Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Yellow Birch and glue

Posts

Yellow Birch and glue

#1

Yellow Birch and glue

Ron Bauman

>I periodically run across warnings about gluing yellow birch. I've never had any trouble myself, but am about to acquire a fair amount of 8/4 stock and am wondering before I start working it what the warnings pertain to. I'd hate to get a ways along on a job and find a problem that could have been avoided by using the "right" glue. Any knowledge you've got would be appreciated.

Re: Yellow Birch and glue

#2

Ellis Walentine

New one on me

Ellis Walentine

>I never had any trouble gluing birch. I'll be curious to know if anyone else has heard negative reports.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Yellow Birch and glue

#3

New one on me also....

Link Van Cleave

>Why would it be any different than hard maple. It isn't. Never had a issue with it.

Link

Re: Yellow Birch and glue

#4

Re: Yellow Birch and glue

David Yoho

>Ron, could you dig one of those warnings up and report back? I've glued a lot of birch through the years and never had a single problem.

David

Re: Yellow Birch and glue

#5

Could it be....

Jack

>Hi Ron

Could it be that the posts you saw were not about solid birch but about the prefinished yellow birch plywood that's imported from Asia? There are frequent posts about this on other forums. Nothing, that anyone would want to use, will stick to that finish.

As for solid birch lumber, I would have to vote like Ellis and the others. Never had a problem.

Regards

Jack

Re: Yellow Birch and glue

#6

David

Ron Bauman

>David: Odd that you should ask as I was just looking at a couple of sites and found this http://www.righteouswoods.net/birch.html if you read down you'll see a warning. It's not the first time I've seen it. Strange though, that no one else has; and I've really never had problems, but didn't want anything to dissemble after it left my hands.

Re: Yellow Birch and glue

#7

Ellis Walentine

All my resources...

Ellis Walentine

>...and my experience with birch indicate that it glues well. A couple sourcebooks mentioned that close attention to gluing conditions is recommended. I don't know what that means. Usually when I prepare something for gluing, I make sure the joint fits together seamlessly and without any clamping pressure at all before the glue goes on. I always make sure I'm working within the temperature range of the glue, which I define as 60° to 90°.F for most glues. And, when I clamp the joint, I make sure the clamping force is adequate but not too tight and that there is no bowing or skewing of the joint as a result of lopsided clamping force. Maybe that's why I never had any trouble with birch, but I wouldn't worry too much even if you don't get everything just right prior to glue-up. Despite what some say, birch is a friendly wood to work and to glue. The one thing you should watch out for, especially if the wood is figured, is warping. Make sure your piece is designed so that long or wide pieces of birch are properly bounded by frames or battens or breadboard ends and so forth. Unsupported boards that aren't seasoned well are more likely than other similar species to twist, at least in my experience.

Have fun.

Ellis

Re: Yellow Birch and glue

#8

Re: Yellow Birch and glue

Howard Acheson

>Go here to the Wood Handbook published by the US Forest Service Wood Products Lab. See page 7 Table 9-1

http://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/documnts/fplgtr/fplgtr113/ch09.pdf

Yellow Birch is listed as one of the harder to glue woods but also included in the same list or other hard woods like beech, maple, cherry and oaks.

BTW, hard maple is the wood used by most adhesives manufacturers to test the strength of their adhesives because it is a harder wood to glue.

Re: Yellow Birch and glue

#9

Difficult to glue...

Kneale Brownson awaiting snow in N. MI

>isn't really a "warning". I'd guess the difficulty they envision is in having the kind of straight joints that fit together completely with no need to press them together, like Ellis describes. Like the splitting on nailing, I've seen birch glue-ups split in the middle of the boards. I presumed from stresses created by forcing the pieces together at the glue joint.

Re: Yellow Birch and glue

#10

Re: Yellow Birch and glue

Ron Hildreth

>I just recieved my newest issue of FWW. It has an article in it about glue-ups, relative to wood species and the right clamping pressure for each. Might be what you need to be sure gluing up birch won't cause any problems later.

Ron in Iowa