Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

New Sketchup Question....

Posts

New Sketchup Question....

#1

New Sketchup Question....

Tony - Memphis

>Trying to draw a cabriole leg. I am using the intersect method. Got the basic shape almost, but have yet to get the whole thing to work. Any thoughts? I draw the shape and get rid of the waste. I then create a copy of that, rotate it correctly, move it on top of the original using the correct corner as reference, the intersect. That works if I leave the back of the knee cut off. It does the front of the knee ok, but not the back. All sorts of strange things happen. I tried creating a group and that didn't work either.

Thanks,

Tony

Re: New Sketchup Question....

#2

Re: New Sketchup Question....

Rick Lasita

>Hey Tony, can't answer your specific question, but I did just finishing reading a nice article in Fine Woodworking last night on the SketchUp program. He has some instruction there, and references the SketchUp site. December 07 issue #194. Hope things are going well down I-40, I'm heading to Colco and The Woodwork Shop later this morning.

Re: New Sketchup Question....

#3

Re: New Sketchup Help

Carol Reed - in Nebraska

>Dave Richards is a Sketch-Up Guru. I have talked with him on the phone, at his suggestion, when I was having a problem. He hangs out at familywoodworking.org. He did hang out at SMC, but I don't know if he still does. He has writen several on-line tutorials, and I think, an article for FWW. Knowledgeable and very generous with his time.

I am also AutoCAD literate and learning to use SketchUp has been interesting, to say the least. I think CAD users have a rougher time of it because the mindset of the programming is altogether different.

Re: New Sketchup Question....

#4

nail on the head

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>I think CAD users have a rougher time of it because

>the mindset of the programming is altogether different

I think you hit the nail on the head. I am a 3D modeling and animation guy (before I retired, anyway) and found SketchUp intuitive and fairly easy to use once I learned what command did what function. Unfortunately, I don't use it enough to be efficient. (Ask a question about 3DS Max and I can probably help, though)

Years ago, I used Autocad extensively and was very fast with it. Today, I still use it occasionally but find it cumbersome and very slow compared to my 3D software, even for 3D work. I think I switched mindsets over the years!

Tony, I don't know what the problem is - I tried starting with a single block and subtracted four simple edges with curves as I illustrated before and it worked OK, except at one point it lost an end surface I had to replace. It sounds like you are creating one intersected object then using it for further intersections? I don't know how SketchUp handles that, but some other packages get confused with multiple booleans. Also, some packages blow up if you have any faces or edges coplaner (sitting exactly on top of and aligned with other faces) - could that be the case?

There are some other good ways too build a complex object, for example by adding several pieces together rather than subtracting several times.

I'm having trouble visualizing your model from your description, perhaps disadvantaged by being unfamiliar with the terms "cabriole" and "knee". Again, I am NOT a SketchUp expert, but I'd be glad to take a look at your object if I can open your file with version 5. If you want that, send an email.

JKJ

Re: New Sketchup Question....

#5

cabriole knee

Dan Donaldson

>Here is a diagram of the parts of a cab leg.


img

Re: New Sketchup Question....

#6

Thanks All...

Tony - Memphis

>After I posted, I recalled the article in FWW and looked at it online. I followed an example and it worked. I was leaving out one step. Still doesn't makes sense, but it worked! Thanks for the help.

Where 'bouts are you Rick? Must not be too far on I40 I'm guessing? I like to go to Colco now and then just to breathe it all in! Their selection is better than it used to be. Haven't been lately though.

Tony

Re: New Sketchup Question....

#7

Cabriole Leg Pic

Tony - Memphis

>I just did the top part of a leg trying to learn how to do it. I had been leaving out the step of intersecting after exploding I think. Something like that anyway.

Tony


img