Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

OT - Educate me on DVRs

Posts

OT - Educate me on DVRs

#1

OT - Educate me on DVRs

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>I really don't want a Tivo. I pay a monthly service charge for enough things already. But my old VCR is probably not going to serve me very well any longer. I just want a digital equivalent of the vcr to record an occasional program I have to miss. Does this exist? Everything I see nowadays makes reference to cable converters, DirecTV, yada yada that requires a subcription.

FWIW, I have DirecTV and antenna. DirecTV for the DIY, old movies, speed channel, Discovery etc. and antenna for local HD channels.

Re: OT - Educate me on DVRs

#2

Re: OT - Educate me on DVRs

Rich in Mn

>You can geta DVD recorder. This unit, often conbined with a VHS tape recorder, will allow you to record programs on to a DVD. The process is very similar to recording on VHS but you willhave to finalizze the DVD after recording.

No service fees just buy DVD R's for recording.

Re: OT - Educate me on DVRs

#3

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: OT - Educate me on DVRs

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>You really need the subscription for a DVR to work like it was intended. It has to be able to "phone home" to download the program guides, which then allow you to scroll through and select the programs you want recorded.

Through my cable service, I have a dual-tuner DVR that holds about 40 hours of normal programming and about 16 hours of HD content. I can be recording 2 programs at once, while watching a third that was previously recorded. I can set series recordings to grab any new shows, or even repeats as well--on one or all channels on which that show is aired. It's pretty slick...

Jason

Re: OT - Educate me on DVRs

#4

Re: OT - Educate me on DVRs

Don Pierson

>I have had a Pioneer DVR for several years...has a hard drive...no montly fees...plays dvd's...records TV programs from RF antenna onto hard drive...can record recorded programs onto DVD...ala Roy and NYW Norm...a menu of TV programs is downloaded nightly automatically...has a weeks schedule of broadcasts...I think it works with cable and satelite tv...records when program is aired and I watch on my time schedule...greatest thing since sliced bread! I have no idea what is going to happen when eveything goes digital!

Re: OT - Educate me on DVRs

#5

Re: OT - Educate me on DVRs

Barry Irby

>I have a DVR from Comcast. I think it is ten bucks a month. While I hate monthly fees, I figured that was thirty months to pay off a $300 DVR, and by that time the DVR would be outmoded, broken, worn out, or something. I'm glad i did it this way. I literally just came back from returning the unit for about the third or fourth time. If the ones comcast is proffering are typical, something is always going kaput on them. I just walk in (stand In line a while), hand it to them and walk out with another one, no charge.

The one thing I don't like is there is no way to tell this thing to record only the new version of the show. If they run Norm three times a week, you can record one of them or all of them, but not just the new episodes. Its hard to explain, but the local system does not indicate shows are repeats or when the new episode is aired, so sometimes I end up with five versions of the same show. Takes a little editing to delete the unwanted ones. I actually have to watch a few seconds of the show to determine I already have it and then delete it. Also, if the move Norm to a new time slot, not only does it not record Norm, it does not record whatever they put in his slot. So It does not have enough sense to record each new episode of "Norm", it does not record the slot either.

Be careful buying one. Be sure it is compatible with whatever is coming next.

Re: OT - Educate me on DVRs

#6

"leasing" DVR's

Curt Harms

>For what You want, a DVD recorder should work fine. It might be worth looking into DVD-RAM. DVD-RAM can be recorded over a bunch of times, like more than 10,000. DVD-RW can't be recorded over as often though I don't know how many times DVD-RW can be recorded over.

We have a DirecTV DVR. When we bought it, there was nothing in the display that indicated that it was a lease. We were annoyed and thought about returning it. We decided not to. The technology is in flux right now and it might well make better sense to not spend the money to buy what might well be an obsolete piece of gear very few years down the road. What we found with this unit is to lease it was $299, to buy it outright was either $749 or $799, I don't recall which. It does have 2 HD receivers that work with one access card. Right now there just aren't any real bargains, especially if you want HD.

HTH

Curt

Re: OT - Educate me on DVRs

#7

My DVR from Time Warner is "free"

Jack

>but I do pay an extra $9 month because it has 2 tuners in it, but that is less than getting a second tuner or adding watch and record

Re: OT - Educate me on DVRs

#8

Re: OT - Educate me on DVRs

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Tim,

I have a SageTV system setup that works wonderfully (www.sagetv.com). Check it out and see what you think. The software is initially $80.00, but there is not subscription fee.

You will have to purchase capture cards (either standard or high def) for you desires. You also have to do a little research on getting things to work correctly sometimes, but their forums are great, and the system works like a charm. They even have a license for connecting to your Sage server back at home through a high-speed connection (i.e. at a hotel) so you can watch what you have recorded while you are away. I do not have any high def components yet, but as soon as they come out with their high def extender device, I am going to start building the system for that possibility.

A DVR will definitely change the way that you watch television.

Check them out and see what you think. Hope this helps.

Rob Hix

P.S. I have no interest in the company except being a very satisfied customer.

Re: OT - Educate me on DVRs

#9

phillips DVDR3575H

Jake (SoMN)

>Just a DVR with a DVD burner. Can't say how well it works, it is being delivered today. No monthly fees and a digital tuner....not true HD though. Was around 300. Doesn't download TV guide like Tivo or the cable company DVR's. Works more like a VCR for programing. I to hate the thought of paying a monthly fee for television when I watch so little of it.

Jake

Kind of hard to find. But found this one at Circuit City and Amazon. Panasonic also makes on, but I can't remember the model #

Re: OT - Educate me on DVRs

#10

Re: OT - Educate me on DVRs *LINK*

Patrick Jaromin

>Tim -

I have extensive experience with PVRs. I own:

*ReplayTV (since they first came out)

*TiVo (~3yrs)

*Windows MCE (a few months)

*MythTV (DIY Linux-based PVR)

For the money, the TiVO is far and away the absolute best. Hands down. I purchased it with "lifetime" service which they unfortunately no longer offer...so yes, there is a monthly fee that I'm not sure I would go for either if I didn't already have the unit.

If you're looking for a way around the monthly, then your best bet is the Windows MCE device. I'm no fan of windows and it is the least reliable of them all (I reboot the system every week or so)...but there's no monthly fee and you can potentially use the system for other things. The "SageTV" Media Center is an unnecesary addon -- just get Windows Vista (all except Home Basic) and you're all set. I purchased a refurbished Gateway "Media Center" PC from TigerDirect (Naperville warehouse) for ~$400 with a tuner and remote. I primarily use it as a DVD "jukebox" - we rip our DVDs to the hard drive and use the free "My Movies 2" plugin...saves wear and tear on the kids DVDs.

On a side note, nothing beats the Channel Plus video modulators. All of the PVRs live in the basement and are modulated on different channels so they are watchable on any TV in the house. The IR signals are sent over the same RG6 as the TV signal, so there's no additional wiring.

Cheers!


http://tenonandspline.com/blog

Re: OT - Educate me on DVRs

#12

Re: Thanks everyone

Doug in VA

>Tim:

I spent 5 years working on DVR technology. Most services will charge you something for the guide data updates. Since you have DirecTV, you should consider finding an Ultimte TV DVR/Tuner. I have two old ones at home. They still work but I do not have DirecTV anymore. These units had the jump-forward button not offered anymore on most DVRs. Check out ebay.

Doug

Re: OT - Educate me on DVRs

#13

Re: OT - Educate me on DVRs

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Here's what I have:

DirecTV sat service, with the two tuner Tivo based Hughes DVR box. It's now been pumped up to 320+ hours of recording time, when the initial disk drive conked out.

The TiVo subscription runs another $5 a month over what I pay for the sat services. Same bill to DTV.

www.weaknees.com sells these units. I don't know if anyone else does right now. There are rumors that there are new Tivo based boxes due soon, but I don't know.

You won't be able to record HD with these older units. For that, you'd need something else, likely from DirecTV, and there are mixed reviews on those, last I looked. We don't have the desire to have HD yet, although most of the gear is capable.

We also bought a Sony VHS/DVD recorder, to save off the recordings that we wanted to keep to DVD. That's been helpful. Maybe $225?

TiVo wants $13 or so for the standalone service. I did that for a couple years, before sat services. No more.

Good luck. Standalone service isn't nearly as slick as well-integrated...

Re: OT - Educate me on DVRs

#14

Re: OT - Educate me on DVRs

David G. Sparks

>I like my DVR I rent from the cable company. It's only $4.95 a month. Pausing live tv is way cool. I often start watching my shows a few minutes late so I can fast forward through the commercials.