HSS turning tools
Nick
>I read about high-speed steel turning tools in the turning archive recently. The author seems to have fallen under the spell of the tool manufacturers. Contrary to popular opinion, high-speed steel is not appropriate for wood turning tools and is not the best steel for making them.
HSS is made for metal-working tools because it holds its temper to much higher temperatures than other tool steels, which lose their temper in the 300-500 degree range. HSS can run much hotter. If your wood-turning tools are running in that range, then you work is smoking (except for cherry, which burns when you look at it funny). HSS is just not needed for most woodworking tools.
The problem with HSS is that they don't take as sharp an edge as some other tool steels and they don't hold the edge as long. On the other hand, HSS is better than plain carbon steel (e.g., 1095), which makes really poor edge tools compared to modern tool steels. The folks who make plane irons have finally arrived in the 20th century and now use A-2 instead of 1095. A-2 holds an edge much longer and it's not even the best of the edge tool steels.



