Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Tenon question and strength question? (long)

Posts

Tenon question and strength question? (long)

#1

JL

Tenon question and strength question? (long)

JL

>I'll be building a stand for the cradle that I posted earlier.

My current thoughts are to use the same wood (big leaf maple) for the stand. I was planning on doing the foot section separately from the vertical section. I was going to take some 3/4" actual big leaf maple and cut it down to 8" in width for the vertical section (maybe put some curves in too - but leave it at least 6" wide). I was thinking about putting some 3/8" tenons (1 to 1 1/2" long) on the end where I join it to the foot section. I wasn't going to do a continuous tenon, but an interrupted one. The 3/8" mortises will be in the foot sections into the side grain of the wood.

So - will the 3/8" tenons be strong enough? I was planning on making three tenons 3/8" thick x 1 to 1 1/2" long x 1 1/2" wide. They'll have to hold the weight of the cradle, baby and bedding - say about 50+ lbs. I'll be joining the two vertical sections using through tenons and wedges.

Getting more lumber is also an option - though if I get 5/4, it would have to be a different variety of maple, such as hard maple or soft maple. I could also laminate some big leaf maple together to give me thicker pieces.

Thoughts? TIA

Re: Tenon question and strength question? (long)

#2

Re: Tenon question and strength question? (long)

Kneale Brownson awaiting snow in N. MI

>This one's oak instead of maple, and it's glued-up instead of full width 3/4-inch boards, but the dimensions are similar otherwise. I just used an inch of 3/8 continuous tenon to connect to the slightly thicker foot. My connections to the cradle are threaded so it can be separated from the stand, allowed to swing or tightened so the cradle can't swing.


Re: Tenon question and strength question? (long)

#3

JL

Re: Thanks..

JL

>I may just try the 3/8" tenons - but I doubt if I'll run them continuously. I think I want a bit more strength in the foot "web".

Re: Tenon question and strength question? (long)

#4

Ellis Walentine

You didn't mention...

Ellis Walentine

>...how thick the foot will be. If it is thicker than the vertical piece, I'd probably make the tenons 1/2" thick, though with that tall center stretcher, you're not likely to see any racking unless Uncle Festus falls against the cradle.

Regarding making the tenon(s) continuous or non-continuous: the shearing forces on the glue surfaces are the same, regardless. The advantage of multiple tenons is that they leave wood tissue intact between the mortises, which helps maintain the integrity of the foot piece. Naturally, this effect ranges from irrelevant to critical depending on the strength and design issues involved. I think three tenons is overkill. In this case, two tenons is probably overkill.

Ellis

Re: Tenon question and strength question? (long)

#5

Lee Grindinger

Mortise and tenon failures

Lee Grindinger

>Virtually every failed mortise and tenon joint I've seen has been a failure in the mortise. The long grain strength of the tenon is quite durable in the tenoned piece and failures are extremely rare. It's the cross grain of the mortise that generally fails. While 3/8" is good, 1/2" is better as long as you beef up the foot by making the mortise walls thicker. Generally the tenon thickness is a rule of thirds but in a case of high stress joints like yours I'd make the foot thicker by as much as you find aesthetically pleasing. I'd shoot for mortise walls at least 1/2" thick even if it means retaining the 3/8" tenon.

Lee

Re: Tenon question and strength question? (long)

#6

JL

Re: Thanks all..

JL

>I'll make the foot thicker so I can have a thicker mortise wall. I have enough lumber to "double" the feet. I'll leave the verticals the same thickness (3/4").