Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Sander question...

Posts

Sander question...

#1

Sander question...

Robert Henderson

>I already have a random orbit sander.

Is there any advantage to also owning a 1/4 sheet palm sander?

Re: Sander question...

#2

Re: Sander question...

Thomas S Stockton

>Probably not, the only thing I use my pad sander for is breaking edges. I find that pad sanders don't leave as nice a finished surface as a random orbital.

Tom

Re: Sander question...

#3

Re: Sander question...

Jim Dillon

>Bob,

I have both and find I don't use the 1/4-sheet sander much anymore, except, as Tom mentioned, breaking the edge. Even then, especially on critical areas, I'd use a cork block for far better control. The ToolsForWorkingWood web site has a nice cork block that fits my hand well. In thinking about it, I have used it more on small pieces of wood (puzzle pieces) and narrow pieces of wood (say, 1 inch wide) where the ROS footprint is too large. Just some thoughts.

Jim

Re: Sander question...

#4

Re: Sander question...

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Robert,

I use both orbutal and random orbital sanders. The orbital is great for corners and edges, and seems less aggressive that the ROS design. I find my 1/3 sheet orbital sander is excellent for leveling panels and table tops in the area of glued up joints. By having a wider and longer foot print, they level a larger area and are less prone to cause gulleys or divits along the glue line. If I could reasonably afford the big P+C 1/2 sheet orbital I would use that and retire my 1/3rd sheet Skil. One other observation: My P+C Speedblock 1/4 sheet sander is smoother and quieter that any of the DeWalt, P+C, and Ridgid 5" ROS machines I have in the shop. So, I use both designs depending on the task at hand.

George

Re: Sander question...

#5

Re: Sander question...

Lee Ohmart

>I have the PC ROS and Makita and a PC 1/4 sheet sanders. I like the ROS for larger areas and more aggressive removal of material. The ability to change grits fast and hook it up to the shp-vac are nice as well. The 1/4 sheet sanders excel at working more slowly using finer grits.

Re: Sander question...

#6

Re: Sander question...

Bill White

>Ditto on Lee's comments.

Bill

Re: Sander question...

#7

Re: Sander question...

Barry Irby

>I have a half sheet and 1/4 sheet sander and two five inch ROS. since I got the ROS about five years ago, I have not used either of the other two. I wore out one ROS, got another and then rebuilt the first.

Re: Sander question...

#8

Re: Sander question...

Bill Schreiber, Litchfield, NH

>Before my carpal tunnel issues, I would use my Palm sander for final rub out on finishes because it would take automotive wet/dry sandpaper. Of course now, I'm relegated to elbow grease, hand planes and scrapers to get it done. The results are the same, it just takes much longer.

Regards,

Bill

Re: Sander question...

#9

Nope, but to be fair

Michael Dresdner

>I should mention that my two favorite ROS are both Festool. They are fast, quiet, completely controllable and reliable. I have not picked up a jitterbug since I got them, except for photo shoots for articles.

Re: Sander question...

#10

Re: Sander question...

Robert Henderson

>Thank you all for your opinion!