Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?
Barry Irby
>I have a long standing checking account with Suntrust. (Acct. NO. BR549 for those wishing to steal my identity)
On 10/29 I deposited X amount of money. Today I open an notice from the bank saying they are moving $900 from my overdraft protection into the account. (I have auto withdrawals for mortgages and investments come out of the account, so I thought they had beat my next paycheck to the bank.) So, on my way to a lunch meeting I run by the bank and deposit the next check and some other odds and ends including $900 in cash. During and after the meeting it occurs to me that something is wrong, so I go back to the bank.
They look it up. Oops! Heh, Heh! We made a mistake. Instead of depositing your check for X we with drew X from your account. It was the withdrawal of X that over drew your account, causing us to cover it by moving the $900. But its OK now because we put 2X back in your account. Hah, Hah?. Did you move the 900 back to my overdraft protection? Ah, no, you have to give us a check for that. Why? Because it would be more clear. A paper trail. I don't have a check with me. We will print you one. Clear as mud, a bizarre transaction and a homemade check. Ok, what about the fees. Uh, you don't think you should pay them? After all, your account was overdrawn. You are kidding, right? If you had deposited X instead of withdrawing it, I would have never been overdrawn. YOU over drew my account. OK, Ok we will replace the fees. Then there was a long discussion of codes and how to credit it and what account the money should come out of, etc.
So what do you think? Is this about the dumbest banking transaction you ever heard of? The part that amazed me was they did not want to just electronically move the money back to the overdraft account, but were willing to cover their mistake by depositing 2X as if that would be clear to all. Apparently they were willing to send me the form letter saying I had overdrawn the account but were not willing to call or send a letter explaining it. If I had just paid the overdraft back and paid the fees, they would have dismissed the whole thing. What now?



