Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

Posts

OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#1

OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

Howard In Toronto

>Hi all -

Is Michigan considered part of the US "midwest".

I say yes; LOML says no.

I've got four dollars ridin on thisun.....

Thanks.

Howard

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#2

It is from here. (Baltimore)

Mike Schwing from Maryland

>

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#3

Yes

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#4

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

Kneale Brownson awaiting snow in N. MI

>Traditional "Midwest" is the region cornered by North Dakota, Kansas, Ohio and Michigan.

As a native Michiganian, I've always understood myself to be a native Midwesterner too.

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#5

AHA!!!! Thanks!

Howard In Toronto

>

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#6

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

Ron Hildreth

>That could be a loaded question, Howard, and I'm bound to tick off a few people in my earlier life. When I used to drive tractor-trailer rig long distance, I ran mostly west coast, and as far as I was concerned, the U.S. stopped at the Mississippi River. I hated it beyond there toward the east. However, I've been away from truck driving for over 30 years, and having a daughter who now resides in Boston, I've changed my mind about this. Heck, I'm even a devoted Red Sox Fan!

I know I didn't answer your question, but now days I'm just glad to live anywhere in this great country!

BTW- take her out to a good Steakhouse where the beef they serve came from our midwest, to pay off the bet, and you'll both win (unless you're vegetarians).

Ron in Iowa

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#7

Ron - that was my intention anyway

Howard In Toronto

>and no we're not vegetarians BUT I personally prefers my Alberta beef!

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#8

Re: Ron - that was my intention anyway

Ron Hildreth

>Howard,

It once was that when I took SWMBO out to supper, I would later in the evening be rewarded with bedroom privledges. Now I can't remember where the steakhouse was, or what we DID in the bedroom!!!

Ron in Iowa

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#9

How about US dept of commerce?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>From this it looks like Michigan is in the Miswest REGION, but the East North Central DIVISION.

I just found out I'm an East South Centralan. Yippie.


img

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#10

Michiganian, yes; michigander, no.

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>Where did that awful gander descriptor come from? The first time I heard it, after living in Michigan all my life, was a public service spot by Michelle Engler, plugging childhood immunizations back in the '90's. Now, our Republican legislators tend toward the 'gander, while the Dems tend towards 'ganian.

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#11

Re: Most of us Ohiuns consider Michiganders

Dale Stansbery

>foreigners this coming Saturday. Rest of the year, I guess they're mid western.

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#12

The Midwest includes

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>the portion of the Northwest Territory north of the Ohio River and east of the Mont, Wy, Col borders. Obviously this is part of the La Purchase. The Census map shown by John Jordan is essentially correct.

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#13

Alan Young

The actuall geographical truth

Alan Young

>The Lower Peninsula is part of the Midwest and it is populated by "trolls" ie people that live below "The bridge" The Upper Peninsula or UP as in "you pee" (sorry...) is populated by "Yoopers" but is actually neither part of the Midwest or West or even North for that matter. It is a far west extension of Finland.

Alan- originally from North Dakota 1959-1982 but Lived here in Michigan Longer 1982-2007 so now I am an expert.

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#14

I Thought Gander Was In Canada

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#15

Re: Michiganian, yes; michigander, no.

Kneale Brownson awaiting snow in N. MI

>The "gander" version is attributed to Abraham Lincoln, when he used it derogatorily to describe Michigan territorial Governor Lewis Cass as a silly goose.

So I guess that's why SOME Grand Old Party devotees latch onto it.

I learned Michiganian when I was in grade school in the 1940s.

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#16

Guess I'm in the minority

Darrin

>Just my opinion, but I disagree. To me the mid-west would be Colorado, Utah, Wyoming, Idaho, and Montana. The Great Plains stretch from northern Texas up to North Dakota. Which leaves anything east of the Mississippi river, just that, east. Just one of several pet peeves.

Darrin

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#17

Re: Guess I'm in the minority... Me too

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>I've always wondered how the west ended 400 miles from the western border (Pacific ocean). I do admit I like the regional designation of the Pacific Northwest.

glc

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#18

Re: Guess I'm in the minority

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> To me the mid-west would be Colorado, Utah, Wyoming, Idaho, and Montana. The Great Plains stretch from northern Texas up to North Dakota. Which leaves anything east of the Mississippi river, just that, east.

I hate to say this Darrin, but I don't know of a soul who would consider Utah, Idaho, or Montana anything but a Western state. Frankly so are Colorado and Wyoming by almost any definition, but there's no argument I can conceive of on the first three.

Although I don't completely disagree on your definition of the Great Plains, that wasn't the question. Those states (Kansas, Nebraska, South and North Dakota) are arguably Western, but are at the very least the most western of the Midwestern states. Even limiting the region to your definition of the Mississippi, you have to include Missouri, Iowa, and Minnesota as midwestern.

And, as a 26 year veteran of Chicagoland (and the Central Time Zone), I'm afraid I must assert definitively that Illinois (and by extension, Wisconsin) are most definitely Midwestern states. I'll concede Indiana and Michigan (particularly da yoo-pee) as belonging, too, but I do draw the line at Ohio.

Anyway, unless you can come up with at least one other person who considers Utah or Idaho a midwestern state, I'm afraid you're going to have to either redefine your pet peeves or consign yourself to a life of frustration, because no one's buying it.

Rod


Now in the South, and sure of it.

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#19

Re: The actuall geographical truth

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>Well Alan, I was a "Troll" for many years and we thought little of the UPers. Now that I am a "Badger" once again, we still think little of the UPers. Poor UPers!! Of course I could also become a "Troll" again by moving to Mount Horeb (Mt Horrible) outside Madison. Mount Horeb is known for its Trolls; carvings, castings, whatever.

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#20

College football can settle this question

wilbur

>If your state has a Big Ten school, you're in the Midwest.

Michigan has two Big Ten schools.

Therefore, Michigan is in the Midwest.

Q.E.D.

And those folks from Penn State are just interlopers.

Sprinkle :@) liberally throughout this post.

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#21

i say give the state to Canada GO BUCKEYES !!!

Mark Valsi

>

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#22

Re: Guess I'm in the minority

Darrin

>Rod,

I agree with you. If you look at the Plains states as the beginning of the west, then you would (maybe) agree that at least geographically, CO, UT, WY, ID, and MT would be mid-west. I am in no way trying to change their western heritage. I'm just saying that of the western region they would be the actual mid-west. As far as a life of frustration, there are some points I resigned myself to long ago. LOL

Darrin

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#23

Re: Guess I'm in the minority

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> If you look at the Plains states as the beginning of the west, then you would (maybe) agree that at least geographically, CO, UT, WY, ID, and MT would be mid-west…I'm just saying that of the western region they would be the actual mid-west.

Well, we're probably trying to pick fly specks out of pepper over semantics, but what you describe is probably more properly middle-of-the-West (and generic, at that), whereas the term Midwest (note the capitalization) has an historical and traditional connotation which excludes all of your samples except for the Plains States (also a traditional description, none of which are in your other group, either).

Good luck with your frustrations—I have plenty of them with which I'm trying to cope, too.

Rod

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#24

Re: Frustrations

Kneale Brownson awaiting snow in N. MI

>When you guys get a little older, you'll come to realize that becoming frustrated about anything is a waste of emotion and an unnecessary stress on your health.

Re: OT - help me settle a (very small) bet

#25

Re:GO BUCKEYES !!! I thought they already went

Kneale Brownson awaiting snow in N. MI

>