Re: Stupid Pop Woodworking email/Jet Ad... Spammin
Rod Fitzsimmons Frey
>I got the same ad this morning. I'm not interested in Jet products or in buying a table saw right now. I couldn't disagree more about whether it's appropriate or not, though. Here's why it doesn't bother me:
When I buy a magazine, I get a heavily subsidized price because the advertising pays for much of the printing, production, etc. About 5% of the ads are relevant to me and I read them: the rest is not and I ignore them.
I subscribe to the Popular Woodworking email newsletter as well. Production costs are much lower for an email newsletter, but so is the price: it's free to me. There are costs, though, and those are covered by a bit of advertising here and there, including the JET ad this morning. That's right and proper: PWW is providing excellent value to me, and they need to get paid for the value.
I believe that we should not lump all email advertising under the same label. It seems like we have been trained to label any email that we weren't expecting as 'spam'. It's my opinion that this tendency stems from the origins of the Internet in university labs. I've been on the net for long enough to remember the debate about whether there should even *be* a .com designation, whether for-profits should be allowed to use the net. The shock and horror among the comp-sci intelligentsia when the corporate side of the net began to really take off was something to behold.
But it's corporate use of the net that gives us $40/mo high speed access, that's led to the profound changes that the net has brought. And that's fueled by advertising.
There's a world of difference between the JET ad and, for example, the various male-enhancement product ads that land in my inbox. The latter are random, completely untargeted, and simply exploiting the odd economics of the Internet (free communications). The former is part of an implied contract I have with PWW, and is much more analogous to the magazine ads than the Viagra ads.
In short, I encourage everyone to challenge the meme that categorizes all email advertising as evil. There's spam, which is annoying but hardly more, and there's advertising, which is the source of all sorts of good things including affordable magazines, wonderful websites, livings for people like Chris Schwartz who can make a living wage working wood and writing about it (not to mention all the other employees and their families at various publishers), inexpensive and increasingly high-quality woodworking equipment, and so on. I welcome the JET ad, because it is evidence that the high-quality PWW newsletters are economically viable and will continue to land in my inbox.