Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Who among us can claim total originality?

Posts

Who among us can claim total originality?

#1

Who among us can claim total originality?

Keith Newton

>I have always loved Art Noveau, and have always been so connected to nature, which has always been an influence on my work, an even more-so lately. I have been hoping to live long enough to see a revival, or at least to get a commission to do a nice Noveau piece.

Are there any other Noveau Fanitics among us?

What do you think, can we get a revival started? Does anyone have connections to start a competition or something to get the wheels turning. We are coming up on the centenial, if we are not already there. Lets get something going.

I am for one way past due to channel some of those great artist. As far as I am concerned, there was no greater period of artistic style. KN

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

#2

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Hi Keith, your subject line and message body don't go together. Some of your work comes pretty close to total originality. A few of your pieces I have never seen another design like it, yet I can still see the major design influences that you have incorporated into your work.

Are you suggesting that nobody can claim total originality today? While difficult, I don't believe that is true.

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

#3

I can...

wilbur

>I find original ways to screw up my project every time I'm in my shop.

I'm a veritable prodigy in this respect.

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

#4

When God made me, he threw out the mould

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Liability issues ;) Couldn't afford to make the same mistake twice ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

#5

Lee Grindinger

Not bloody likely..., but give it a go

Lee Grindinger

>I agree with your opinion of Art Noveau. It must be about the shortest lived major genre in the history of furniture design though. I'm convinced it died as a major style because there were not enough skilled craftsmen to make it feasible for the industry.

Is it original? I dunno, it's certainly a unique re-combination of previous shapes. A discussion like this gets really squishy because a clear and accepted definition of "original" needs defining. Is a re-combination of previously conceived shapes original? I think it is, just like writing a song is original even though all you're doing is re-combining notes none of which are new.

So, you define original for me and I'll tell you if I ever did it.

Lee

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

#6

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

Tim Caley - North Litttle Rock

>OK, I'll take one for the team and expose my stupidity. What the heck is it that you are talking about?

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

#7

Ellis Walentine

Reviving bygone styles

Ellis Walentine

>I don't have any answers, just some hunches, Keith. For one thing, time marches on and few people today have the time or the chops to carve out major pieces in the high Art Nouveau style -- not that it isn't lyrical or highly original, at least in the furniture realm -- and probably even fewer customers could afford work of this scope and difficulty.

Also, well-known work of a particular era such as the Art Noveau period has some unavoidable baggage that goes along with it, including the association of this style with that era and all the social attributes that went along with it.

Of course, if the look is what you're after, you can probably produce it efficiently with modern multiple-axis CNC routing equipment. Make a standard cherry frame, load it in the machine, and presto, it's a complicated, delicately nuanced Nouveau motif. Some finish sanding and you're all set.

I don't know if you can call it original, but if you can distill the essential attributes of the Nouveau style into a new visual vocabulary, you might be able to capture the things you like most about the original style in a whole new style that has similar resonance.

Sounds like that would be a real challenge.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

#8

Re: Reviving bygone styles

Keith Newton

>Ellis, You hit on it with this. I never want to copy anyone's work, but have been having a lot of ideas that I could work into that style.

I guess I should try some of the ideas on some turnings just to keep the project small, before I jump off into a bigger project.

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

#9

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

Keith Newton

>thanks Mike, I think there was a compliment in there.

You know as hard as I try to develop my own style, someone always comes along and says, I can see what influenced that. I even do that myself, even if I couldn't see the connection when the idea first comes to me.

I guess what got me thinking about this, is that recently someone from WC wrote me a complimentary note, and remarked that my work looked like it was inspired by that style. I had not thought of that, but could see how they came to that perception.

Well, maybe if my work is looking like it fits that style when I am not trying to make it look that way, maybe I should go ahead and make something where I am trying to make it Art Nouveau.

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

#10

Alan Young

A Fanatic?.......No.. A Fan Yes....

Alan Young

>Keith-

I am a recent casual observer of Art Nouveau pieces...It is a style that at first glance seems somewhat unto itself..A concentrated style to be sure-yet it is interesting to me that it can be linked to English Arts and Crafts pieces...After all-the joinery still has to be there. But what happens after the joint is fun... swooping sinuous lines-

A&C,Mission,Shaker,or Early American Colonial pieces are readily recognized and quickly adapted to today's settings...but the Art Nouveau seems to me harder to "blend"...probably because all the fore mentioned styles are so ubiquitous....

That would seem to give Art Nouveau pieces a chance for making a fresh statement...But perhaps a risky venture for speculative pieces..still if you can convince a patron of it's rareness if not uniqueness then perhaps the right client could be persuaded for some substantial work..

A challenge for sure to reproduce an Art Nouveau piece or "create" a new piece in that style...

Alan

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

#11

Re: Revivals

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Always seem lessen the original; once it�s gone, the memory is always better than the copy. Better to synthesize a reinterpretation of a design vocabulary into a new direction, a sprout off the original plant if you will. The content behind the style and the societal issues that shaped it are long gone over the past 100 years.

A/N artists certainly had no claim to originality in using plant forms and curves, and their borrowing from the Baroque and Rococo movements is rather hard to deny. Their updating organic design elements with the increased freedom in materials and fabrication techniques was much of their contribution. Like all artistic style, A/N was relatively short-lived and then morphed into other �styles� like Deco and Bauhaus the didn�t depend so much on subconscious content.

Distill those parts of A/N that you�re most fond of and then work them into your own pieces. If you wait for a revival, you�ll miss your chance to establish something, if not totally new, at least unique.

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

#12

Hi Mark, Allan, and Lee

Keith Newton

>I wouldn't think of knocking off a copy of older work. I have too many ideas of my own that I would like to do.

I don't know how much of the stuff from that period is out there, but I'll bet what there is, would be extremely expensive, because it is so rare to see any of it, that there should be some demand for new works, if they are well designed and executed.

I guess I am putting out feelers. I have some ideas trying to find their way out of my head-bone, and I can't afford to specualte on any more work until I have a bit more money than I presently have.

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

#13

Re: Feelers

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>are fine, Keith, but you'll have to have concrete evidence of your demonstrated ability to handle the style elements before anyone's going to hire you to do more. After all, would you hire someone to build you a car from scratch just because he likes the way they look? Artists get commissions based upon their portfolio of finished work that can be seen. Outside of the CNC router stuff that Ellis mentioned, I think you'll find the style very demanding because, with its reliance on long curves and transitions from one form to the next, even small waivers will show up terribly.

And there is lots of A/N stuff around. It gets stacked in junk shops and antique parlors all over, not to mention estate auctions. Nothing "rare" about it; just out of style, vogue and demand. There was a brief flurry of nostalgia in the late 60's and early 70's when Aubrey Beardsley prints and Klimt reproductions were all the rage (along with acid and Peyote). |;-}}}

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

#14

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

Craig

>Keith,

In case you haven't seen them here are a couple people doing interesting work with an AN twist. Terry probably takes it the furthest into a new direction though. His new site loads very slowly even on my DSL just so you know. I'm sure you have seen Rogers work in the past but it's always interesting to look over. I guess if you look at their sites and get an idea its no longer original though, what a quandry, to look or not to look.

Craig

http://www.terrybostwickstudio.com/

http://www.heitzmanstudios.com/index.html

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

#15

Re: Who among us can claim total originality? *LINK*

MikeW

>Hi Keith,

I mostly did early 20th century modern--but had wanted to get a comission for AN work. In the off chance I ever did, I saved the link below to a guy who was in the guild I belonged to. Quite nice work.

Take care, Mike


Julian Hamer's web site

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

#16

Thanks Craig and Mike. I saved those links

Keith Newton

>I need to spend more time looking at them. I liked the Bostwick works the best. My only comment is that all of them have been stripped of too much of the fine details that make the older works so incredible.

thanks again for sharing those K

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

#17

Re: Thanks Craig and Mike. I saved those links

Craig

>I have always liked Terry's work but the lines on some of it look too hard for my taste, almost like the smooth flowing feel of the old AN stuff has been replaced with a more modern harsher look.

Craig

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

#18

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

Tim Caley - North Litttle Rock

>Just received my December issue of Popular Woodworking magazine and it appears that your comment is very timely. The is an Art Nouveau table built by Gustav Stickley in 1900 as one of the projects.

Do you have an inside line on PW publication dates Keith?

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

#19

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

Keith Newton

>No I don't. In fact I hardly ever see it. I never thought of Gus fitting into the Nouveau style, unless you count some of those little inlays. I will have to give it a look when I get out to B&N. thanks

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

#20

Rick L

Re: Stickley isn't even close to Art...

Rick L

>Nouveau style. Art Nouveau was French based and is more like sculpture. Stickley was in the Craftsman style like Wright, Greene and Greene. I can't even imagine an Art Nouveau in a magazine like Pop Wood. Most of the readers of the hobby mags are into Shaker and Arts and Crafts style. Art Nouveau would be too advanced for any of the wood mags to present.

Re: Who among us can claim total originality?

#21

I forgot William Doub, lots of AN stuff *LINK*

Craig

>He has quite a bit of AN stuff.

Craig


William Doub