Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Safety first -- a cautionary tale

Posts

Re: Safety first -- a cautionary tale

#26

Sorry to hear and another caution

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I'm sorry to hear about your friend. Saw accidents are never fun.

You mentioned in your note that your friend was making plunge cuts on a table saw. Hopefully he was raising the blade into the work and not lowering the work onto the moving blade.

For the uniformed on the site, we should clarify that when you make plunge cuts on a TS you always always always place the work piece on the table with the blade lowered and the saw off. Have a stop block in place to hold the work from kicking back. Start the saw and raise the moving blade into the piece of wood, make the cut, then lower the blade completely, turn off the saw before removing the piece of wood.

Never ever lower a piece of wood onto a moving blade whether or not you have a back stop in place.

work safe

Lee

Re: Safety first -- a cautionary tale

#27

More details please

ScottM

>We can learn more from this if we have more details.

Part being cut?

Method of cut?

Hand placement?

Thanks

Scott

Re: Safety first -- a cautionary tale

#28

Re: Safety first -- a cautionary tale

Dan Mitchell

>Bill-Thanks for the reply. I assumed that's what the process was, but I wasn't sure. I've done something a bit similar 3 times, cutting a sacrificial fence from melamine particle board & a wooden blade insert I had made for the dado blade, & cutting an OEM zero clearance insert. On all 3 occasions though, I secured the piece down to the table top & raised the blade into it, rather than lowering the piece onto the blade. Although I guess it would take a bit more setup, at least in the case of the hole in the middle of a board I would think you could do it this way as well. The groove in the middle I personally would do with a router, as you said.

Dan

Re: Safety first -- a cautionary tale

#29

Re: Sorry to hear it

Brian in Brighton

>Now I am more interested in the Saw Stop contractors model.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Safety first -- a cautionary tale

#30

Re: Safety first -- a cautionary tale

Steve Lillie

>My sympathy for the other Steve -- he has a long and painful recovery ahead. I had a minor tablsaw accident about a year ago, losing about 1/8 inch off the end of my thumb: no guard, no push-stick, a narrow rip, and no splitter make for a dangerous combination. After several months of treatment including skin grafts, the thumb looks OK, if a little misshapen. Of course, full sensation will never return. I certainly won't trivialize this sort of injury again, nor will I question the cost-benefit trade off of safety equipment for my shop.

I have replaced my 20-year-old Delta contractor's saw with a shiny new SawStop, even though it crushed my woodworking budget for the next 20 years or so. On the bright side, I got to hang out in the cosmetic surgeon's office with lots of young people trying to look more beautiful.

Re: Safety first -- a cautionary tale

#31

Makes me think of getting that Sawstop..

Bri in Mtl

>...more and more. If it can happen to a guy like that well....

Re: Safety first -- a cautionary tale

#32

Re: Safety first -- a cautionary tale

Peter Hyde

>Ellis, I can empathize with your post as last week the bandsaw bit me. Not anywhere near the terrible loss that your friend had, just a painful deep cut in the side of my right hand. At the time I had hit the stop button but not used the brake so the blade was still slowing.

I have gone through the post mortem of the incident over and over in my head and can find no reason why I didn't use the brake. Senior moment? probably as I am 65. But why after years of using the brake does the mind play these tricks. So I have to believe it was the Fickle Finger of Fate giving me a wake up call and will be a lot more attentive from here on in around machinery.

Re: Safety first -- a cautionary tale

#33

Re: Makes me think of getting that Sawstop..

Don Bullock

>That's exactly what I did. I showed SWMBO the videos on their site and that's all it took for us to figure out how to "afford" one. At my age (60) I'm not as quick or stable as I was when I was young. The table saw I had was an old (1979) Craftsman. I didn't feel I was very safe (even though I used the guard, push sticks, etc.) with it. I've found that with the SS I'm much more aware of safety on all my machines than I was before I bought it. While the SS isn't "fool proof" it is definately much safer than what I was working with.

Re: Safety first -- a cautionary tale

#34

Sawstop not the answer

McKay Sleight

>I have three sawstops in the school shop. In the first 28 years of teaching, I have only had one student have a minor accident on a table saw. HOWEVER, since I have installed the sawstops last year, I have had 6 activations of the saw. This means one of two things:

1)the kids are not as smart as the first 28 years.

OR

2)the kids think that the saw is so safe that it is no longer necessary to follow safety rules.

I believe it to be the latter.

If you are using the wrong saw for the operation, or too small, or too tired, or.....you get the picture.

I had to get rid of a Powermatic 72 for the third saw. The PM is three times the saw as the sawstop.

Sorry, but this technology does not replace training and common sense.


img

Re: Safety first -- a cautionary tale

#35

Re: Sawstop not the answer

Ray Newman

>McKay Sleight: agreed. You said it all in my opinion!

Re: Safety first -- a cautionary tale

#36

Re: Sawstop not the answer

Bri in Mtl

>Personally I think it's your number 1 option. re:kids.

"Sorry, but this technology does not replace training and common sense."

The gentleman in question does sound like he has/had the training and common sense. We all know accidents happen to the best of us.

Bottom bottom line -the guy would've kept his fingers if he had a Sawstop.