>I was reading in "Building Cabinet Doors & Drawers' by Danny Proulx and saw some solid-wood slab doors for cabinets. They were made by edge glueing with biscuits. It says that it is a very old, traditional cabinetmaking technique that was popular many years ago. Neat looking door that would look great with the heart pine I have to build the cabinets with.
Is this a good technique? Will the glue joints hold on a door that is used regularly?
>A properly glued joint is stronger than the surrounding wood. It is not necessary to use biscuits. Biscuits are only for alignment, and basically a waste of time to install in edge glued boards unless they are long boards the biscuits help to align the boards. If you build a slab door like this you want to be careful not to go over 18" wide or so to avoid having major issues with wood movement. Some people put a cleat on the back of the door to "prevent warping". In today's climate controlled homes I do not believe the cleat is necessary, and takes away from the interior space of the cabinet.
>First, as mentioned above, you don't need biscuits to reinforce long grain, wood-to-wood edge joints. Biscuits were developed for plywood and particleboard cabinet joinery, though they have many useful applications in general woodworking as well, such as applying face frames and reinforcing mitered corners.
This said, you always want to consider the stresses, strains and insults that your projects will be subjected to. Any board will have more or less of a tendency to split along the grain if the insult is extreme enough. Naturally, it will vary with species, thickness, width and the nature of the forces applied.
For this reason, battens are often used, both to keep the board flat and to give some beam strength against splitting forces. You just need to make sure your battens are not glued fast to the board, or you will experience the seasonal cupping that Clint mentioned. You can get around this by either dovetailing the cleat across your board with very shallow dovetails (1/4" is plenty) and/or using slotted holes and screws.
As Lee mentioned, solid doors are best used in overlay mode so that movement isn't so obvious.
>I learned the hard way that battens across the backs of solid wood slab doors have to have slotted screw holes to allow for movement. Years ago, I had a subcontractor build in a hutch. He glued and screwed the battens and I heard the snaps as the wood split as the heating season began. As I was getting into woodworking, I planed off those battens, split and reglued the doors, and replaced the battens with battens having slotted screw holes so there could be some float with the seasonal changes in relative humidity in the house. It's been 35 years and they don't cup or split, and still look fine. They are overlay doors, so the changes in door width with the seasons doesn't show. Gene Gauss