Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

Posts

Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

#1

Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

Joe Burke

>Okay .... Here's additional info. I'll even throw in a picture.

First off .... I'm in North Carolina and the job was done in December.

The box is a veneer job. I used quartersawn Brazilian mahogany for the core. Why? Just because. I have a good supply of 16/4 mahogany I lucked into, so I ripped out quartersawn boards. How do I know it's Brazilian? The word Brazil was stenciled on one treated end ... and it's old.

The veneer is wenge applied with the same Franklin's hide glue.

I will say that when I sawed the stock initially the MC was a bit higher than I'd have liked. The lumber had been stored outside, and even though it had been in my climate comntroled shop for over a year, the MC was still too high. I rigged up a little dry kiln consisting of a quartz heater in the bottom of a shop cabinet with the door propped open and the boards stickered inside. It worked well as the MC came down with no ill effects on the boards. I left them out to acclimate for a week or so and forged ahead with the MC still fine.

The boards were app. 5/8" thick x 5" wide and 15" long rough.

The box is finished with shellac.

I can't recall when I first felt the squeeze out, but it might have been as long as 2-4 weeks after the box was finished. That's what puzzles me about this ... the time lapse between completion and feeling the squeeze out. It defintely came about well after completion.

I'd have thought with the stock being QS as well as mahogany along with my drying it ... to around 9% which is equillibrium for my shop ... and the time of year, that stock movement wouldn't be a concern.

The most plausible thing you suggested, Stephen, was too much glue. I often fear that with mitres that the glue will soak into the end grain, so I may be a bit heavy handed. Still, why would it come out so long after completion? That's why I called this creep, even though I have no idea if that's what this is. Maybe the veneer is the source?

Again, I can feel the glue on the corners of the box as well as at the joint between the curve on the top of the box where it meets the straight sides.

I can fix this and I hate to make a mountian of a molehill, but this is a never before experienced puzzle.

Here's a picture ...


img

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

#2

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

Warren in Lancaster, Pa

>I have heard of creep problems with Franklins glue before. I think it is a big mistake to lump Franklin's "liquid Hide Glue" with hide glue, or to try Franklin's stuff as an introduction to hide glue. There are enough differences that you cannot read of some hide glue property or use and expect it to carry over to the adulterated stuff. In my experience, workers who are serious about hide glue take the time to learn to use the real thing.

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

#3

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

Joe Burke

>That may well turn out to be the case, and if so, that's what I need to know. However, in all my research I couldn't find any info that said ... the liquid alternatives are bad for these reasons. It may be a case of learning the hard way ... like I usually do.

I'm not looking for a love affair with hide glue. Just a longer open time and no creep. If the liquid won't do that I'll likely use something else.

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

#4

Lee Grindinger

Love affair?..., or passing fancy

Lee Grindinger

>Joe, I used liquid hide glue a lot, mine was a love affair for just the reasons you've stated..., lonely woodworker in need of longer time spent canoodling and a solid bond formed afterwards. Nope, no flash in the pan set and run glue affairs for me, I wanted the real deal just like you.

Mike Dresdner wrote lovingly of this glue citing the additives that place the gel point below room temperature. I no longer have his article bu it spoke glowingly of this glue. Perhaps he'll step in here. I never had the creep issues you're having and I'm wondering if it's a one time deal.

Was the glue fully good? This glue has a shelf life and the check is to put a dad between finger and thumb and separate the digits repeatably until strings form as moisture leaves. A great many strings should form, these are the protein chains that make hide glue work.

Could this issue you're having be a one shot deal, will sanding the piece and applying more finish solve the problem? It definitely sounds like a moisture issue.

Nice box, by the way. Like I said, I used liquid hide glue a lot, it's nice to have the open time, much longer than hot hide glue, it's nice to have the re-pairability and it's nice to have the creeplessness.

Lee

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

#5

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

GregR

>I saw a demo once where all the different glues were put on piece of glass and left to cure for a couple of days. The liquid hide glue was still very wet after two days. The demostrator said the the liquid hide glue was not the same as hot hide glue and that it never fully cures. Maybe that's the problem. Just a thought.

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

#6

I guess I'd hoped LTR ...

Joe Burke

>Long Term Relationship .... in case you didn't know.

I forgot to mention hide glue taking stain, or being more finish friendly too.

I bought the glue new from WWS, and I'd just assumed with their stock turnover it was fresh. I've used a pile of it lately, so that bottle hadn't been sitting around, and I know it's gone. Of course, that didn't mean it wasn't past it's born on date. The glue did set up and harden off, so my bet is that it was okay.

I agree that this must be a moisture issue. One I'd like to avoid in the future. Hence this thread. Always learning.

One reason I'd tried all this was a thread where you'd stated you were using Franklin's for veneer work. Might have been that square coffee type table with some walnut burl on top?? Anyway, I like the stuff. I'm just perplexed.

Thanks for the kind words.

Where are you now??? I can't keep up.

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

#7

Lee Grindinger

LTRs and one bottle stands *LINK*

Lee Grindinger

>Joe, the dates on the bottles mean little. I used glue that was a year past it's date that was still perfectly good, do the dab-between-the-fingers test for the only results you need.

Like I said, I used tons of the stuff, especially for veneer work because, as you said, it's transparent to stain, it's repairable and it has a long open time. It's very good stuff for difficult assemblies too.

Hide glue does not cure, as someone said, it dries. It's aways water soluble which is precisely what makes it repairable.

You didn't say if sanding and applying more finish cured the problem, I'm wondering if it's not a wood moisture issue, one thing about any glue is tha it adds water to the materials and a project needs to dry out before final sanding and finishing, whether it's PVA, Urea, or hide glue. Moisture is moisture.

We're now in St Croix, Virgin Islands. Life is awfully good.

Lee


img

RuthAndLee.com

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

#8

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

Larry Clinton

>Hmmm, I sure would have to question the instructor's credentials. I would put a fairly substantial bet that the glue used for the test was past it's expiration date. I don't think Titebond (or Patrick's old brown glue) would sell a glue that didn't "fully cure". I have just used one pint bottle and am well into the second one of the Titebond liquid hide glue. I have several Bessy clamps that had the excess glue and drippings set up on them in far less than 1 day. I tried to scrape some glue off the poly clamp faces yesterday - will have to soak in ammonia & water to clean - stuff is hard as a rock. I also have some dripped and cured on my epoxy coated shop floor. It appears to be at least as hard as the epoxy. Normally Titebond 3 just pops off the poly faces. I have never experienced the liquid hide glue (Titebond) staying wet, but I am pretty particular about not using old glue. I also use hot hide glue. I have a hot pot (soup warmer) I bought new for about 10 ~$15, and a digital meat thermometer. However, when gluing up the blanket chest I am building with mortise and tenon joints I couldn't extend the open time long enough for me to fit all the parts and pieces and get clamps on tight. The liquid hide glue has worked very well for me.

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

#9

You might want to check this out. *LINK*

Paul Woolson

>If it's open time you are looking for, as well as the properties of Hide, check out fish glue.

It's OLD SCHOOL but starting to make a revival in instrument maker's shops as there is no heating required. 1-1/2 to 2 hour open time. No creep when completely dry (12 hours). Worth looking into.


Norland Fish Glue

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

#10

Gosh Lee ..... That looks ...

Joe Burke

>just awful. All that sand, sun and breeze. How do you take it?? It's surely good to be you, huh?

I'm sure it's a moisture problem too. As I reflect back almost a year now, I had bottles that had been thinned some. I could have used that, which might have introduced even extra water. Who knows?

I might have rushed the finishing, but as I ponder, the box is more complicated than it looks. It went together in stages. There was no way to slap it together and go to finishing.

I appreciate the input. At this point, I'm just thinking out loud.

I haven't fixed it as yet, but I will. The shellac finish is repairable as well, so one way or the other it'll get done.

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

#11

Re: You might want to check this out.

Joe Burke

>Interesting. I wonder if it smells like fish?? Hmmmm ;-)

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

#12

Re: You might want to check this out.

Paul Woolson

>Not as much as hide glue (real hide glue that is) smells like livestock.

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

#13

Suggestion

David Yoho

>I tried to scrape some glue off the poly clamp faces yesterday - will have to soak in ammonia & water to clean - stuff is hard as a rock.

Larry, besides hot water, have you tried using hot vinegar to remove dried hide glue? It works really well for me, whether loosening a joint or for clean up. I put some white vinegar in a small container, pop it in the microwave for about a minute, and brush or wipe it onto the dry glue.

I must also say I'm glad to see Lee Grindinger's positive comments on liquid hide glue along with yours. I'm not against using hot hide glue or saying liquid is better. However, it's better for ME because I often require longer open times when using it. I've been using it a lot more than yellow glue, since discovering it several years ago. It's good stuff and sticks like the dickens!

David

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

#14

Re: You might want to check this out.

Sonja Lemon

>Joe, Before you get all excited about fish glue, here are some facts to think about. It does not have the strength of hide glue. (GOOD fish glue does not smell bad.) It is used where a high tack is desired, such as gluing cloth or leather to wood. It is used in book binding also. We have used it to stick leather pouches to wood in instrument repairs.

High quality hide glue is virtually odorless. It can be purchased from PianoTek Supply Co. (They will sell the glue to non piano industry people!) A Google search will take you there.

Usual disclaimer, satisfied customer for years.

Sonja

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

#15

creep hypothesis is highly unlikely

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Creep is the response of a polymer( glue for example) under stress. Where is the stress in this situation that would cause the cured adhesive to flow? I don't see any force on the adhesive that would cause it to flow(creep, squeeze out). What you have seen is a common adhesive problem and it is most commonly caused by the lumber moving not the adhesive.

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

#16

Re: creep hypothesis is highly unlikely

Joe Burke

>I'll buy that Bill. I've been using the word creep because I didn't know what else to call it. I suppose the proof is in the pudding. I thought the mahogany was dry enough, but the facts say otherwise.

I guess here the wood crept away from the glue and not vice versa. I just gave the box a good going over and there's glue out from every joint at this point. I'd even say there's some glue that's worked it's way from beneath the veneer. Maybe the stock being quarter sawn has worked against me in that it's actually the thickness of the boards that may have changed in this case.

At any rate, this is the first time I've encountered shrinkage of this magnatude. I don't care to see it again.

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2

#17

Re: Hide Glue and the Creeps - part 2 *LINK*

tstock

>My guess is that the glue was old - even liquid hide should not creep if fresh...it's just not very strong compared with hot hide glue. Here's the link to a UofDel paper on LHG versus HHG... a little light reading.


LHG versus HHG