Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

HSS turning tools

Posts

HSS turning tools

#1

HSS turning tools

Nick

>I read about high-speed steel turning tools in the turning archive recently. The author seems to have fallen under the spell of the tool manufacturers. Contrary to popular opinion, high-speed steel is not appropriate for wood turning tools and is not the best steel for making them.

HSS is made for metal-working tools because it holds its temper to much higher temperatures than other tool steels, which lose their temper in the 300-500 degree range. HSS can run much hotter. If your wood-turning tools are running in that range, then you work is smoking (except for cherry, which burns when you look at it funny). HSS is just not needed for most woodworking tools.

The problem with HSS is that they don't take as sharp an edge as some other tool steels and they don't hold the edge as long. On the other hand, HSS is better than plain carbon steel (e.g., 1095), which makes really poor edge tools compared to modern tool steels. The folks who make plane irons have finally arrived in the 20th century and now use A-2 instead of 1095. A-2 holds an edge much longer and it's not even the best of the edge tool steels.

Re: HSS turning tools

#2

Re: HSS turning tools - somewhat disagree

Larry Clinton

>Nick, the main reason many tools are made from "HS" steel is not their performance during use, but the ability to grind them without loosing temper. I have been grinding tools for many years and it still is quite easy for me to accidentally bring up a tool to 300 Deg. (Yes, I do grind with soft coarse white wheels (even on my surface grinder). Also much is touted about the ability to bring a tool to a razor edge. This is in fact not necessary - nor really desirable in many cases. As an experiment bring a chisel or plane blade to a razor edge & shave some hair. Then use the tool - make a couple paring cuts with the chisel or a couple passes on oak with the plane blade. Try shaving your arm again - bet you don't loose any hair. Edge holding ability involves many things, including the hardness, abrasive resistance, chip resistance etc. Carbide works very well in many tools - including some turning tools, saw blades, router bits - yet it will readily chip if brought to a razor edge. I have used most all of the various grades of steel during my manufacturing Engineer career, sometime one will really surprise you in an application. I have used S7 - a spring type material and found it has some of the best abrasive resistance of any steel - including the graphite type steels. This was in a manufacturing application - not saying it is good for a cutting tool (although I may try some out someday. A2 (air hardening) and O2 (oil hardening) tool steels are a good choice for plane blades and other cutting tools - not because they will attain the sharpest edge or hold it the longest - but because they sharpen fairly easily and will take and hold an edge fairly well. Many other steels will take and hold a better edge - but could not easily be sharpened on normal equipment used by woodworkers.

Re: HSS turning tools

#3

mostly disagree

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>"Contrary to popular opinion, high-speed steel is not appropriate for wood turning tools and is not the best steel for making them." There is a wealth of data to refute this statement. Most of the high speed tool steels have elements that result in very abrasion resistant carbides which result in slower dulling compared to carbon steels like O-1. The same reason that M2 is almost universally used in jointer knives also makes it a good lathe tool steel. M4 is even better. What would you suggest for lathe tools, or any other woodworking application?

"The problem with HSS is that they don't take as sharp an edge as some other tool steels and they don't hold the edge as long. " Can you provide data to justify this statement? Steve Elliot did quantitative testing of edge sharpness and dulling and concluded that M2, 3V and similar steels could be sharpened to just as fine an edge as A2 or O-1. Furthermore, they dulled slower. If his web site is still up I suggest you go study his findings.

No doubt there are some high speed steels that are inappropriate for wood working, but the steels that are commonly used- M2, 3V,10V,M4 and the like- are used for sound reasons.

Re: HSS turning tools

#4

Re: HSS turning tools

Sean Troy

>Hmmmm, I guess all the turning tool manufacturers must be wrong. After all, some of them have only be making the tools for 100 years.

Re: HSS turning tools

#5

Entirely agree with "mostly disagree"

Forrest Addy

>

Re: HSS turning tools

#6

Agree with Bill

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>I turn a lot with tools made from M2, V15 and unknown (to me) HSS alloys and comercial and home made CS tools in A, O and W alloys. The V15 gouges hold their edge the best followed by the M2s. None of the CS tools come close. They may be able to be sharpened to a finer edge but won't stay that sharp for more than a few seconds on hard woods.

Re: HSS turning tools

#7

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: HSS turning tools

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Just because they make them, doesn't mean they use them as we (non-manufacturers) do.

Jason

Re: HSS turning tools

#8

Re: HSS turning tools - somewhat disagree

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>Edge holding ability involves many things...

Including deep cuts in hard exotic wood at surface rates around 1500 feet/min while changing between end and side grain perhaps 15 times a second? Seems like that might be hard on a sharp plane iron.

The geometry of the edge may more important than the level of razer-like sharpness for turning.

JKJ

Re: HSS turning tools

#9

Urban Mythe

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>It has been recited and repeated so many times that it has taken on a life of its own - "High carbon steel will take a finer edge than high speed steel." The reason most often cited is the smaller cyrstaline structure of the "softer" alloy. This is an example of faulty logic based on true but irrelevant information. It may well be true that HCS has a finer grain than M2 or the higher alloys, but it is a difference without any meaning because, notwithstanding what some may think, no woodworker sharpens tools to the molecular level. Turners, for instance, most often use 80 to 120 grit wheels. Some will go a bit further to hone a micro bevel with a 280 or 320 hone or hard Arkansas slip to remove the wire edge pushed up by the grind wheel. The point here is that a 100 grit wheel with leave a 100 grit edge on every tool it touches, no finer but no courser, regardless of the alloy.

It is simply impossible the get a finer edge on one alloy as opposed to another while using the same abrasive.

Re: HSS turning tools

#10

Agree with Bill

Brian in Brighton

>M2 offers toughness that oil hardening steels can't match. If I had my druthers about plane blades I would have chosen D2. It's tougher than A2 and is used for shearing machines and such. But the price is higher than A2.

Brian in Brighton

Re: HSS turning tools

#11

Re: Agree with Bill

Nick

>I agree with D-2. It is much better than A-2. I wonder what turning tools made of D-2 would be like. All my turning tools are made of 52100- easy to sharpen and holds an edge very well.

Re: HSS turning tools

#12

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Gee, Mark...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>There you go applying logic and common sense. We can't have that on the Internet.

Jason (pardon my sarcasm...)

Re: HSS turning tools

#13

Sorry

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>It's a bad habit of mine. I keep trying to turn my back on it, but it just keeps biting me. Damn inconvenient, for sure. |;-}}}

mm

Re: HSS turning tools

#14

Re: Here's a thought...

Marv

>I'm not a learned turner of wood. Done a little but nothing of any significance. I have a set of turning chisels I bought on eBay for $ 9.99. Every time I use one, I sharpen it. Do I put a razor edge on it, nope. I go to my grinder, make it shiney and touch it with a slipstone a couple times and I'm good to go. I have no idea what the steel is. Might even be coldroll for all I know. My point is, why get all caught up in the details as to what the steel is made of when we usually do some sanding on whatever we turn anyway? Keep it simple is my motto.

When I machine metal on a lathe, I stick pretty much to carbide.

Marv

Re: HSS turning tools

#15

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Here's a thought...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Your tool steel, ability to sharpen it, and your ability to apply can make the difference between going to the 40-grit gouge and the 220-grit gouge when you start to apply the "flexible tools".

Jason

Re: HSS turning tools

#16

Re: Here's a thought...

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>why get all caught up in the details as to what

>the steel is made of when we usually do some sanding

>on whatever we turn anyway?

I think a lot of that depends on the wood. For example, when turning hard, dense woods like flowering dogwood, cocobolo, ebony, etc, a smoothly sharpened and even a polished edge will allow cutting a surface that needs little or now sanding. Yesterday I turned a number of little finger tops from black locust and went directly from the tool to 1000 grit paper, just to knock off the sharp edges. The same cut with a coarsely ground edge will require a significant amount of sanding. Similar to a cabnet-scraped flat surface, the surface seems to look better without sanding, too. (The surface you can get with a polished skew chisel is incredible!)

The popular Tormek sharpening system, in fact, provides a rotating leather polishing wheel to use after sharpening to an already amazingly clean edge. They claim that polishing the edge gives other advantages as well - a stronger and more durable edge, and more efficient cutting due to decreased friction. They recommend polishing, or honing, until all sharpening marks scratches are removed. (I believe this is similar to the way wood carving tools are prepared.)

BTW, a number of turners seem to do as I do - sharpen when needed but touch up the edge with a very fine diamond many times between sharpenings. There is a lot of discussion about sharpening for turning the the Turning message board here.

JKJ

Re: HSS turning tools

#17

Hold That Thought...

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Marv,

Sharpening is a core skill for turners. The difference between a properly ground edge and merely a "sharp" tool is surprising to many turners. Can't comment on your "good-to-go" without seeing the tool, but I'll suggest you get hold of a good tutorial on turning tool sharpening. You can also click on the Tool Grinds Library over on the left side of your screen. Turning can be a huge amount of fun or it can be drudgery, all depending on the efficiency of the tool and how it's ground. Take some time and learn to grind. You'll save yourself a lot of effort when the tool does most of the work.

mm