Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Hide Glue and The Creeps

Posts

Hide Glue and The Creeps

#1

Hide Glue and The Creeps

Joe Burke

>I don't know if this is creep or not. I'll describe it and see what the consensus is.

Last year around Christmas I built a jewelry box and used Franklin Liquid Hide Gule for almost all the assembly. One reason I've been using the stuff is because I'd been under the impression hide glue didn't creep.

After finishing the box ... days not hours ... I noticed what could only be glue working it's way back out along some joint lines. At the edge of some spline mitres ... corners of the box ... and along some other joints where I'd glued parts together. The once very sharp and clean corners on the mitres now feel rough and it's got to be glue. It's as if the glue worked it's way back out of the joint and hardened off. It can't be anything else.

So what gives? I've reread my info and hide glue is listed as a good option against creep, and there was no bad mouthing of the liquid stuff.

Is this creep or something else, and why might it have happened?

I used the same hide glue in the last couple of days to inlay some 1/16th inch rosewood stringing and after scraping and sanding it flush I can now feel a bit of the same thing along that line.

Set me straight before I move to urea formaldahyde powder. I know that won't creep.

Re: Hide Glue and The Creeps

#2

Re: Hide Glue and The Creeps

John Pappas

>I think of creep as movement of parts under stress or tension such as would occur in a curved lamination. Without lateral stress parts are not going to creep. I wonder if what you have is a case of wood that has lost some moisture content since assembly. The glue didn't shrink, and the wood did, thus you feel a slight difference in the previously perfect surface. I have had that happen with table tops that I have assembled. Just my hunch.

Re: Hide Glue and The Creeps

#3

Creepwise, LHG does not equal HHG. *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Resistance to glue creep is one reason guitar builders continue to use HHG for affixing bridges. Liquid hide glue, not so much, although some LHGs are less creepy than others.

From "I�ll stick with hide glue...", Frank Ford, (see link):

"Commercial liquid hide glues have gel suppressants & remain liquid at room temperature. They are not quite as useful for most instrument work: slightly greater tendency for the joint to �creep,� lower moisture & heat resistance, short shelf life, no initial tack. Many instrument makers and repairers use liquid hide glue, but they are (or should be) careful to test each batch, in addition to watching the expiration date printed on the bottle.

Urea will extend the working time of the glue, and will not weaken the adhesion if it is mixed with the glue just before use. More than 5-10% urea (by dry weight) may increase the flexibility of the dried glue; it may allow glue joints to �creep� more, especially in heat stress. Most instrument builders and repairers try to avoid having to use urea.

When a hide glue joint is clamped, thick liquid glue should squeeze out all around. If the squeeze-out is �crumbly� when rubbed with a finger, or has the texture of cottage cheese, the joint may not have been clamped in time. Excess glue should be washed off finished surfaces to avoid chipping the finish as the glue dries and shrinks."


"I'll stick with hide glue...", Frank Ford

Re: Hide Glue and The Creeps

#4

agreed

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I agree with this hypothesis.

Re: Hide Glue and The Creeps

#5

Re: Creepwise, LHG does not equal HHG.

tstock

>Agree - liquid hide glue is really not suitable for joints which will be stressed. Hot hide glue should work for you, and the set-up to use it is cheap...a $12 hot pot from Walmart, a cheap digital candy thermometer to monitor water bath or glue temp (150 degree water gives me 145 degree glue), a jelly jar, a brush or two, and a borrowed hair dryer to heat larger surfaces for more working time. Add a squeeze bottle if you need the extra speed and extra heat of thicker HHG.

192g HHG gels around 95 degrees F, so keep the surfaces and glue above that until clamped and you are in business. Wait until the squeeze-out has gelled, then scrape the excess - comes off like...slightly sticky Jello. Wipe with a bit of warm water to catch any residue...much faster and easier cleanup than Titebond and no nasty yellow stains.


img

Re: Hide Glue and The Creeps

#6

Re: Hide Glue and The Creeps

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Joe,

I need to know the wood you used and the area of the country you live in, hide glue behaves differently in other environs.

Sounds like the wood swelled from the moisture and just squirted a little out as the pours swelled up, I could be wrong.

Once the initial squeeze out happens it shouldn't be a problem but fluctuations in temperature and humidity may cause it to expand or contract slightly, but I doubt it. Also a thick glue joint can cause this to occur.

But creep is something that takes time so what you experienced may just be moisture adjustment at the time of gluing.

If this does not answer your question or if the condition persists we can go into it further.

Stephen

Re: Hide Glue and The Creeps

#7

Re: Hide Glue and The Creeps

Paul Woolson

>I've been thinking about this since the original post. I'm not familiar with the liquid hide glues as I always mix my own.

My thought on what you are calling creep might be that the glue absorbed some moisture from the finish. That re-softened the glue and then it had to re set. This process might have made it expand a bit.