Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

OT - Solar Battery Top-Off for Generator? *LINK*

Posts

OT - Solar Battery Top-Off for Generator? *LINK*

#1

Brian McKearney

OT - Solar Battery Top-Off for Generator? *LINK*

Brian McKearney

>This is pretty much off topic, but I value the opinions of those on this message board.

My parents live in a fairly remote area and have a generator for backup as the power often goes out for varying periods of time. My Mom recently asked me to check out the generator to make sure that it will start for winter, and I realized that the problem is that the generator has an electric start, but doesn't get used often enough and the battery typically goes dead. I saw a solar battery top-off system in the Harbor Freight catalog recently and was wondering if it would be a wise idea to mount a solar panel to the roof and just keep something like this constantly connected to the generator battery to keep it fully charged and ready to go whenever it's needed.

Would something like this (see link) work and is this something that could just be connected and forgotten, or is there more to it? Could I safely connect a solar panel like this to the battery while the battery is still connected to the generator, or would I need to disconnect the battery from the generator while it's charging from the solar panel? I don't want to damage the generator, but it would be great if I could keep the battery ready for action at all times.

Is this a good idea? Would I need something a little more expensive than the one in the link, or is that one sufficient?

Brian


Solar Battery Charger at Harbor Freight

Re: OT - Solar Battery Top-Off for Generator? *LINK*

#2

Re: OT - Solar Battery Top-Off for Generator?

Ron Hildreth

>Brian,

I've never had a solar set up like the one you're looking at, and it might be a good way to keep the battery charged. One other alternative that I use successfully on both my Harley and my Dad's motorhome is a battery tender, which is nothing more than a glorified trickle charger. It has a built in sensor that will charge the battery when it needs it, and goes to standby mode when the battery is charged. You plug it in and forget it. Drawback, of coarse, is having to run an extension cord. It does a good job in not only keeping the battery charged, but prolonging the life of my battery. My 2000 Harley is now seven years old and I'm still on the original battery. That's unheard of in the motorcycling community- it should have died three years ago, even though it's a dry-cell battery. Dad's motorhome batteries are new two years ago, so the jury is still out on those, but wouldn't suprise me if they hang in there for a lot longer than usual, too.

Most motorcycle shops, dealerships, hardware stores, even Wallyworld carries them for around $20-25 bucks.

All of that, just to add some brain fodder!

Ron in Iowa

Re: OT - Solar Battery Top-Off for Generator? *LINK*

#3

Re: OT - Solar Battery Top-Off for Generator?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>battery tender

I second the motion on the battery tender. I have several of these and they work well. They will ever overcharge, a sure battery killer.

JKJ

Re: OT - Solar Battery Top-Off for Generator? *LINK*

#4

Re: OT - Solar Battery Top-Off for Generator?

Tim Caley - North Litttle Rock

>One thing you have to watch for when buying these. My son bought one because his car alarm keeps running the battery down. You have to make sure that your cigarette lighter has power when the car is turned off otherwise it won't work. The lighter must have a direct path to the battery.

Re: OT - Solar Battery Top-Off for Generator? *LINK*

#5

SO----------

Ron Hildreth

>You have to make sure your battery is charged, so the cigarette lighter works, so you can plug in the solar panel, so the battery stays charged!

I think I'm dizzy!!

Ron in Iowa

Re: OT - Solar Battery Top-Off for Generator? *LINK*

#6

missed your question

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>Could I safely connect a solar panel like this to the

>battery while the battery is still connected to the

>generator, or would I need to disconnect the battery

>from the generator while it's charging from the solar panel?

Brian,

Sorry, I didn't read your message carefully and missed this question. If your's is anything like my generator, the battery is only connected to the generator through a relay engaged by the starting switch. When the switch is off, the battery is disconnected so any charger you connect will not affect the generator. BTW, I do NOT disconnect the battery from my generator (or 4-wheelers, etc) when using the Battery Tender mentioned above.

What you didn't ask and what I don't know without asking my favorite power electronics consultant is if starting the generator with the solar panel connected will damage the panel! My generator charges the battery during operation, so it will apply voltage and try to dump current back through the battery and through the solar panel if connected. My gut feeling is it will not hurt the panel since a commercial battery charging panel probably has a blocking diode built into the circuit. (Without a blocking diode, the battery may discharge through the solar panel anyway at night so the thing would be not be too useful.) But read the manual first if possible.

JKJ

Re: OT - Solar Battery Top-Off for Generator? *LINK*

#7

Re: OT - Long battery charger stuff *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>What you want to do is put the battery on 'float' charge. I think you would be better off with a battery tender for about 30 bucks. It has a fairly sophisticated temperature compensated charge controller built into it. It will charge the battery until it detects a fully charged condition and then will switch to a 'float' charge voltage which will maintain the battery. Keeping the battery on 'float' will also help prolong the life of the battery better than periodically charging the battery and then letting it sit and self-discharge, and better than simply leaving a trickle charger connected. Unless the Solar charger specifically states that it provides for a controlled 'float' charge voltage, it is just a trickle charger, and not the most reliable method of insuring a good battery when the power goes off.

Here�s a link to the battery tender website and some good battery charging information.

One of the Battery Tender Jr. models should suffice and I have found them online for 20-30 dollars.

I have no affiliation with the company, other than being a satisfied customer. I do have experience in the power industry, including a number of years with a company whose business is industrial battery monitoring equipment for critical power systems, switchgear, Data center backup power, etc. My apologies on this wordy reply, but my experience in the battery monitoring industry has left me with a passionate understanding of the too often ignored complexities of the 'lowly' lead acid battery.


http://batterytender.com/battery_basics.php

Re: OT - Solar Battery Top-Off for Generator? *LINK*

#8

Re: OT - Solar Battery Top-Off for Generator?

DB

>I have three suggestions for you.

#1 Run the generator at least once a month.

#2 If possible bring the battery inside a garage.

#3 Connect the batery to a battery charger (small inexpensive one would be fine about $25.00).

I always disconnect the charger when testing the generator to make sure the charger does not get damaged from the high current draw on start up. When the power goes out you do not need to worry about the charger as it is already disconnected from the power.

Re: OT - Solar Battery Top-Off for Generator? *LINK*

#9

Brian McKearney

Re: OT - Long battery charger stuff

Brian McKearney

>Bob,

You (and several others who have replied - thank you) obviously know much more about this topic that I (thus the reason for my question). Any thoughts about leaving a device such as you mentioned connected to the battery while the generator is running?

The problem that I'm attempting to solve is that I've got a couple of elderly parents who live in a rather remote location and my Dad is not well. So, in the event of a power outage, I'd like to make as simple as possible for my Mom to go out and start the generator. My first concern is whether or not the battery will be charged enough to use the electric start on the generator.

If I can minimize the amount of connections/disconnections in the whole process, then all the better.

Brian

Re: OT - Solar Battery Top-Off for Generator? *LINK*

#10

another consideration

Curt Harms

>I don't know about newer generators, but some,if they aren't used periodically, will somehow lose a field so that even though running fine, they won't put out electricity. The fix was/is to touch a battery to something in the generator to restore this field so it would generate properly. Obviously I don't really understand generators but I remember that the simplest fix was to simply run them monthly. It seems like starting it every few weeks and put some sort of load on it, light bulb or whatever, would be good insurance. It would also insure that the operator remembers how to operate it.

HTH

Curt

Re: OT - Solar Battery Top-Off for Generator? *LINK*

#11

Why bother with solar?

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>Where I work we have several back up generators and Auxilary desiel engines. The batteries are on trickle chargers / battery tneders. They are not unhooked when the engines start.

My question is why solar? When the power is on the charger is keeping the battery full, the power goes off, the generator is started and keeps the battery full, so why a solar charger?

Periodic operation and maintenance is a good thing, however. Battery terminals need to be kept clean etc.

glc

Re: OT - Solar Battery Top-Off for Generator? *LINK*

#12

Brian McKearney

Re: OT - Solar Battery Top-Off for Generator?

Brian McKearney

>Thank you for all the responses. I received some good info and good ideas. I'll investigate and hopefully come up with a good solution soon.

Brian