Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

OT new computer - XP or Vista

Posts

OT new computer - XP or Vista

#1

OT new computer - XP or Vista

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>Looking to upgrade my tired old PC. I use Win2K at home and XP at work. I've heard alot of older software does not play well with Vista. Anybody have any experience on that. I do know that there has not been any service packs issued for Vista and that sorta scares me. Should I stay with XP-pro?

And no, I'm not interested in Macs or Linux.

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#2

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

Dan Donaldson

>I would go with XP. I recently bought a new dual core Dell with 2 gig of ram which came with Vista. I played with the Vista for a day or so, and it was a dog compared to my previous, much slower computer running XP. In my case, I didn't care because I wiped the Vista and replaced it with Linux, but if I were to have kept the Windows install, I think I would have preferred to have XP.

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#3

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

doug f, san clemente, ca

>Tim - While Vista is a cut above XP in performance, there are still a lot of bugs in the system. Some peripherals have a difficult time with it (printers seem to be especially susceptible). If you like XP Pro (I happen to love it), stick with it for the time being until Microsoft has its act together.

Doug

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#4

50% informed answer…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Upfront caveat: I know nothing of Vista—never looked at it, never considered it.

I was mad at myself when I missed the window last January of machines available at the various big boxes with XP. The very day Vista was officially announced, there wasn't an XP machine to be had, and I was in nearly desparate need of finally retiring my weary, nine year old 98SE workhorse (to say that it didn't owe me a thing is an understatement). All the seemingly knowledgable people were saying that Vista wasn't worth considering until at least one service pack had been released. Given that I've never been a bleeding edge adopter in the first place, however, I didn't give up.

I got to thinking—all of those big corporations with extensive IT departments who might need another machine or two certainly weren't going to go with Vista—too new, too untried. There must be someplace they would go for XP. Sure enough, prowling around the Dell website I found there were plenty of machines with XP available (long story short, there still are). I didn't look elsewhere, but I'm sure the story is the same with other computer retailers (Gateway, etc.).

So that's what I got—a Dell with XP Pro installed. When it came time a couple of months later to get a laptop, I got it with XP Pro, too. Nothing like similar systems to maintain (it gets worse—I just got my mother to get a new box, but with XP Home).

I've been through M$' antics for too many years to ever be one of their unpaid beta testers. I was a reasonably happy DOS 3.3 user (I probably used 3.1—that's too long ago—maybe used 2.xx, too), avoided 4 like the plague (thankfully, as it turned out), forayed briefly on a later version of 5—which wasn't bad, as I recall, waited on 6 although 6.22 turned out to be a very robust and stable DOS platform. It should go without saying that there has never been a windoze 3xx version which was used for more than five minutes on any machine of mine.

I was a reasonably happy user of 95 (given that I was dragged kicking and screaming from command line DOS, although, again, not early) and 98, then 98SE worked well for me for a long time. I am so glad I (almost) missed Millenium Edition. I say almost, because my mother's machine mentioned above was a big box ME version (H-P) which was just awful. That was no small part of the motivation to get her an XP machine.

I don't trust M$ and eventually will be able to say that without a lick of hypocrisy, as I am likely to go linux sometime (maybe soon). In the meantime, for the foreseeable future, XP is as far as I'm willing to go on the Redmond XPress.

If you read this carefully, you'll likely note the fact that, essentially, I'm a new user of XP, which means 100% of this post may be suspect, not the 50% advertised in the subject line.

Rod

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#5

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

Howard Norman

>I built a new system for myself about two months ago and installed XP Pro on it. Didn't seriously consider Vista. I am reasonable sure that you can get a new unit from either Dell or HP with XP installed. I still hear lots of problems with older printers and Vista.

I have installed Ubuntu (lixux) on a partition on this new computer but haven't done much with it yet. Maybe one of these days.

Howard

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#6

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

Stuart Johnson

>I went from Win 98 to Vista. While I don't use many of the features there as bits and pieces that have had a learning curve attached. I like the old explorer but so far I haven't had any real problems.

I have the old Adobe PhotoDelux that I really like that won't run. My HP Laser Jet 5 wouldn't connect but an update by either HP or Vista kicked in and it now runs. Some other programs such as Photo Shop will run but you need to download a patch. I don't like patches so I'm waiting for a new release prior to purchasing.

All in all I'm happy and since I never used XP I don't know if one is really better than the other.

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#7

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>I ordered a Dell XPS710 Quad Core a couple months ago. I ordered it with XP. I had the option of ordering it with either OS.

There's no compelling reason to go to Vista right now. At least for me. XP is pretty stable.

Good luck.

Joe

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#8

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

John Weber

>Tim,

I know you said no Macs, but I switched this year after 20 years with PC's. I bought an iMac and it's awesome, basic included software is great, although I did buy Office for the Mac to have Word and Excel. Networking and printing took a little while to set up with my PC home based network, but I'll never go back, and as we replace our old PC's I'll be buying Macs. I think for everyday use, the Mac operating system is just better. About the only drawback is high-end gaming, but I don't play games so it really doesn't matter to me. I've met a couple PC users that switched and still missed thier PC's, but for me I switched in May and glad I'm rid of of the MS ball and chain.

John

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#9

Windows '98 if you can find it !

Steve Mackay

>

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#10

Have the Best and Avoid the Worst of Both

Garrett in Victoria

>If you already have a licensed version of XP and are getting Vista with a new computer (or vise versa), you can download (free) Microsoft Virtual PC 2007 and run both operating systems on the same computer, switching back and forth between them with a key stroke or mouse click.

Cheers, Garrett

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#11

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

David Yoho

>My limited experience with Vista and reading I've done would lead me to say stick with XP-Pro. I have not been impressed at all with the new OS.

Businesses replacing computers or buying new are still going XP primarily because it's a proven product. Our local school district offices still purchase HP systems with XP-Pro installed.

I know you're not interested in a Mac, so for others, I've seen the improvement the new Leopard (Mac OS) has made on the Intel based Mac and it's incredible! Windows has NOTHING on this new OS from Apple. If I ever tire of XP, I'm probably going to go Mac. The new OS lets you work and play the way YOU want to and is heads and shoulders better than anything MS has done to date.

David

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#12

Re: I ordered new computer today

Theresa K

>I placed an order for a new computer today, and went with XP. I had been deliberating over Vista or XP for the last few days. Today I clicked the 'place the order' button...and had a bit of a queasy feeling, hoping I did the right thing. This thread has helped settle that queasy feeling immensely!

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#13

W98 was good but now it is too obsolete

Bill Howatt

>

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#14

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

Charles Yawn

>Tim, I just replaced my PC at home the first of October, and opted for the Vista operating system. It is not as stable and universally accepted as XP (which was on my old machine). I had to pay to upgrade several programs, download patches and spend a good bit of time figuring out how to make programs and Vista work right. Still doing that a month and a half later.

I recommend staying with XP until all the bugs are worked out with Vista. Charles

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#15

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

Larry Clinton

>My son is a certified MS professional don't remember all the sub certifications he has but he is in charge of this counties computer network. He tried one (isolated) computer with Vista - then reported back to Microsoft that it was not ready for the mainstream use. I just built a new dual core computer for myself a few months ago, I installed a new issue of MS XP-PRO. I really hated to get rid of the 98SE but too many new apps weren't available for it and security was becomming an issue. I purchased a used Dell Laptop for my wife last month, one reason I went used was that most of the new laptops come with Vista installed and I didn't want to fight the networking issues and printer drivers etc involved with Vista. I may go to Linux if Vista isn't squared away before XP is obsolete. May do it anyhow as the new "Lease?" issues with Microsoft software may make the determination.

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#16

Chet Kloss

Vista is better.

Chet Kloss

>Tons of it has been installed in businesses around the world. That was dramatically brought to light during Microsoft's last analysts call (and as a result their stock went way up - yippee, more tools for me).

You should go with whatever your comfortable with, but I would not bet against the thousands of businesses who have purchased it.

There will always be incidents of somebody's brother's friend's uncle who doesn't like it. That's inevetable but not really significant. It really is a much more important thing for businesses and they have voted loud and clear.

XP is good and Vista is better. If you don't go with it now, you likely will later.

,,,,,,,,,,,,,Chet

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#17

Hmmm…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>…that doesn't jibe with the article I just read (can't remember which rag—at the Dr's office). They had some startling comparisons of the difference between Vista's sales vs XP's sales since Vista's rollout, compared with XP's sales vs 98SE's sales for an equivalent time period immediately after XP's introduction. It was dramatic. XP blew 98SE away almost immediately in the second instance. In the current situation, XP is still blowing the competition away—this time against it's purported replacement.

Although I'm not an insider and you may be, it doesn't make sense to me for IT departments heavily invested in computers in general and a huge installed base of XP machines in particular to take a chance on a brand new OS less than a year old—particularly in light of M$' track record in the arena of unpaid, volunteer beta testers (that is first adopters who pay for the “privilege”). I keep hearing knowledgeable people saying, “wait for at least one service pack.” The fact that such a service pack will not only be necessary, but is historically inevitable, speaks volumes about the initial release.

Your assertions frankly sound like wishful thinking, and I apologize if there's hard evidence to back it up. But, if so many businesses are jumping on the Vista bandwagon, why are Dell's and other retailers' XP sales still robust? The bulk of those are almost assuredly business purchases. There aren't enough geeks around to account for enough demand to keep the option open otherwise.

Rod

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#18

Re: Hmmm�

Bill Howatt

>I think it is funny, or perhaps nostalgia is a better term, about how marvelous XP is. Well, it is pretty good but when it was first introduced its press was about the same as for Vista. Some apps won't run on it, the user interface is a bunch of eye-candy, too many bugs to be useful, and so on.

Sure Vista has problems. Anybody who writes anything major for the PC has problems due to the huge amount of different hardware and software that must co-exist in any number of combinations and permutations - and a lot of it supplied by low-cost manufacturers.

Corporations waiting for at least the first service pack is nothing new since they found out the hard way that being an early adopter is potential suicide. There is nothing like being responsible for a couple thousand PCs in a corporation and having any type of problem affect them all - a nightmare beyond belief.

Vista will get the kinks ironed out and when the next OS is released there will be all sorts of people who will be trying to buy Vista instead. I believe the termination date for the sale of XP by Dell and others is this January.

Bill

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#19

Re: Hmmm�

Dan Donaldson

>The fact that I was assuming that XP would be going away before too long is the main reason that I first investigated Linux. I wanted an alternative before I was forced into Vista. I have been using Windows since the very first and did some of the beta testing for the company I work for through the various versions. That was Windows 1.0, the Windows 286 then 386 then 3.1, then 3.11, 95, 98, 98se, (even, yechh ME), and finally XP. Each (except ME ;-)) was an improvement over the previous, and maybe Vista will be also, but I do not like the way that MS has implemented a lot of stuff in Vista. If you change too much in your system, you have to revalidate your install or it won't run anymore. In most cases, you get one revalidation, then have to buy it again. You can even get into trouble on some driver updates. Enough of them and Vista decides that you need to revalidate and it quits until you do. Basically, it means that you rent your computer from Microsoft, and if they don't like something that you are doing, they can shut you down any time they like. The worst thing about this is that it only affects those that are trying to be legal, the pirates have already got versions that work around this stuff.

The last computer I bought came with Vista. I played with it for a few days, but it was so slow and intrusive that I pulled the drive with it installed out of the computer, dropped in a spare 500 gig drive and loaded Linux. This is not a real gamer, but is a 1.8 gig dual core with 2 gig of ram and a fairly decent video, which should run fairly well, but was a dog with Vista. That was a clean install, with no tweaking on my part. It took over 3 minutes to boot from power on until everything was completely loaded. (the desktop came up sooner, but stuff was still loading in the background). My current setup gets to a full desktop with everything loaded and ready in less than 50 seconds.

I like to play around with my computers, which also means that I break stuff every so often. I cannot afford to rebuy my OS every time something breaks and I have to reload. I work in an area that has a lot of software developers around (I spent 8 years managing the development activities for a large OEM) and many of them are switching to either Linux or Mac's where they can for their own use.

Rant mode off ;-)

Each to his/her own. For many, Vista will be the cat's meow, but this last round of stuff was more than I am willing to put up with.

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#20

Bill Blasic

Re: Hmmm�

Bill Blasic

>Vista Sucks!!! It is so sloooow, a resource hog. XP is not the greatest but much better than Vista.

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#21

Re: Hmmm�

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>XP is not the greatest but much better than Vista.

Before I retired, I had a mix of dual-processor machines. XP on a new, very fast machine was clunkier than W2K on an slower machine. (My work was graphically and computationally intensive, not web surfing.)

Like much other software, every MS OS generataion accumulates more baggage, the designers relying on increases in hardware speed and memory to maintain responsiveness rather than invest the time and money to write efficient code.

JKJ

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#22

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Very true...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...about bloated code, but I can say this about XP. I upgraded to it from ME (ugh, shiver, suck thumb, cry for mommy). ME probably crashed on me an average of once a week on one computer--I run my (now 2, both with XP) computers 24/7 for the most part. I can't recall the last time that XP crashed to the point of unusable and a 3-finger salute was necessary (have rebooted a number of times to re-stabilized the system).

I don't even want to think about Vista--one of my computers might run it in a stripped-down mode, the other (laptop, 1.5GHz Celeron, .5GB RAM) probably won't (struggles with having 2 users logged on at the same time).

Jason

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#23

Chet Kloss

Re: Hmmm�

Chet Kloss

>Rod,

The hard evidence is in Microsoft's 10Q & 10K filed for this quarter with the Securities and Exchange commission. Those doc's are not opinions or wishful thinking.

According to their info, Vista is selling very well in businesses and has out-sold XP when compared to the same time in their respective releases.

All I'm saying is that businesses vote with their dollars and they're voting for Vista.

,,,,,,,,,,,,,Chet

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#24

A very irritating trend...

John in New Mexico

>One thing I used to love about the Open Office word processor that came with my various linux distributions was that it did not do any of that annoying windows crap, like automatically putting in todays date, or trying to force you into some kind of pre-determined formatting as soon as you started indenting things. More recent versions act like MS Word, though at least its still fairly easy to hunt down all these "features" and turn them off. But it does make me wonder why they add them in the first place.

Re: OT new computer - XP or Vista

#25

Old dog . . . yadda, yadda . . .

steve.mackay@earthlink.net

>if it ain't broke . . .