#6

Re: I agree with that Tom.

Thomas S Stockton

>Maybe the porosity of the bamboo gives the glue something to grab onto.

Tom

Re: Glue test results on plyboo....

#7

Re: Glue test results on plyboo....

john lucas

>Link I did sort of the same test a few years ago gluing 1" square pieces of several different woods, end grain to end grain. I was trying to find what would make the strongest joint when building a segmented piece where end grain was the main glue joint.

I used PvA,both white and yellow, two different types of Poly, one was gorilla glue, and slow set and fast set epoxy. To test the pieces which were 6" long and 1" square I clamped one end in a vise and then put a clamp on the other end. I added a 5lb weight to the clamp and slid it out the wood until it broke. The poly broke before I could even get the weight fully on the clamp. The yellow and white were about even with the weight almost all the way out the clamp and the epoxy was very close right behind.

I've tried poly on several other projects and find that although it works the other glues work as well or better in all cases and are much easier to clean up and work with. I've also had to throw away part of every single bottle of poly due to hardening. I never have that problem with PVA or Epoxy.

Re: Glue test results on plyboo....

#8

Re: Glue test results on plyboo....

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>A local boating magazine (Pacific Yachting) did a "glue" article and ended up recommending Poly. I went back and forth with the author and suggested places he could do his own research that countered his "findings (I have serious questions about the depth of testing he did too) but he never did print a counter article or even a warning for that mater. I wonder how many people have/will suffer failures because of the stuff. I know it's gone from my shelves now...

Rob

Re: Glue test results on plyboo....

#9

Re: Good Info

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>I've also found Gorilla glue to be the worst of those I've tried. So far, the best is the Elmers ProBond, but I'll have to give the System Three a try.

Thanks,

Jay