Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Spalted Black Locust

Posts

Spalted Black Locust

#1

Spalted Black Locust

Kris Lasure

>I stopped by a local sawyer last night and he had two very nice boards around 10 BF total of 4/4 spalted black locust. I didn't have a camera to take any pictures, but they would make great panels or such. Thing is he was asking $160 for both and I got him down to $100 for the pair. Still $10 per BF. At that cost I would saw them up for veneer to maximize the use out of them, but just seems pretty steep for the price. I figured I would stop by in about another month or so to see if they are still there and see if I can get the price down more. Do any of you have any experience with pricing black locust especially spalted? I wish I could post some pics to give a better idea of what they look like. Both are 8" - 10" wide. One is 5' long and the other 8'. Spalting all the way through. Two small knots in the entire board. Beautiful looking lumber.

Is his cost way out of line?

kl

Re: Spalted Black Locust

#2

Re: Spalted Black Locust

Ray Binnicker

>Kris,

I've worked with Black Locust a little. I've never seen it spalted. This certainly doesn't mean it don't spalt. As far as the price; I've always found Black Locust to be pretty reasonable. Those prices you gave seems a little high to me.

Ray Binnicker

Re: Spalted Black Locust

#3

Yikes! I'm skeptical

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>First, I am skeptical you saw spalted locust. Spalt is a result of mold invasion (rot would be another name for it) and I have never seen this kind of mold invade heartwood. Locust is mostly heartwood and exceptionally rot-resistant heartwood at that. I find it inconceivable that locust can spalt. This condition is associated with the woods that have mostly sapwood and hence are easily invaded by fungus- maples, box elder, willow and the like.

There are two ways to look at this "opportunity".

In general moldy locust, or any other species, is of no value to a saw mill's typical lumber customers. In fact, locust boards of any kind are of little value to a mill's typical customers. Locust is coarse, dark unattractive yellow and hard to work. (After weathering though it begins to look like Teak and I have used it to good effect his way). In most situations this material would be headed for the firewood pile or chipped for paper.

However, if one has something unique in even one person's eyes, then it acquires value beyond normal reason. I have spent lots of time around mills and especially small ones will take the trouble to set this unique stuff aside hoping some person comes along that sees value in it. If you can put this wood into some piece where it adds $10/bd of value then you should buy it and the mill will also be delighted to get $10/bd for otherwise valueless material. The sale will provide endless entertainment during break time at the mill, and if used to good effect, admirers of the furniture will marvel that you were able to find such a perfect pattern for the door(or whatever).

The bottom line is that while I would not pay $10/bdft for moldy locust that fact has no relevance to what it could be worth in your furniture.

Re: Spalted Black Locust

#4

Re: Yikes! I'm skeptical

Kris Lasure

>Thanks for the response, Bill. Even the sawyer said he was surprised to see it when sawed the log. He said he started throwing certain pieces on the burn pile as he pulled them off the saw, then these last couple of boards had the spalting all the way through. He mentioned that these last couple of boards came off one side of the log and that was the only area where it was spalted. I'm thinking back now and don't recall seeing the greenish tint to the wood that I believe locust heart wood has. It was more yellowish in color. He had taken and wiped olive oil over the best surface to show the grain which made "pop" even more. I found some pricing online for around 3.50 BF for plain sawn black locust. As you mentioned, beauty is in the eye of the beholder. I'm not really prepared to pluck 10/BF down for this either, but we'll see how long he hangs on to it. If I get a chance I'll get some pictures someday and post.

Re: Spalted Black Locust

#5

rare

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>I have never seen spalting in black locust, although the logs do rot from inside frequently. But the rot I have seen is unusable brown bark like crapola.

The point is this: there is very little reference out there for pricing this kind of unique material (assuming it is what he says it is). As Bill mentioned, you might be the only one they find who is interested. But if somone else comes along and gets it, ask yourself how much you would care. If you would miss it, I'd go and negotiate the best price you can and stash it. You either take advantage of wood opportunities or stand around talking about fish that got away.

Re: Spalted Black Locust

#6

Re: Yikes! I'm skeptical

Robin Corell, in Atascadero CA

>I too am skeptical thet the wood you saw was spalted Black locust. I will contradict Bill and add that I have frequently seen spalting in heart wood. I happen to have a birch log that is entirely spalted, in fact it is so spectacularly spalted that I have been saving it to use as oyster veneer.

I have also seen a lot of pics and refrences to honey locust that was labled as black locust. I think some of the confusion is due to identyfying the trees by the presence or absence of 2" thorns. My guess is that the thorn issue is due more to confusing cultivars with true wild trees and is not a reliable identifyer. To really know what type of locust it is you have to open it up and look at the wood. True black locust(robnia psudoacacia) has brownish black streaks running through the heart wood. The sap wood is usually very little and is a creamy off white color. By very litle I meanit probalby measueres aout 1.5" on a moderate size tree.

I will also contradict Bill and add that black locust is a dream to work with. It turns nicely and even carves moderately well. there are few domestic woods that exceed the spectacular polish that black locust will take. I have had other wood workers look at a piece of it and think it is a tropical exotic. I think the reason many wood workers feel black locust is dificult to work with may be due to working with wood with too high of a moisture content. of all the woods I have milled black locust by far takes the longest to compleately dry. Almost 2x as long as most other woods.

The only advise I would offer regarding your wood in question is that $10/bf for green seems a bit excessive, but it does come down to the singularity of the wood. if it is truely spalted Black locust of if it is even a spectacular piece of non spalted locust it is worth what you atre willing to spend on it and what you think you can get out of it. I local sawyer once had a black locust log that looked like brazilian rosewood. I still wish I had some of that log.

The pic is of a pair of stools made from Black locust and finished with Jasco brand tung oil. you can soo some of the dark streaks on the seats and on one of the legs.

Robin


img

Re: Spalted Black Locust

#7

Re: Spalted Black Locust

Jim Dillon

>Kris,

While I can't speak to the question of spalted locust, my wife and I put down over 400 square feet of T&G 3/4-inch random width black/honey locust in our cabin. We paid around $3.50/square foot IIRC. It was vintage wood and may have come from the floor of a machine shop as there were oil(?) stains in spots. Personally, I think it is a very nice looking wood with either an oil or polyurethane finish. I don't recall any difficulty working with it using power tools other than it is very, very hard; it makes great drawer runners. I wish I had more of it.

Jim

Re: Spalted Black Locust

#8

Re: Spalted Black Locust

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>I wish I had more of it.

Where do you live and how much are you looking for?

I saw black locust occasionally - it makes fabulous garden stakes, fence stretcher sticks, and fence posts. Great for blocks to pound on and for things that stay out in the weather or in contact with the ground. Due to the way it grows, I find it hard to get wide clear boards from even a large log but the last time I got some nice 6x6s - I have a few more logs from the same tree.

BTW, it's a real pain in the neck to saw because it's so hard and because it dulls the bandsaw blade quickly. I had to go real slow and change the blade often or the cut would wander all over the place.

JKJ

Re: Spalted Black Locust

#9

Re: Spalted Black Locust

Jim Dillon

>JKJ,

Many thanks for your kind offer but I better take a rain check. Right now I am literally stumbling over wood in my garage shop and I really would like to think (dream ?) that I can still fit my car in. If the situation changes, I'll e-mail you fully recognizing that the wood may be gone. As an aside, I fashioned some leftover locust flooring into stiles and rails in combination with a spalted sycamore door panel and I thought it looked very nice. And I've often wondered how it turns. Just in case, I pulled a few chunks from the firewood pile to give it a try "someday". BTW, my shop is in northern Virginia 20 miles west of Martinsburg.

Thanks again,

Jim

Re: Spalted Black Locust

#10

Re: I'd bet its Honey Locust

Larry Clinton

>I have seen some spalting in some of the honey locust we have purchased. At our local sawmill, they have Black & Honey locust in the same bin. Your statement that it is more yellow (may have some pink in it too) indicates it is Honey Locust. I haven't seen any Black Locust spalted. Around here Locust is cheaper than most of the other lumber - thinking its around $1.50 bf for 4/4 KD. My son & I have used quite a bit, the Black machines much better than the Honey.

Re: Spalted Black Locust

#11

Re: Checking Locust

Larry Clinton

>By the way an easy check for Honey VS Black locust. The Black has closed Tyloses (sic) like White Oak. The Honey Locust has open tyloses like Red oak. If you can get a small chunk, you can blow through the Honey Locust.