Which comes first.......
Barry Irby
>The wood or the project? Do you have a project in mind and go get the wood for it, or do you have the wood and let it inspire you to build something of it?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Which comes first.......
Barry Irby
>The wood or the project? Do you have a project in mind and go get the wood for it, or do you have the wood and let it inspire you to build something of it?
The Chicken Sez . . .
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>"Ask the egg." But eggs can't talk so the chicken wins by default.
Ideas always come first. The material, whatever its nature, must always be subservient to the idea. If the material rules, then all you can make is a tree.
mm
Ditto, but . . .
Steve Mackay
>there are still those scraps of purple heart lurking under my bench. Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm.
Sometimes
Dan Donaldson
>I agree most of the time, but I have also been at a lumber yard and found some piece of wood that was special in some way that I didn't have a project for at the time. I usually buy stuff like that and just store it waiting for the right project because that kind of wood is never around whe you are looking for it. I have several pieces in that catagory just sitting and waiting for the right place for use.
Re: Which comes first.......
John E
>Both. USUALLY, at least for me, the project idea comes first, then go get the wood. But occasionally, there is that special piece of wood that screams to be displayed. Most of my woodworking is "practical" - furniture or stuff we or someone else needs for the house. But I also enjoy making small boxes like jewelry boxes, or boxes for kids to keep stuff, and these are often good places to use that special board with beautiful grain, or some type of knot or defect that can be highlighted. Several times I've come up with projects by staring at a board thinking "Now what can I do with this?"
John
Re: On Hold
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>I've got a b/m pair of 12x60 Br. rosewood and a 10' piece of 8/4x18 waterfall cherry in the same position.
Something will come up that calls to them.
Both......
Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie
>I've got a stash of 8/4 walnut that's been sitting on my shelves for several years. Decided to build a Soccer Table with it. Now I have to go and buy MORE walnut because I don't have quite enough.
Happy Woodworking!
Yes
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>
Re: She tells me what to make...
Brian in Brighton
>then I figure out how to make, it. Get approval on the design. Find the wood. Figure out how to get a few new tools, or at least router bits, out of the deal. Cut all the wood. Start assembly. Then she tells me what I did wrong. Try to fix it without looking like I changed a bunch of stuff turning an end table into a wardrobe.
Brian in Brighton
Re: Depends...
Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast
>I have never been inspired to build a set of kitchen cabinets from seeing a nice piece of birch plywood, but the other day I saw some nice purpleheart and some Christmas ideas started racing through my mind. Of course I work at the speed of light where time is infinite so it may be a few years to that Christmas.
Bill
I agree....
Lee Schierer - McKean, PA
>For most projects, I figure out the design and go buy the wood. Once in a while I see a piece of wood that has particular character and I save that until the right job for it comes along. I try not to become a wood collector because my storage space is pretty limited..... Anybody want to buy 500 bdft of hickory??? :)
Lee
Re: The wood
Larry Clinton
>I attend a lot of auctions in the summer, and never turn down a good buy on wood (until the last auction). I have the upstairs room (30'X 10' X 8' high) just about packed with wood. I only buy when I can't find the exact wood I need for a project - (or an exotic). Had to leave the last auction 'fore they sold the wood as I don't have any indoor storage room left.
we must be married to sisters... :-)
Bruce, a MN Galoot
>
Re: Which comes first.......
George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA
>Good Afternoon Barry,
Mostly, it is the project. Of late I am buying significant(for me) amounts of cherry and poplar for out master bedroom suite. I can't afford to buy wood for later inspiration because I need specific wood commodities. I have done it the other way. But in this phase of my woodworking it doesn't work.
George
We're just a bunch of Wood Collectors
Ron in Drums PA
>I have loads of boards that are just to nice to do anything with.
Maybe someday when that perfect project comes around...
Re: Which comes first.......
Pete in Holland, MI
>I go either way. Due to some good sources for good native wood in northern Michigan, I usually have 500-1000 bd ft of Oak, Maple and some Walnut at my disposal for small projects. Big projects require forethought to pick up the wood (4 hrs away) on scheduled trips in that direction. Usually buy more than I need so I have some for later.
Have had occasions to get some good timberable trees, over the years. Those get cut and bingo........the shelves are full again !
hmmm.........
Dan Donaldson
>500-1000 bf for SMALL projects? My idea of a small project is 2-5 board feet ;-)