Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Opinions on Freud 3HP Router???

Posts

Opinions on Freud 3HP Router???

#1

Opinions on Freud 3HP Router???

Bill H-Evansville, IN

>I'm in the market for a bigger router to mount in my table to raise some panels for cabinets. The low price of the Freud (FT2200E) makes it very attractive. American woodworker reviewed it favorably, but Popular Woodworking was less impressed. Has anybody tried it that can comment on it's performance? Or should I spend the bucks for a Bosch?

Thanks,

Bill

Re: Opinions on Freud 3HP Router???

#2

Re: Opinions on Freud 3HP Router???

mdclor

>I've had the older model in my table for years. It does everything I ask of it. I haven't even thought of replacing it. Happy hunting!

Merle

Re: Opinions on Freud 3HP Router???

#3

Re: Opinions on Freud 3HP Router???

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Bill,

That would have been my 1st choice when I was in the market for a big one. It was unavailable anywhere locally, and so were the Hitachi M-12 and the DeWalt 625. I drove all the way to Delaware where I heard Lowes had a close-out on the DeWalts. As luck had it, the Porter Cable folks had a 7518 returned, and I was able to get that for $285. It has been a wonderful performer for the passed 8 years or so. I use it for wider bits/raising panels, etc. I would have found each of the heavyweights would have served my needs. At the time I had to go with what was available or lose the job. I lucked out, and lived happily ever after. The P+C was still the most expensive, but the job paid for it, and then some.

George

Re: Opinions on Freud 3HP Router???

#4

Re: Opinions on Freud 3HP Router???

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I really like mine, a FT2000E. It lives in a table, and doesn't do freehand any more, but it works well, really well, for that job. Money well spent, and that's not something I can say about everything I bought back in those early years.

Re: Opinions on Freud 3HP Router???

#5

Re: Opinions on Freud 3HP Router???

Jerry Nicholson

>Mine has been modified for table use only (springs and rubber booties removed) and works great. I have raised panels in walnut and red oak without any difficulty whatsoever. I am not sure how long I have had it - 8 to 10 years I would guess.

Jerry

Re: Opinions on Freud 3HP Router???

#7

Crass commercial announcement.

Art Silva

>Woodcraft has the Freud 2200E on sale for $199.99 until 12/31/07.

Mom says make your move, the supply is limited.

Re: Opinions on Freud 3HP Router???

#8

Re: Opinions on Freud 3HP Router??? *LINK*

knotscott

>I had the FT2000E which was a predecessor. My only complaint was the size of the throat opening...it's smaller than the big 3" bits, but there are viable work arounds. AFAIK, the only other decent 3hp choice in that price range is the big Hitachi M12V2...on sale thru Amazon now for ~ $130 shipped.

The Bosch is a nice router, but in that price range, I'd go for the Milwaukee 5625 or the PC7518....both proven powerhouses. The MW has better above table features than the PC.


MW5625

Re: Opinions on Freud 3HP Router???

#9

Re: Opinions on Freud 3HP Router???

JEB

>I have one I purchased in 1998 specifically for that purpose (to make raised panels). I've been very pleased with it's performance, and for the price, you can't beat it.

It doesn't come with any frills, even the manual is very basic (at least mine was 10 years ago), but for what you save on the cost of the router, you can buy any accessories you might need.

Although it's probably one other larger routers, one feature I really like is the speed adjuster. It allows you to lower the speed for the large panel bits, but increase it for smaller bits in softer woods.

As we speak, I'm using mine to trim out the mortises in the legs for the workbench frame I'm in the process of building. I'd don't use mine out of the table very often, but my smaller router is a fix base unit (actually I have two, an old craftsman; and a really old all metal Stanley I purchased for $25 from a guy a few years ago (just had to have it)).

One suggestion I'd make, and eventually I'm going to get one for mine, if you are mainly going to use it in a table. Buy either a collet extension or one of those new add-on that allow you to raise the bit from above the table. While I can't afford the latter, I'm planning on buying the former before I do my next big project that I'll need to use the router in the table.

The one I'm planning on getting is the one from MLSC (http://www.mlcswoodworking.com/shopsite_sc/store/html/smarthtml/pages/router_collet.html). While it doesn't allow you to raise the bit from above the table, it does allow you to raise the bit/collet high enough that you can change the bit above the table.

I don't think you'd be dissapointed in you purchase. I sure haven't.

Hope this helps...JEB