Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Vibration Mitigation (Long)

Posts

Vibration Mitigation (Long)

#1

Vibration Mitigation (Long)

Bill Schreiber, Litchfield, NH

>All,

I am writing this to pick all of your brains as to the best way forward with my problem. I have put a lot of thought into it, but I really want to run this by the collective wisdom here and maybe come up with a better solution.

I have had carpal tunnel problems for the past six years. In fact all of this was written using voice-activated software. Because of how sensitive my hands have been to vibration, I have had to severely curtail the amount of woodworking I've done. I have tried getting good at hand tools with some success, but nothing beats a router table and a table saw for certain operations such as making mortises, dadoes, cutting wood accurately to size, etc.

What is interesting about my carpal tunnel is that I can easily do a half-hour of running my table saw but only can stand a few minutes of using my router table. I can use my jigsaw, my electric drill my skills saw for fairly long periods of time without any problems. Last year I did my roof using asphalt shingles and hammer without any problem at all. The last time I used to my router table I did four dadoes and my hands really bothered me for three days after. It is very high frequency vibration which appears to affect me the most.

I've tried vibration gloves, foam padding to everything I touch and it really hasn't been a significant gain in usability especially on the router table. My next project would most easily be done utilizing a router table and I really want to get back to doing a lot more woodworking too since I miss it.

So I have been doing a lot of research on vibration mitigation techniques. Right now, I have a router table that is similar to Norms plan with a throat insert that is actually attached to the router itself. My plan is to disconnect the throat insert from the router and build a fixture which would be screwed to the table itself which would hold the router in exactly the same position without actually ever touching the throat insert or the router table top itself. The router table top itself would be connected to the table by four vibration isolators that I found through Grainger. These are basically long pieces of rubber with bolts coming out of each end but they never actually touch each other except through the rubber. I want to purchase threaded rod which I will use to put through the edge guide holes but will extend slightly out. In the fixture I plan to build (made out of wood of course), I will have corresponding female grooves that the router will set in. This way I can easily pick the router up out of the table and changed bits etc.

One thing I thought about it was possibly isolating the fixture itself as well as the table top. The problem though is that the vibration isolators are made of rubber and they give a bit under moderate pressure. I also have the problem that the physical bit touching the wood will also create vibration. So one thought was to build a sled with vibration isolators connected to the handles I would actually use to push the sled by the bit.

Anyways, any comments or suggestions are welcome. I would appreciate any suggestions from the brain trust here.

Regards,

Bill

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

#2

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long X 2)

Bob Burnet (NW Florida)

>Bill,

I am not sure that isolation of the router assembly from the table or the insert is the real issue. The vibration from a router table assembly usually comes from either an out of balance router (primarily the router motor) or from the vibration induced by the router bit when cutting. You want to make sure that the router bit stays in a constant position and doesn't "move around" while routing. See if spiral bits help. Also you may want to try different speeds if you have a variable speed router. Best wishes.

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

#3

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>This might be an overkill idea, but have you considered getting a shaper and setting it up for routing? I wonder if the mass of the machine would help cut down on the vibration?

Tom

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

#4

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

Henry (Raleigh NC)

>Bill:

I have no expertise here, presumed or otherwise.

I did not attempt to understand all of your engineering ideas of the router table itself, but from a woodworking precision standpoint I believe rigidity in the table and mount are needed for precision.

I think your last line about vibration isolation from your hands is the place to focus. A well designed sled (or sleds?) with fairly stiff rubber isolation pads between the handles and the sled would be a start � you�ll still need to be able to control the sled and apply consistent pressure (employ more feather boards?). Further isolation of your hands from the handles with gloves and foam sound like things you have tried; it�s likely that a combination of approaches is what�s needed.

Henry

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

#5

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

Tom MacGregor

>If you haven't already, carefully examine your body mechanics - the ergonomics of your routing. Is it possible that the exact position of your hands plus the manner in which you apply force (muscle power) causes at least part of the problem? Changing your stance or the height of the table, or designing a sled that allows a different grip might help as much as damping vibration. Differences in the nature of the motion required are what allowed me to do some activities but not others until I had a carpal tunnel release performed on my right wrist last year.

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

#6

Re: stock feeder

Kneale Brownson awaiting snow in N. MI

>Wouldn't a motorized stock feeder eliminate the hands-on problems?


Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

#7

I like it...

Bill Schreiber, Litchfield, NH

>more cast iron for the shop. It would certainly help (not sure how much, but definitely some) but right now no money. Might be a bit before I could implement. Have to try some other approaches first.

I lke the way you are thinking - more tools!

Regards,

Bill

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

#8

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long X 2)

Bill Schreiber, Litchfield, NH

>I hadn't thought to slow down the router (duh!) since it is a VS. What is interesting and I don't understand why, is that to touch the router it doesn't feel really that it is vibrating that much. It is two hours after I use it that I am in a lot of discomfort. Also, lower frequency vibration is no where near as irritating (jig saw, table saw, miter saw etc).

I will try changing the speed, play withthat.

thanks- bill

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

#9

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

Bill Schreiber, Litchfield, NH

>I have some ideas on isolating the vibration from my hands. That is a much easier implementation than what I am trying to do with the table. I definitely need to be able to do both.

Thanks foryour input. Bill

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

#10

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>Having similar but opposite issues as you, I can swing a hammer for about one spike and I am done for several days, yet the router has no effect.

As said above try varying the height of the router table, imagine your wrist in a wrist brace, how high would the table have to be to work at it? Now raise the table to that height and try it. May even want to use the wrist brace when working at it - the ones with the metal spoon in it to keep the wrist straight.

I understand that cast iron, because of it's internal elasticity, naturally dampens vibration. If vibration alone is the issue you may try a cast iron table or as stated above a shaper with a cast iron table and router collect on it.

If all else fails, teach the (insert proper noun for significant other here) how to use the router table!

Bill, who advises that if you go under the knife do only o ne wrist at a time.

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

#11

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

Bill Schreiber, Litchfield, NH

>Interesting. I would be curious to know what changes you made that were effective.

I certainly could try playing with this. The other night I tried a few things with my table and had touched the router for perhaps 30 seconds or so without applying any force to it. My hands the next morning were still irritated. Very frustrating since I still after six years don't really understand why what bothers them does bother them.

Thanks for your help,

Bill

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

#12

Re: stock feeder

Bill Schreiber, Litchfield, NH

>I have thought about it! That would be a solution but right now the money isn't there to do the 200 plus dollars necessary. Great idea though.

Bill

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

#13

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

Bill Schreiber, Litchfield, NH

>That is very interesting that you can use a router with no problems but you have the problem with a hammer. What is funny is after a lot of exercise like a project like my roof or doing my deck my hands feel great.

I'll have to examine myself and how I work to see if I need to make changes. That is something I had not really thought about.

Regards, Bill

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

#14

Re: Vibration Mitigation (Long)

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>This isn't really my area, but I took a biomechanics course a few years back in which we discussed how vibration-induced nerve injury can simulate carpal tunnel syndrome. Certain frequencies and intensities of vibration can transfer energy up the arm more effectively than others, and if repetitive, can cause an injury to the nerves themselves. If memory serves, there is a physician at U Conn (Dempsey) Hospital who specializes in this. Might be worth looking into, especially because in this sort of injury after awhile there is no recovery and the discomfort is constant.

Hope this helps. Good luck.

Ken