>A couple questions about a Maytag furnace and carbon monoxide detectors.
First, carbon monoxide detectors. Is it really necessary to have a detector that sounds an alarm at 30 ppm and costs almost $200? This is what our furnace man is trying to sell us. Of course, they got a great deal by buying a truckload of them so they can sell them at $189 instead of the going rate of almost $220. I cannot find a carbon monoxide detector online that costs that much. The most expensive one I have found is less than $100. If it is really necessary to pay $200 to keep my family safe I will gladly do that. I think they plan on that factor when they try to sell the detectors.
2) My furnace. 3 years ago I bought a Maytag furnace, brand spanking new, expecting it to last 20 years. Wednesday evening it stopped working. The furnace man came out yesterday evening and found a great big hole in the heat exchanger that you can poke a finger through. I had not gotten it serviced yet this year and they are saying that the reason there is a hole in the exchanger is because there was inadequate air flow, so it was my fault for not having adequate ductwork and keeping the filters clean. If this is actually the case then I will just look at it as an expensive lesson learned and go on from there, but I have never heard of a heat exchanger rotting through in 3 years. I have not looked for my papers yet to check the warranty on it but I am pretty sure it had a standard 5 year warranty on the heat exchanger. This would mean they should replace the exchanger even if the ductwork was supposedly inadequate I would think. In my opinion it is just plain rediculous for a heat exchanger to rot through in 3 years but then I don't know much about furnaces.
>I think I paid under $30 for my furnaceroom CO detector. It's been several years, but at the time I think it was rated the best available.
Did your "furnace man" install the one that has failed? If so, then he should have determined any inadequacies of the system at that time. My guess as to why the exchanger rusted out is that exhaust stack moisture was allowed to leak back into it.
>Sounds to me like you're getting yanked around by this guy. You do not need a $200 CO detector. Any name brand should meet or exceed the minimum requirements to keep you safe. Just read the instructions for proper placement. I would get in touch with the furnace manufacturer and ask for a list of authorized dealers in your area and get a second opinion. You might even ask Maytag how to best deal with the situation before involving someone else. They don't want unsatisfied end users or unreputable dealers.
Sounds like you need a new "furnace man" more than anything else. It was his J-O-B to assess your system at the time he sold and installed the furnace. If the unit was oversized (like that CO detector?), it's his fault for selling you more that you need or could use. Call the "real" Maytag factory rep for warranty service, and get a good CO detector for about $50.
As a Home Inspector, I see oversized furnaces regularly. The salesmen sell them by the "ton" as it were. Bigger furnaces fetch a bigger price. So many are oversized because they can charge more. Also, Americans believe bigger is better, so its an easy sell. Sometimes they do a really poor sloppy heat loss calculation and it indicates you need 68,000 Btu's, so rather than sell you a 64,000, they bump you up to 84,000, (just to be safe), then when they go the warehouse to get one the guy says, "we are out of 84's but we sill let you have a 120,000 for the same price." And you really needed a 50,000, so you end up with a furnace two and a half times bigger than you need.
We are fearful that if we put in a small furnace, we will freeze to death. Actually they are sized for the colder days so what happens is, on the coldest day of the years you are chilly for several hours until it catches. On any of the moderate days, you are comfortable and the unit is actually oversized.
Other problems involved are that older duct work may have been sized for heat only, not AC and it may be a undersized for the AC and it may not have proper insulation and an external vapor barrier.
The flue could be a huge issue. If you have insulated your house, caulked and added weather stripping, you might need a significantly smaller furnace. If you changed from oil to gas, you might have "chemistry" going on inside the flue. An oversized flue is not a good thing. The unit is supposed to heat up the flue and cause it to draw well. To little heat in the flue (smaller furnace or more efficient furnace) does not heat the flue and condensation occurs, drools back down and into the heat exchanger. The water is slightly acidic and will eat up the furnace.
Your new furnace may have assisted draft. (a little blower on the front that comes on first and establishes the draft and blows the fumes out.) It must be compatible with the flue. The flue must be "impervious". The liner must be water proof and there should be a trap in the system that catches any condensation and dumps it down the drain. Similar to a condensation line on an AC.
My point is that changing your old furnace to the one you have now was not as simple as yanking out the old furnace and installing a new one. They must consider the size of the heat loss and any improvements that might have made the house "thermally" smaller or larger. They must examine and improve the ducts as necessary. And they must be certain the flue is properly sized and suitable. BUT, under the pressure of the market place, they frequently ignored the ducts and the flue. You can imagine what a buyer might say if one company insists they need to reline and downsize the flue (for $750) and their competitor does not.
Did the company that installed your furnace buy a building permit? Probably should have. Did they actually get the inspections and pass them? You might get a hold of the Building Inspector for some help. Some of these guys are strong on this subject and proactive and some are rather poor. You may have to press for help.
I would contact Maytag as mentioned by others. (Mention to Maytag that you and your family were subject to death from CO, just to get them moving.)
I would contact any consumer protection service your state has.
And I would buy a name brand CO detector and follow the directions for installation and it should cost $30 to under a hundred. Get a recording one so it will record a little history for you and not just alarm and drive you nuts. (A properly burning gas furnace does not produce very much CO, but with a breach in the heat exchanger it is unlikely yours was "Properly burning".
After I had some facts together I would go back to the installer. Even a badly installed furnace should have lasted over three years.
Let us know how this sorts out. Try to make them "go back and do it right".
>a good Home Inspector. I don't know where White Pigeon is so I don't just happen to know one in your neighborhood. You could call some local Realtors and ask for the baddest, most dreaded HI in your area. The one they never recommend to their clients, but the one they call when their mother buys a house. And You can check on the ASHI Website, They have an inspector locator. (ASHI.Org) This is potentially complicated stuff and you need somebody strong on the subject.
>All of the above;-) When I changed my furnace a few years ago, I put in a high efficiency one that uses the PVC pipe for the intake and exhaust. When I did that, the only thing left on the flu was the hot water heater, so I had to have a liner installed to reduce the size of the flu since it was too big for just the water heater. I also have the drain mentioned, and it is amazing how often the pump runs to clear out water during the heating season.
>I would recommend the Nighthawk brand of CO detector. I'd recommend that you purchase a model that plugs into an outlet, and has a battery backup, and DO make sure that it has a digital readout...you can check peak levels and such that way. Also, I'd recommend that you DO NOT purchase a combination CO/Gas detector. They have become popular lately, but we have been on a lot of runs do to the gas portion malfunctioning (I work for the fire department).
Remember to place CO detectors in areas other than your furnace room...CO alarms should be in or near sleeping areas, for the obvious reason of waking you up. In the event of a furnace malfunction resulting in CO production, it will go throughout the home, and not be only upstairs or downstairs.
As with other chemicals, there are two bad ways to become hurt...an extrememly high level of exposure for only a brief time will obviously be bad...but so is a small amount for a long exposure.
Feel free to e-mail me for more technical details...our policy is quite precise on what we consider safe for public exposure.
>Keeping the filters clean allows adequate air flow, and saves you energy dollars. If you let them get REALLY dirty, air flow will be choked and the exchanger will overheat. Fact of life.
Just like maintenance on your car. If the engine on your new truck puked at 20,000 miles and you haven't changed the oil yet, it isn't really GM's problem because you failed to do the regularly scheduled maintenance in the manual.
Avoided or forgotten about machines will make their presence known at the least opportune time.
>I installed and serviced furnaces for over 20 years as a side job. I have never, ever heard of a furnace manufacturer that refused to honor a faulty heat exchanger due to improper installation (or any other reason). In fact all of the newer high efficiency units have a lifetime warranty on the exchanger. They normally have a period of so many years in which the exchanger and labor is covered - then just the parts. I am certain that if you contact Maytag, they will repair your furnace for free. As it appears you have a shyster for a furnace man, I would refuse any contact with him (except maybe in court). A good CO detector should cost between 30 and $100 MAX. As I would have absolutely no faith in anything the current shyster is saying, I would contact a reputable furnace man in your area and have the entire job inspected. As far as inadequate ducts or dirty filters causing heat exchanger failure - that is pure bunk. ALL furnaces have high limit switches that control the maximum temperature in the heat exchanger area. If it reaches that temperature the burner is cut off and the fan continues to run. The heat exchanger cannot be damaged. The only effects from inadequate air flow are higher heat bills (loss of heat out the chimney caused by the higher operating temperatures) and inadequate heating (you will be cold as the furnace can't force enough hot air into the rooms). The inadequate air flow would cause even more problems with the air conditioning. If enough air doesn't flow over the A-coil, the unit will actually turn into a block of ice and prevent any air flow. Obviously at that point you know the AC isn't working. Again - it cannot damage the air conditioner - just won't work in real hot weather. The chimney is another issue - but won't damage the unit. If the drain blocks, the furnace will have water back up into the chimney pvc piping. This will cause low or no air flow out of the chimney and the furnace chimney flow sensor will prevent the furnace from igniting or burning. Actually all installation instructions require that the chimney be installed so that the water condensed will flow back to the furnace and out the drain. Again this cannot cause premature heat exchanger failure as the furnace will not operate. I am sure the heat exchanger was defective when installed. All high efficiency units have corrosion resistant stainless steel - and have for several years - Due to the fact they don't have a standing pilot (which keeps the heat exchange warm and dry) they had a major problem with heat exchanger failure when they were first introduced some 30 to 40 years ago. The units were corroding and failing in a very few years. They quickly solved that problem with the newer stainless steel exchangers and promoted them with the lifetime warranty as people were weary of purchasing them. In my experience with hundreds of furnaces, I have never seen any heat exchanger fail in 3 years, (although I have seen a few defective new units). I, and other reputable furnace men, used purple smoke bombs to inspect questionable furnaces. This is a device put into the combustion chamber that puts out a dense non-staining smoke. If a crack or hole existed in the heat exchanger, the purple smoke would show in the fan area (return air area) of the furnace and at the hot air registers (and often quickly fog the room).
>How do you KNOW the heat exchanger failed? Did you see it yourself or did the furnace guy just tell you that it failed? I'm with Larry on this. There is no good reason to believe it failed. They had trouble with the early high efficiency ones rusting out because of the lack of a pilot and because they extracted so much heat from t he flue gasses that condensation was occurring in the furnace and the condensate was acidic. But as Larry says, this has been solved with Stainless and plastic which are immune to the water and acid. The guy you are dealing with might just be trying to trick you into a replacement unit under the warranty, or Not. Unless it was defective from the manufacturer, a failure is extremely unlikely. I am 99.999% sure Maytag will make this right. They don't want you posting the second part of this story on WoodCentral or anywhere else.
>My furnace guy called this morning and said that Maytag will replace the heat exchanger for "shipping and handling costs only". We kind of got into it over the phone this morning because I have quit being timid about such things some time ago. I pretty much just say how I feel about it and let the chips fall where they may. After discussing it with another furnace company I have decided to give the original furnace guy a good chance and the benefit of the doubt and let him fix the furnace. We apologized to each other for our behaviour (he actually apologized first) and he seems like a nice guy. He does know his business and has been working in the area for about 10 years I think. I will have to pay for labor to replace the heat exchanger, which is a chunk of money in todays world but it will not end up costing me nearly as much as I was afraid it would. Needless to say this has been an education for me and I will keep a closer eye on the furnace from now on.
I will look into the Nighthawk brand of CO detector. You know a lot of posts on this forum are off topic, but the one thing that binds us all together is woodworking. Plain and simple, there are a large number of experts in other fields reading Woodcentral and helping each other out makes life worth living. Thanks for all the input on the CO detectors, and also the furnace.
My house was built very inexpensively by a man who worked in a mobile home factory. I think it was actually designed to be used as a shop and then converted into living quarters. It has two stories, a crawl space, and a gambrel style roof. A small utiliy room off the side is a nice area for the laundry room and dog crates and such. Making a high dollar wage has never been that important to me, and so I found an affordable house. We are making it a nice and comfortable house over the years, but sweat equity takes time and money. Anyways, the small room where our furnace and water heater and softener are located has been a den of despair for some time now. Having the furnace torn apart has goaded me into planning on spending my day tomorrow filling in some drywall areas and then installing new flooring and paneling and ceiling tiles in the area. I'll have to move a drain pipe that runs right through the middle of the room; the dumbest thing I have ever seen anywhere I think. This will make me feel 100% better in short order. The furnace guy will lay out a new ducting design for better air flow in the house which should make the furnace more efficient and hopefully help it to last longer. I will work on installing the ductwork myself. Thanks again for your input; it really was priceless.
>Moses, when I have had warranty work done, the local wholesaler of equipment provided the parts and the contractor provided the labor. Replacing a heat exchanger should not take over a couple of hours. They should replace it at their expense.
Of course, this does not include any improvements you make.
>NOT cost you a dime. I would read my Warranty carefully. Most heat exchangers have a 5 year PARTS & LABOR warranty then a lifetime parts only. I still think the guy is a shyster.