Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

Posts

OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

#1

OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Received an information sheet in my #1 son's homework tonight, it was about children having allergies to this and that in class x, y, z, w, etc., and guidelines on what to do and not to do regarding our kids.

Now, my wife, who's a RN by trade, started arguing that it's principally genetics that are responsible for the outbreak of allergies left and right among the children, her position being that with the highest population ever to live on earth the genetic diversity is bound to ferret out more allergy-prone individuals.

I can't agree with that, since allergies on the scale we see now among kids seem to be increasing exponentially or so. To me pollutants, chemicals used left and right for anything from food to cleaners and whatever else, seem a lot more likely to have been sensitizers to the development of allergies. Smog could be another culprit for all I know. The genes might have been there in the past, but it's the amount and variety of chemicals of all kinds that have made our kids allergy-prone.

I can just relate to my personal experience, growing up in the country, at my school I can't recall of anyone having had any "life-threatening" allergies...

Since the breadth of expertise is so wide here, I thought I'd throw the question to get feedback...

TIA,

DC

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

#2

Allergies? Get a dog *LINK*

Dan Mitchell

>An interesting study a couple years ago published in the Journal of the American Medical Association suggested that if a child is exposed to a pet in the 1st year of life, they have about a 70% lower incidence of developing allergies. The theory is that the bacteria pets carry (filthy little beasts that they are ;-) may effectively suppress the immune system's allergic response. Even without pets in the home, it seems plausible the proliferation of (generally unnecessary) anti-bacterial soaps etc. may also play a role by limiting exposure to such bacteria in the natural environment.


More woofs less a-choos

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

#3

JL

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

JL

>This is going to sound unusual, but so be it.

We live in a fairly clean environment now. We have clean water, clean food, clean clothes, etc.

In the "old days" people were constantly exposed to a variety of "insulting agents" to the body - from worms, bacteria and a number of other sources (such as in the food). The immune system had to respond to these insults. Now it doesn't have these insults to respond to. Therefore the immune system "finds" things to respond to - be it allergens or the body itself (autoimmune diseases).

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

#4

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

Don Orr

>In line with JL's response, there have been studies that show a reduced incidence of allergies in "country" kids than in "suburban & urban" kids. Presumably, kids raised in the "country" and play outside and have animals are exposed early in life to allergens which stimulate the immune system and build up resistance. Kids raised in more "sterile" environments apparently don't have the same advantage of building stronger immune capabilities. Don't know what this all means relative to the recent MRSA problem though. I grew up in the "country" and played outside a lot and we had animals large and small and I don't have any allergies (yet). But neither do most of my family. Nature-Nurture-Combination of both ? I think yes to all those.

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

#5

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

Carol Reed - in Nebraska

>Aha! So Mom running after the kids with wash cloth in hand is not doing them any long term favors. :)

I always KNEW it. When I was a kid and I saw the wash cloth coming, the race was on! LOL

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

#6

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

Brian in Brighton

>Couldn't agree more with everyone so far. I knew only a handful of kids who had severe allergies and only one who was allergic to milk products, none for peanuts, not much else. We also played outside all the time, walked or rode 15 blocks to school playground (without Mom in tow telling us not to dare each other to pick something gross up). We would go into any woods we could find, jump in any pond we found and generally get dirty. Then the object is to avoid bath time. 9 of 12 of the neighbors have kids under 5, and yet they hardly ever play outside with one another. One mother is agorophobic and she has a 2 year old that no one has ever seen except the 3 times that we saw them in the car on the way by.

These overprotective, overbearing nitwits are becoming their kids own worst enemy. Sure, there are weirdos out there. Chances are a lot higher you will die from a car accident than being kidnapped.

My Mom not only let us kids play outside, she would get us dressed and push us outside and tell us not to come back inside to play until dark. Life was great back then. Of course, we only had 4 channels on TV and Pong was just coming out.

Brian in Brighton

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

#7

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

Lee Ohmart

>While I agree with the postings that currently many children are segregated from nature and that this has been proven to aggravate the emergence of allergy to normal environmental substances, there is another piece of the puzzle. Denis touched on it when he commented on smog. Pollutants have the effect of irritation the respiratory tract and this in turn exacerbates mild allergic reactions. One of the body's reactions to irritants is to enhance the natural defense mechanisms especially in the area of the irritation. Cells in the blood stream that protect us against disease also initiate the allergic response often referred to as the histamine cascade. That's why allergic people take anti-histamines, to block the histamine. So to a certain extent, it is nurture. Children need to get out there, touch as many animals as possible and play in the mud. As we say in Maine, "You gotta eat a peck of dirt before you die."

On the other hand, allergies do have a genetic link. We see in children born to people with allergies a significant increase in the number of thier children also expressing allergic responses. Denis, your wife's theory on genetic inbreeding due to population increases has intrigued me as well. I've never seen any studies to support it, however.

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

#8

Re: Many people are to overprotective

Larry Clinton

>When I was young, I was intentionally exposed to measles, mumps, chicken pox etc. My mother always believed the childhood diseases were far less dangerous while a child was young. I did the same thing when we raised our 6 children. I have done some fairly extensive reading involving this subject and it appears the current belief among physicians support this theory. I have also read studies involving groups of children that were isolated from exposure to common germs and pollutants. It appears they are far less healthy and have far more serious effects from diseases they do contract than children that lead normal lives and who contract the many common diseases. Salmonella is a prime example. In the forties and fifties I had never heard of it. I had an ulcer and was advised by my doctor to ingest Raw eggs (sucked them from the shell), whipping cream and lots of butter, in an effort to coat my stomach. No one was particular about separating raw chicken from cooked, or disinfecting the counter when cutting handling raw chicken. Most chickens were taken directly from the yard, killed, cleaned and cooked in an hour or so. As far as air pollution, most all the cars & trucks smoked bad enough to track them visually for a mile or so. We also had a train track about a block from our house - ran coal fired steam engines, really made the women run when the wind blew toward their wash hanging on the line. Course we burned all the leaves, trash and limbs when needed. I am currently 66 and have zero allergies, rarely have a cold and am healthier than most teenagers I know.

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

#9

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

John E

>I'm an MD, but can't say I've seen any "science" on the subject. I just thought I'd throw out one of my favorite quotes from one of my mentors during medical training. This older physician was being fussed at by a nurse for not wearing a mask during a procedure (a bronchoscopy). Keep in mind, the mask was for his protection, not the patients, otherwise there would have been no argument. His reply was "You've got to challenge your immune system!" There IS science behind that - your immune system responds to stimuli - no stimuli, no response.

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

#10

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

paul in AZ

>Denis:

You have to be careful to differentiate between an allergy -which is an immune response- and a chemical insult -a "poisoning" if you will.

A chemical, be it anything from smog to a cannister of tear gas will affect everybody to some extent.

An allergen requires a host genetically preprogrammed to react, an initial exposure to set up the reaction and then whatever subsequent exposures that make one sick. This is why of the millions who eat peanut butter for eg. only a few will react to the peanuts. As with other things like some infectious diseases DNA is why some get it and others with the same exposure don't.

I'm hard pressed to buy the inbreeding thing though.

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

#11

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Carol, It wasn't the wash cloth that scared me--but I did have lots of concern about that yardstick Mom would sometimes don. Usually meant I was in trouble for something!

Come to think about it, I think I was allergic to that thing!

Ron in Iowa

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

#12

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

John in Calgary

>This is all very interesting.

I grew up in a small town (our house wasn't in the country, but I did play in the ravine next to our house for hours on end like some of the posts above) and never had any trouble with allergies or sensitivities. Now that I live in the city, I have trouble with plugged sinuses, runny noses and sensitivities to a few foods (first MSG and now garlic, of all things).

My kids spend a lot of time outside, but not necessarily tromping through the woods (think of a 2 year old trying to be like her two bigger sisters carrying a worm around in her hand as if she were holding a shovel for 2 hours one day). They haven't had any trouble with runny noses and allergic reactions, but I have two daughters that have a sensitivity to wheat and one (the youngest at 2) who now seems to be developing a sensitivity to milk protein like her mother.

I'm still working on my own theories about my own problems (I think its a combination of the weird atmospheric pressure changes in Calgary and the ability of high rise office towers to concentrate allergens) so I'm not sure if this supports Denis's ideas or not.

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

#13

a new world is opening up with the epigenome *LINK*

Albert

>http://www.wired.com/medtech/health/news/2005/08/68468


nova

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

#14

Re: Allergies? Get a dog

Myra in TN

>Although a dog is no guarantee (but a great companion for your children). We had three dogs who had the run of the house (except for our bedrooms) as long as we were at home. My daughter had severe asthma and multiple allergies, some life threatening. She still has potentially life threatening allergies and asthma as a 25 year old. Our focus was always on learning to live a normal life while keeping them asthma/allergies under control.

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

#15

Re: Allergies? Get a dog? Heck NO!

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Dan,

Two of my sons were severely allergic to several things including some foods. But we soon discovered that our beloved little dog made Ed's life miserable and he required frequent hospitalization. We had to get rid of the dog or get rid of the child. Fortunately we found a good home for the dog. When Jimmy came along, history repeated itself. He is "worst case" according to the family Doctor. No pets in this house.

George

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

#16

Re: Allergies? Get a dog

Dan Mitchell

>Myrna & George - I don't think the studies authors meant their findings to be a prescription, and of course my subject line was tongue in cheek. Still, a 70% decrease in allergy cases is an impressive figure, which of course, as is always the case with such findings is subject to further study. The study results specifically relate to where a pet was present in the child's 1st year. I would be curious to know if that was the case with your kids, or if the pet(s) were added after that time.

Dan

Re: OT - Allergies - Nature vs. "nurture"

#17

out of the woods

JohnKJordan in East TN

>It's sad that some kids never get the outside experience.

I have families with small children come to the farm as much as I can. Once I was driving a 4-wheeler down one of my trails into the woods with a 5-year old girl. She suddenly got very quiet, looking around. She said "I've never seen the INSIDE of a forest before." Yikes! I've finally found my calling in life.

JKJ