>I made a mahogany counter top for a wet bar that turned out really well, glued up 6/4 planks about 13" wide each to get the full width of about 25". Now we are talking about doing mahogany in the kitchen. My question is, are we nuts? The bar counter really doesn't get much use, the kitchen will get a lot of use. We are OK with getting dings and scratches, I want to be sure that the finish is right... used waterlox on the bar and it looks beautiful, will that hold up to the daily used-kitchen countertop, or should I be going for some epoxy or other more exotic finish? spar varnish? (I read that spar varnish stays a bit too soft..)
Attaching a picture of the bar... hand planed from the rough...
You will have to be the judge of whether or not mahogany is a good choice for your kitchen. Sounds to me like you know what you're in for. Mahogany is not that hard so it will ding more than maple or some others. As for spar varnish, I believe the application intended for the product has little in common with the requirements for protecting a kitchen counter. It has a ton of UV blockers which you don't care about and it is, I believe, more flexible than regular varnish.
If I was doing this I think I would concerned with maintenance as there is going to be a lot of it. My choice would probably be an oil as it's easy to renew. I think any film finish would be pretty tough to live with.
Just my two cents for all it's worth. Good luck with your project.
>Hunter, as long as you can afford it, mahogany is as good a choice as any for that countertop. Have you thought about Jatoba (sometimes referred to as Brazilian cherry)? It would be in the same color range as mahogany but harder wood.
I love Waterlox as a finish, but for this type of job you need something that dries to a harder finish. As Michael Dresdner pointed out, an oil-based polyurethane is more appropriate.
>Hunter, I took a unconventional direction, about 2 1/2 years ago, when building my farmer's table for my large family to belly up to. I knew my grand kids would not be kind to any finish and put any wood table to the ultimate "hardness"test. I decided to build the top from 4/4 poplar and stain it red mahogany with 5 coats of tung oil finish. So far the table and finish have held up fine. We're feeding 26 for turkey day. geary from nj. p.s. your counter is beauteous!!!!!I wish I knew how to put pictures on this contraption,I'd show you my table...the grain of the poplar is great and the liquids bead up,leaving no marks whatsoever.
>If you can't figure it out, e-mail me the picture and I will fix it up for you and post it. Take a look at the FAQ's (you can find them in the left frame, second from the top). There is a tutorial on how to do it.