Re: Trying to achieve this look
Joe Burke
>This is one of those times when we'd like for finishing to be less involved that it really is. There are so many variables.
As Bill said, the most important thing is to practice on a lot of scrap before you try anything on your cabinets.
The photograph shows something that I'd bet has been stained with an NGR stain (non grain raisng) which dries so fast it almost has to be sprayed, and then toned. Toner being pigmented finish. The NGR stain also yeilds a more even color.
I'd try what Bill suggested with maybe one change. I've had good luck using a washcoat of thinned shellac to even out the color and control absorbtion. You can get Sealcoat, a Zinsser product at most big box stores, which is a shellac product. Thin it at least 50/50, or more, with dentaured alcohol and brush or wipe a coat onto the wood. After it's dry, scuff sand it to smooth the raised grain and then apply your stain.
I also like gel stains, but you could try anything.
The photo shows something pretty dark, and coming close to that while getting even color will be the challenge. If one coat isn't dark enough, apply a thinner coat of the Sealcoat and then stain again.
Now, some gel stains, like Bartley's, contain some urethane so that they can be used as a stand alone finish. If you used one of those, I don't think you'd need to washcoat between stain applications. However, if your stain is only a stain, you'll need the washcoat to keep the second coat of stain from reactivating the first coat. If the second coat reactivates the first you wind up moving around one thick layer of stain as opposed to darkening with two layers.
See what I mean about this being invloved?
After you're happy with the color you can leave it if you've used something like Bartley's. Or you can apply a topcoat over the Bartley's. Or you might need to seal the stain in with another washcoat and then topcoat,
Simple right?
FWIW .... If I had to do this I'd washcoat it and then shoot it with some NGR. Then tone and topcoat. But I have a finishing room full of spray equipment and industrial coatings.
You can get there with the Sealcoat and gel stain too. It's just a different process.