Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

Posts

Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#1

Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

Barry Irby

>I have a long standing checking account with Suntrust. (Acct. NO. BR549 for those wishing to steal my identity)

On 10/29 I deposited X amount of money. Today I open an notice from the bank saying they are moving $900 from my overdraft protection into the account. (I have auto withdrawals for mortgages and investments come out of the account, so I thought they had beat my next paycheck to the bank.) So, on my way to a lunch meeting I run by the bank and deposit the next check and some other odds and ends including $900 in cash. During and after the meeting it occurs to me that something is wrong, so I go back to the bank.

They look it up. Oops! Heh, Heh! We made a mistake. Instead of depositing your check for X we with drew X from your account. It was the withdrawal of X that over drew your account, causing us to cover it by moving the $900. But its OK now because we put 2X back in your account. Hah, Hah?. Did you move the 900 back to my overdraft protection? Ah, no, you have to give us a check for that. Why? Because it would be more clear. A paper trail. I don't have a check with me. We will print you one. Clear as mud, a bizarre transaction and a homemade check. Ok, what about the fees. Uh, you don't think you should pay them? After all, your account was overdrawn. You are kidding, right? If you had deposited X instead of withdrawing it, I would have never been overdrawn. YOU over drew my account. OK, Ok we will replace the fees. Then there was a long discussion of codes and how to credit it and what account the money should come out of, etc.

So what do you think? Is this about the dumbest banking transaction you ever heard of? The part that amazed me was they did not want to just electronically move the money back to the overdraft account, but were willing to cover their mistake by depositing 2X as if that would be clear to all. Apparently they were willing to send me the form letter saying I had overdrawn the account but were not willing to call or send a letter explaining it. If I had just paid the overdraft back and paid the fees, they would have dismissed the whole thing. What now?

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#2

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

Jim Swank

>You are actually very lucky to have resolved things this simply. I know that's not what you want to hear, but I'm a bit surprised that they admitted they had a problem and were willing to take some action to correct it without a special dispensation from 4 vice-presidents, all properly notarized at your expense.

I'm being a bit facetious, but we (and I) have become so accustomed to shoddy treatment that this is almost a breath of fresh air.

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#3

Wife just did it . . .

Steve Mackay

>'bout the same thing. You owe nothing and they owe you to restore things the way they SHOULD have been from begining to end AND an apology ( wich ain't enough but the best you'll get ). If they still have the " deer in the headlights " look. stand in the lobby and start speaking WITH AUTHORITY about the problem. You should see HER " authority " ! Even I was scared. They'll fix it. Just takes a few ( well, you know ) of your time.

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#4

Re: Nope

Dave Arbuckle, Plano, TX

>Is this about the dumbest banking transaction you ever heard of?

Nope. My mother in law banked with a, uh, very large bank named in part after the country in which I live. She had a big account with them, containing the proceeds of selling her house. Couple hundred and some thousand bucks in it. Through some feat of rocket surgery, they bounced a check of hers for about $10,000.

Dumbest thing ever? No way, anyone can make a mistake. But, after my wife went in, explained it all to one of their employees so he could take care of it, bouncing the same check again was pretty high on my scale of silly banking tricks. :-D

To be fair, I'm told the branch manager was _very_ apologetic. If it had been me, it would have taken an _exceptionally_ apologetic district VP, but that's just me...

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#5

Annually

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>That sort of thing happens annually for us. Come to think of it I don't think it has for a year or so.... uh, oh.... better watch out.

Yes, my bank, the biggest bank in America (hint, hint) does something like that annually. And the mrtgage company. Oh, dear. Don't get me started on that.

All I can say is that if people DON'T check and doucle check everything, then these money instittions are making money off you in worse ways that fees.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#6

Even worse

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I once wrote a check to the state gov't for Sales & Use (business) taxes. On the check I clearly wrote soemthing like $277.09 and the nine cents was written in numerals in two different places. They only took $277.00 when they deposited my check so my account was 9 cents overdue. Later I got a fine ($200 IIRC) because I "did not pay the amount due in full". And it was THEIR mistake. I got the check back from the bank to prove my case, and spent hours trying to resolve it, realized that every hour was costing me more money in lost time, so to save money I gave up.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#7

JL

Re: One reason why we closed out our big city bank

JL

>account. We had been banking with one of the big guys (based in Charlotte, NC). We decided that we'd go with a smaller bank when we moved.

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#8

Re: Revenge is sweet though

Larry Clinton

>Many years ago, I had a similar incident. I had deposited my paycheck in a small branch bank and sent in my mortgage payment the next day. The check bounced. I went directly to the bank with my deposit slip and we found their error. The bank clerk had shown a withdrawal of my check amount instead of a deposit. They straightened out the error, left the overdraw charge. I started to get quite irate. Finally they took off the charge. Then I demanded they send a letter to the mortgage company stating the error was theirs and that the check was in fact good. The branch manager said that was out of the question. However, they did not realize I was the sales manager / salesman and personal friend of the manager at the local propane company - which was the branch banks major customer. In addition we were underwriting loans for many of our customers through that branch. I used the bank phone and called my friend / manager and explained the situation. He agreed that we would pull all our accounts from the bank if they didn't rectify the situation by writing the mortgage company. I just handed the phone to the manager. In about 30 seconds, after several but, but, buts, he agreed to send the letter. I told him he had 24 hours and that I would expect a copy of the letter to be sent to me for my records. He was somewhat red in the face when I left, but I received a copy of the very apologetic letter the next day. I never had any problems with that bank again.

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#9

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

Thomas S Stockton

>I had someone get my debit card # and try to clean out my account. Once I went in and asked about my account the bank rep was real helpful and we looked at my records a couple of different ways and once it was clear that there was fraud going on she got me on the phone with someone in the card division and it was handled as smoothly as could be. The bad thing was trying to figure out my account for the next month with lots of extra credits and whatnot going on. in the end I didn't loose anything. I bank at a large national bank but find the people at the local branches to be very helpful and make it seem like a much smaller bank.

Tom

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#10

That's why

Larry Marker in Alabama

>I check my online bank records every day. Usually, if there is a problem, it is of my making, but I have found a couple oop's done by the bank. By checking my account via the web every day, surprises are not allowed to live very long.

Larry

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#11

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Simple solution

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Just keep so little in the bank that the math could easily be done on the twenty fingers between you and the teller. I've never had a problem that way.

Jason

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#12

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Everyone has a banking story. Mine is a bank that refused honor checks of mine THREE different times, due to confusion with some dirtball with the same name who was always overdrawn. (No, I don't think it was the other woodturner named John Jordan.) Scary. I changed banks.

JKJ

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#13

This guy has us ALL beat *LINK*

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Bought a $4.33 burger at Burger King with his debit card. Cashier hit 433 and then accidentally hit 433 again. So the total instantly debited from his account was $4334.33, which caused all sorts of problems.

You can read about it here.

Happy Woodworking!


http://www.usatoday.com/news/offbeat/2006-03-28-bu

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#14

Re: This guy has us ALL beat

Barry Irby

>I stopped to buy gas. $35.77. Clerk could not get the card to read. Swiped it over and over. Bill Came and They had charged me for four tanks of gas for the exact same amount in about twenty seconds. I called MasterCard to have it taken off the account. The woman said, "Sir, someone has to pay for the gas." I asked, What do you think the chances are I bought four Identical tanks of gas in twenty seconds?" She took three of them off.

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#15

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

David Charters (Durham, NC)

>Me and a friend of mine just moved to NJ and he owed me some money. He started a checking account at a local bank, and they gave him some starter checks with no name or anything on them until his personal checks came. Well, he wrote me a check, and I took it to the very branch where he started his account, the same folks who gave him the checks, and they wouldn't take it! I said 'what good are these checks if you won't even take them?' they just shrugged. How about that

DC

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#16

HomeDepot

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I purchased some things at HomeDepot totalling $101.45 I swiped the card, signed my name in the box and just before the receipt printed and they had a power outage and everything went blank. Two minutes later the cashier apologized and said we had to do it again, which I did. Well I got two credit card transactions for the exact amount stamped 2 minutes apart. It took 2 trips to HomeDepot, 10+ calls to my credit card company, 4+ calls to HomeDepot, 3 letters and 12 months to get my money back.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#17

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I can top that...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>A former neighbor of mine, Doc, who works part-time for a local landlord recently went into a hardware store for a couple drill bits. Another neighbor of mine ran into him the next day returning them. Doc had decided he "wanted some cheaper bits". Since he had purchased them on the landlord's house charge account, he hadn't looked at the receipt...instead of $0.88 per bit, the store had charged them $880,000.00 per bit... The store took care of it quickly with no further problems.

Jason

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#18

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

Thomas S Stockton

>Banks in NJ a re wierd when i was 19 I went back to visit friends and had the hardest time getting banks there to cash travelers checks, I litterally had to have someone with me who had an account there to get it done.

Tom

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#19

I can beat an $880,000 ring-up easily.

Art Silva

>Every once and awhile, in the throws of tempory brain fade, I make a mistake and scan a Mfg's UPC label instead of our Woodcraft price bar code. The results, as Carl Sagan was famous for saying, was in the billions & billions, & billions. Our third anniversary is Dec. 13, and we have only had to resusitate three or four people so far.

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#20

Check your credit rating

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>SInce they technically bounced a check on your account, make sure they didn't also show an overdraft against your credit rating. Since it was their screw up, they should also pay for the credit report and error correction to the same if their bogus transaction shows up.

Lee

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#21

Good thought, the last time I used the.....

Barry Irby

>overdraft protection was about five years ago. My mortgage withdrawal beat my pay check to the bank. I went to the bank the next morning and asked about it. Yup, the withdrawal beat the check. Mortgage came out at 12:01 AM and the check went in at 9:10AM. So I asked how to clear it up and they said I had to write a check to pay it back, so I did. I asked how much I owed and they said $500. I said, what about interest? Nope. Since I had actually deposited the check in the night depository the night before, they would wave the internet. So about three months later I was turned down for a Credit card. Turns out there was a $2 fee I had not paid. Now I owed them $2.32 and they had reported me as being past due ninety days. I was stunned and furious. I pointed out I had asked them to tell me what I owed and had even pressed them on the interest. They said it was not interest, it was a fee. Not only that, they canceled my overdraft protection. At that point, they reinstated it. I should have left their bank at that point, but There were and are about a half dozen drafts that come out of the account and it would have been a PITA to move the account.

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#22

Idiots...

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I had a mortgage with HomeSide Lending for $XXX,XXX.

HomeSide sold it to Washintong Mutual. Okay. Fine. Stopped sending check to HomeSide and sent checks to Washington Mutual. They took the payments but didn't apply them to my mortgage because they didn't know who I was. Figures. 6 payments (6 months) later all was fixed. Or so I thought.

A couple of years later I check my credit score. Shows that I have a mortage with HomeSide for $XXX,XXX as well as a second mortgage with Washington Mutual for $XXX,XXX. Actually the second mortgage amount was a couple of thousand less (equivalent to a few months worth of payments).

So instead of having mortages of $XXX,XXX, all three credit rating bureaus showed that I was carrying two mortgages owing almost double what I really did. Spent about 5-6 years trying to clean that up.... nope, I don't believe they've been able to clean that up. Still shows incorrect information. According to them I have a credit score of 795 and am carrying a huge mortgage debt.

Idiots!

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#23

Re: Idiots...

Barry Irby

>The part that got me was that I had just gone through a divorce and my Income goes down in the Winter. In the past we had relied on the wife's income to covert eh short fall. I figured overdraft protection was in order. Went to the bank and set it up, explaining I wanted to guard against a bounced check that might hurt the credit score, just in case. In the end, it was the overdraft protection that damaged my credit worse than a bounced check. And, I suspect having them write a letter would have been even worse. I'm sure that any "letter" raises some sort of suspicion and since it is "not ordinary" and not easily interpreted by the computer or automatic scoring, it either doesn't help at all, as in it's ignored, or it hurts you.

You can win, you can't break even, you can't even quit the game.

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#24

Re: Idiots...

Don in Central Illinois

>Switch to a credit union. Normally, lower loan rates, higher interest rates and less fees than banks. Also, a FICO of 795 is pretty darn good. Don't complain about the score and as far as a creditor looking at the report, most of us are smart enough to figure out you don't have 2 mortgages for the same amount on original credit, with the same monthly payments.

Re: Completely OT Banking ? Screwed?

#25

Re: Idiots...

Stuart Johnson

>Many years ago I had a rather large overdraft protection. To make a long story short after a divorce I and then loss of job it got used very heavily. I started making $100 payments and all was okay. That is until I sold my house and decided to move to a new state. I went to each of my creditors and made six months of payments in advance, changed my address to my parents and moved. Well my folks started getting notices about past due amounts at the bank and dutifully let me know. I told them not to worry because all was paid up. When it finally got sorted out it turns out the bank applied the full six months as one payment and listed the loan as being in default. I worked out a payment schedule and everyone was happy. About a year later I went back and made an appointment with some V.P. to come in and pay it off. When I went in it turned out the balance was about $500.00 more than I thought so I told her I would need to continue making payments.

Her response was to not bother. Because of the earlier default the loan had been changed to uncollectible and she would just mark it paid in full. She went on to say it was easier because they had to hand post to a manual record because it was no longer in their system.

I don't know who was the bigger idiot in this case, me for getting into the mess or the bank for not collecting everything they were entitled to receive. I did not get a black mark on my credit because of the problem.