Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

woodworking

Posts

woodworking

#1

woodworking

troy patterson

>just to say hi just visted your site kinda like it I do scrollsaw art work and was wondering if you had any sugestions on the best possible oak woods to use thank you very for your time troy

Re: woodworking

#2

Oak and the scroll saw

Terry Quiram

>Troy

I have been scrolling for 20 years and I have found that Oak is not a particularly good wood for scrolling. The wood will hold up and you can do some fine detail in Oak but the big open pores tend to distract from the design. You want folks to see your design and the wood second. I feel that the design gets washed out when using Oak. If you are determined to use Oak then go either Red or White with close/tight grain and flat sawn with as little figure as possible.

Terry

Re: woodworking

#3

Re: woodworking

Steven Mellott

>I've also had a great deal of difficulty cuttimg oak and keeping the blade perfectly vertical. (The blade seems to bend within the kerf (on 3/4" wood) no matter how tight the tension is.) Granted, I'm new to scroll sawing, so it may be more attributed to operator error than the oak wood itself.

Re: woodworking

#4

Re: Oak and the scroll saw-50% disagree

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Terry,

I somewhat disagree with you, in as much that it depends on the project itself. Some projects lend themselves to certain woods, regardless of the way it's processed. At the same time, the finish you use can make all the difference, too. And last, beauty is in the eye of the beholder. What one guy raves on and on about, the next guy is choking and gagging!

Possibly what Troy was asking is what grade of oak would be the best for scroll work, and to that I would recommend select or better if you want no, or minimal, knots and blemishes for larger projects. If you're doing scroll sawing on smaller projects, you can save some money by using a lower grade such as #1 or better, even #2 or better, and working around the blemishes. Knots and the like are something you're going to want to pay close attention to if you're doing a fretwork portrait of, say John Wayne, or Elvis Pressly, which can ruin the whole thing because of wood coloration or if the knot falls out!

Hope this helps, Troy, and welcome to WoodCentral!

Ron in Iowa


img

Re: woodworking

#5

Re: woodworking *LINK*

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Steve,

If you're interested in scroll sawing, here's a fellow Iowian and scroll sawer that has taught me a lot! His name is Rick Hutcheson, from Grimes, Iowa. If you read through his web site, he'll tell you what you're doing wrong or right.

Ron in Iowa


Rick's scroll sawing

Re: woodworking

#6

we use punctuation on this site

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>it makes reading posts easier as has been found to be the case for many hundred years.

Re: woodworking

#7

Second that

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>

Re: woodworking

#8

Dale Lenz

Re: Welcome aboard

Dale Lenz

>...and I hope you will come back often. MOST of us are a friendly bunch, willing to help. Sorry, I'm not a scroll-saw person, even turned a S-saw down for free. : ' >.

Re: woodworking

#9

Capitals help too!

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Capital letters help too. Or Uppercase, if you prefer.

Sorry Bill, couldn't resist ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: woodworking

#10

HEY MARK YOU MEAN LIKE THIS?????????

Dan Mitchell

>

Re: woodworking

#11

Lee Grindinger

ornery old farts

Lee Grindinger

>not everyone here uses either caps or punctuation, somtimes speling is a bit off too but it reallly does,nt matter because we ar all here for the wouldwerking and passing along infurmation kinda like gas

lee

Re: woodworking

#12

Re: ornery

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Hey Lee,

I'll take the infermashun, but don't need any more gas than I have already. Thanks anyways.

|;-}}}