Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

OT - DSL vs Cable

Posts

OT - DSL vs Cable

#1

OT - DSL vs Cable

Joe Pack

>I use Time-Warner (RoadRunner) for my internet connection. Fast and (usually, once equipment was updated on the utility pole) reliable. But it costs about $50/month. I received a mailing from Verizon for DSL at about half of that. The theoretical speed of the RoadRunner cable is about twice that of DSL, but Verizon says that is theoretical; in actual use, I would not notice an appreciable difference.

What say ye? Truth or snake oil?

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

#2

So what is the true speed....... *LINK*

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>While you can't test the Verizon DSL speed, you can test the RoadRunner speed. What speeds are you getting. Use the tools linked below to check if you need.

Is the DSL full DSL or DSL Light? Around here they have DSL-Lite with 1/2 the calories..... no wait, sorry, it's DSL-Lite for $25/month but it's slower than the normal 1,500Mbs speed for DSL.

Also around here they have DSL 3.0 (twice the speed) but Cable has 3.0 and 6.0 and I've not seen it yet but 9.0 as well.

Happy Woodworking!


http://www.outerlimitsconsulting.com/support/speed

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

#3

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

Tom

>Cable speeds will vary, depending on the number of people using it at the same time. DSL speeds should be constant.

You might want to ask your phone company how far you are from their co, and you can (maybe) extrapolate what your possible maximum speed might be with that distance. If a neighbor has DSL, you could also do a speed test at their house (portal.tds.net has one, there are many). DSL, if you're close enough, is always a better value than cable, as far as I can see.

You probably won't notice any difference (or much) between any broadband connection (even the 'lite' 768 tier) just surfing the net. Pages will open quickly, no matter what. If you do a lot of downloading the difference will be evident.

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

#4

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

Joseph Mulherin

>Another thing to consider....you have to have a telephone connection...double billing for phone and DSL too. I use the RR and am fully satisfied with it because it is on my TV cable setup too.

Whatever, cost is to be considered.....

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

#5

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable *LINK*

JohnKJordan in East TN

>It's all relative. My current cable ran 8 mb/s this morning (using Bandwidthplace) vs about 3 mb/s for the cable I had a few years ago. I thought the old cable was blazing fast. (Sure beat the ISDN I was using.) About the only time speed differences like that make a noticable difference is when moving multi-megabyte files over a really fast route.

However, most of the time the transfer is limited by the originating server or something along the route. (Do a traceroute on one of your favorite web sites for an eyeopener) The 8 mb/s I mentioned above dropped to 0.9 mb/s when I picked a server in Perth Austrailia. (And it's still amazing to me that something like that even works!)

Also, check to see if the DSL offer really is for your specific house. At one time I got periodic DSL offers from BellSouth but my street didn't qualify due the distance although a friend a 1/2 mile away used it.

Here's a comparison of cable vs dsl that appears to be reasonable:


cable vs dsl

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

#6

I didn't see much difference when I switched

Jack

>from TW cable to Verizon DSL

You know a T1 is only 1.5 mbps

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

#7

Re: Switched

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>From DSL to cable. We had frequent service and modem problems with our 510K DSL service. Went to cable and got download speeds between 8 and 12 meg and upload rate at 1 meg. There was a large difference in page-loading speed, and I get way more "waiting for [site]" messages than I used to. East of us they're moving in the fiber-optic stuff that will more than double or triple current cable speeds. The cable has been far more reliable than the DSL, but, as mentioned, if you're not pushing large data files in and out, the speed increase is not such a big factor.

mm

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

#8

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

David Sparks

>I switched from Comcast cable to Embarq DSL this past Spring. Major mistake! I've noticed a big reduction in download speeds, frequent dropped connections, and terrible customer service. At first the customer service was great, but as they got a lot of customers, the great service disappeared. I'll be dropping my Embarq landline and switching back to cable Internet in March when my contract runs out.

The only way I would recommend DSL is if it's your only option other than dial-up.

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

#9

DSL at my house, cable at my mothers...

John in New Mexico

>Not really any different. Cable seems slightly faster at low use times, like now, but if that's even real it would depend on where you are and how many others are also using it.

Personally, I stick with what you have. $50/month isn't that bad, and I tend to be a bit skeptical of "offers". They probably have a bunch of taxes that are not part of the price they advertise, but are included in the figure you're used to paying with the cable - not because the cable company is more honest about it, that's just the check you're used to writing.

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

#10

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

Stuart Johnson

>I just switched from Hughes Net satellite to ATT DSL. With Hughes I normally had 1450 down with a cost of about $85.00 a month. AT&T costs $25 (plus taxes) and I am getting 2500 down. The speed difference is enough to notice in both web pages and email.

As a side note if you do not have any other broadband available Hughes Net is a pretty good but expensive option. I canceled my contract early because I did need to reboot the modem three or four times a day. Even so it beat dial-up.

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

#11

For me, DSL is much more reliable

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>I had cable internet for a while. Got tired of all the service interruptions. Wasn't blazing fast because I wasn't paying for blazing fast, I got the intermediate speed account. Finally switched to SBC (now AT&T) DSL when it became available. I had to wait until they installed a local fiber mux in my neighborhood because I was too far from the Central Office. I now get very reliable, speedy access for $20/month. That's as long as I stay with AT&T for wired phone service. If we drop phone account, the DSL rate goes up accordingly. I don't recall ever having a service outage with the DSL.

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

#12

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

Larry Clinton

>I have the high speed DSL from AT&T (was SBC), my son who lives in the same small city has cable from Comcast. At times his is slightly faster - other times slightly slower. Ninety percent of the time the other end of the connection determines the speed so rather it is rather irrelevant. The reason he switched was that he no longer uses a land line phone service. The reliability of both services has been about equal - both very good. As I have a land line, I will only switch if it is quite a bit cheaper.

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

#13

Re: OT - Watch out for the contract gotchas

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I had Comcast (@Home, somebody else, AT&T Broadband) for over 9 years. The price never went down, that I can recall. Even though I asked. And when I bought a Sat TV connection to fix programming issues, I had to keep a basic cable connection, or pay for the difference in my cable internet bill.

Which I did for quite a while. But the service went to terrible, and the system would simply go away for 20 minutes to an hour, almost every morning. Rebooting all of the gear in the garage did no good. So there is now AT&T DSL running, at 3 mbps, and it's as fast as the supposedly faster Comcast was. At least as fast as I need, and half the price, or less.

But watch out for the connected gotchas...

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

#14

Thanks for all the information.

Joe Pack

>Looks like I have some reading to do.

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

#15

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I have verizon 1.5Gps DSl and all we had to do was plug each phone into a filter and the computer into their modem and about 5 minutes of setup in the browser. We ran a test and were getting 1.3Gps. I have a friend with cable high speed and it slows considerably when lots of people are on their computers at the time. My friend can tell when the kids get home from school based on reduced speed on downloads.

You also need to look at your computer speed and display memory. If your computer is slower or you have limited display memory then you won't see the difference when browsing.

Lee

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

#16

and another thing

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>DSL touts that you have a dedicated line while cable is shared with your neighbors, however both have a bottle neck at the head end where they connect to the internet. At that point everyone shares. You need to consider just how many connections each has and just how fast the connection to the internet is at that headend.

Also while cable is shared it is not necessarily a 3M or 8M all the way back to the headend. Here we have a high speed fiber backbone into the area with only a few people on each shared connection to the backbone.

Now as long as I have no neighbors downloading porn or movies when I an on all is well. I am paying for a 3M connection and getting slightly more most times.

Bill.

Who says the world is getting smaller? The airport is still 2.5 hours away!

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

#17

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

Bill Roland (Mt Juliet,TN)

>We have Bell South (AT&T) DSL6 at home and it is really fast compaired to what I remember cable at work. It has been really reliable. My wife uses it for work(Medical Transcription), with about 13 in the group, the cable ones lose it for hours sometime. We only lose it now and then during a bad storm for only a few minutes.

Look out for the true price of cable after the intro period.

Re: OT - DSL vs Cable

#18

From what I can see...

Dan Donaldson

>It looks like it depends a lot on where you are. For me, the whole area was updated with fiber a few years ago, and I can get cable or DSL for about the same price. I have Comcast, which came from Roadrunner in a buyout. There were some teething issues at first when ownership switched, but now everything runs fine. I usually have download speeds between 7 and 13 meg or so and between 750k and 3 meg on upload depending on conditions. The other night, I was uploading some articles images to the server and put 40 pictures up in less that 30 seconds. (yes, geek that I am, I timed it ;-)) That was with all of the server overhead for the uploads.

I know that some have significant problems with Comcast, and probably with most of the other vendors out there. It looks like the region that you are in makes a difference.