Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Couple questions about Walnut and glue

Posts

Couple questions about Walnut and glue

#1

Couple questions about Walnut and glue

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Hello.

I have a few walnut boards to glue up that will be a small table top approx 36" long by 21" wide. This top will go on a Cherry base that I just glued up yesterday. First time in the 'shop' since last spring. Yeah, I started this little table last winter! Uhg.

I was going to use regular yellow glue to edge glue the boards (no biscuits or anything) but then wondered about the color. I have some Titebond liquid hide glue. Would that be better to use? It's several years old. I seem to recall this stuff having a shelf life, is that correct? Is there a way to test it?

This is what the table is going to look like. These are work-in-process shots.


and...


and...


last one...


Thank you.

Joe

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

#2

Dale Lenz

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

Dale Lenz

>Hi Joe,

I've been using yellow glues for 25+ years and have not had a problem with the glue showing up in my finish work, unless the joints are not tight.

Have not use hide glue before.

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

#3

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

Bruce, a MN galoot

>Titebond makes a dark colored Titebond II that works extremely well. I've used it gluing up a bunch of walnut table tops.

Bruce

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

#4

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Three year old Liquid Hide Glue, from Titebond? It might work just fine. If you're gluing up the panels, you might just try a test on some scrap, and see how fast and strongly it cures. There's a finger tip test I read about, but haven't used. This stuff is supposed to be long open, but fast tack type, and some between your fingertips should sort of take a set in 30 seconds to a minute, IIRC.

I bought abottle of this a couple of years ago to do some veneering, a project that went south pretty quickly. I used the stuff to glue some parts recently, because I could reach the bottle easily in my over-crowded shop. And it worked amazingly well. And, now that I think about it, one of those projects included a counter top glueup of red oak...

The great part of this is, that if the glue up goes south, you can clean up the surface, and use something else pretty easily. Give it a try!

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

#5

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

paul in AZ

>I wouldn't worry about using yellow glue. I have a walnut DR table made some 25 years ago with yellow Titebond that is holding up just fine. As to color showing, if the joint is halfway decent all I use is a wet rag to wipe up any squeezed out excess and glue lines don't show.

I have not had very good luck with the dark Titebond. For whatever reason I found that it doesn't hold as well as the yellow. YMMV.

If you are really concerned and want to overkill, how about a hidden spline? That way it will never ever come apart.

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

#6

various answers

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>This top will go on a Cherry base that I just glued up yesterday. Nice table. It will look better with a cherry top.

I was going to use regular yellow glue but then wondered about the color. A proper glue line will not show.

I have some Titebond liquid hide glue. Would that be better to use? No

It's several years old. I seem to recall this stuff having a shelf life, is that correct? Yes Is there a way to test it? Yes. Hide glue (and all other glues as well are polymers, in this case a protein. Polymers get their strength because their molecules are very long (think spaghetti except even longer) and because they are long they can tangle with one another. So to pull a polymer apart one must break chemical bonds and that takes a lot of energy. The molecule size of hide glue gets broken down with age and then the polymer looses its strength. If the molecules are long, and hence entangled, one can pull strings from the hide glue. Rub some between fingers and then pull apart. If it make strings it means the molecules are still long and the glue is good. It is sort of like pulling a plate of spaghetti apart and the two parts string together.

This is what the table is going to look like. These are work-in-process shots.

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

#7

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

Jesse Cloud

>Would it work? Prolly. Is it worth the risk - no way! Glue is cheap, cheaper than walnut and way cheaper than your time. Buy some fresh glue. I use yellow titebond on walnut all the time - no problem. If the joint is so poor that the glue line shows, you probably should do it over no matter what kind of glue you use...

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

#8

Re: Walnut glue

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Can't help with the hide.

But I tint my TB-III for different woods. Transtint or water/alcohol soluable dye do just fine. A little touch of the liquid dye and you can match your glue to the piece you're doing.

Of course in your example, you'll have to choose between cherry and walnut flavor.

mm

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

#9

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

Ralph in Santa Ana

>You seem to have gotten some good answers to you question, so I don't feel guilty of asking you a question. I'm also making a couple of end tables that look roughly the same size as your table. Would you be so kind as to give the dimensions? The size of the top and the height on the table??? TIA

I'm just getting back into it after about 6 years off and I'm just not too sure of my eye for proportions yet.

Ralph

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

#10

Titebond makes a dark glue

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Titebond makes a dark wood glue specifically for gluing darker woods. ROckler carries, but I'm sure others do as well.

Lee

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

#11

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

David Yoho

>Joe, Bill outlined the test for hide glue well. If yours fails this test, you need new glue. If you were going to buy some anyway, I'd go with the Titebond hide glue before the others mentioned. Should you ever need to take any of those joints apart, hide glue makes it easy. Once it's dry, if some remains on the surface, it doesn't show up under finishes like the yellow glues do. I usually buy the smaller bottle of Titebond when I don't buy it for a specific project. That way I usually use it up before it expires. I buy the larger bottle when I have a project or two that will consume most of it.

David

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

#12

Re: various answers

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Thanks Bill for the direct and concise answers.

Nice table. It will look better with a cherry top

I agree. The person I am making this for requested this combination. Works out fine for me as I had some walnut for the top I'd like to use up anyway.

Thanks.

Joe

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

#13

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>"Would you be so kind as to give the dimensions?"

This table will be used in a large kitchen off to the side. Its size is based on what the person wants and mock ups I made and took there. So if the size seems odd to anybody, that's why; it's sized to fit a particular spot in the kitchen.



  • 4" wide cherry aprons. There will be a drawer on each end.


  • Legs are turned from 1-5/8" square cherry.


  • Table base is 19-1/4" wide by 32" long


  • Walnut top measures 36" by 21"



Btw, you can click on any of the images in the first post of this thread and you will be taken to more pictures.

Thanks.

Joe

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

#14

Thanks all for the suggestions/advice!

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

#15

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

Ralph in Santa Ana

>Thanks Joe, that really helps me out!

Ralph

Re: Couple questions about Walnut and glue

#16

You're welcome. Good luck.

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>