Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

Posts

OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

#1

OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

John T in MD

>Sorry for the OT post, but I've gotten no real help from the computer forums i've explored.... Just condescention and ridicule....

My computer (MPC Clientpro 345, running Windows Xp Home, Intel P4 processor, 1 GB DDR SDRAM (as 2 DIMM's), and a 40 GB Seagate ATA Hard Drive) has recently begun spontaneously jumping into reboot mode. Doesn't seem to matter what i'm doing, or what programs i'm running - it will be working fine, then, without warning or blue screen of death, the screen goes black, and the boot sequesnce has started - I see the RAM counting up, and the whole thing, as if i just started. It even happens when i first power on the computer in the morning, sometimes without even completing the boot sequence before kicking back into the counting RAM part, soemtimes making it all the way into Windows, sometimes waiting till i've logged in before going black and counting RAM again. Then, it may be good for several hours, and will suddenly go black and reboot.

I've run Norton antivirus and AVG scans, and no evidence of viruses or other malware. I've run the Microsoft Memory Diagnostic software, and the chips appear to be OK....

Also, System Properties/Startup and Recovery/ Auto restart on System Failure is disabled, so I should be getting an error message if there's a problem - yes??

Any ideas?? I've been really bad, and don't have backups to speak of, so reformatting the drive and reinstalling windows will be odious to say the least....

Feel free to email me directly if you have any suggestions. Thanks for any help.

-JOhn-

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

#2

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

Jerry Nicholson

>This sounds like a hardware problem, either the system board or the power supply. If it can fail before starting the memory test, then reformatting the hard drive and reinstalling the software won't help (better get those files backed up though). If you know someone with a spare compatible power supply you might try that but my best bet is that this is a system board failure. Your hard drive could be temporarily installed in another computer so you can back up your files. A system board can be replaced but unless the replacement is exactly identical to the original Windows XP will probably complain and require re-activation.

Jerry

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

#3

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

David Yoho

>John, I'm afraid I can't offer any help. I went down this road with my last computer, a Win-98 system I built. After years of service the same thing started happening. I figured it was a hardware issue and proceeded to replace parts in an order of highest suspect to lowest. In all, I replaced the motherboard (hard to locate an exact duplicate after all the years passed since new), video card, CPU chip, and power supply - everything but the hard drive and memory.

At first it looked like that solved it. Then after about a week or two, the problem returned. Tired of throwing money at an old system, I gave up and went with a new XP unit. I still don't know what happened or why. I later used the old hard drive after formatting it as an external USB drive without any issues. I don't think the memory was the issue either, so maybe it was really software related.

David

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

#4

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

Chuck W

>How many watts is the power supply and how old is it?

Computers that randomly reboot can have a bad supply or bad memory.

I run memtest 86 to check for faulty memory. Go into the BIOS and see what the voltages are. A voltage that fluctuates too much may indicate a bad supply.

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

#5

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Bummer. Check the Event Viewer under System Tools to see if there are any hints there just before the crash. (I don't use XP home, but the Event Viewer should be in there somewhere.)

It's hard to guess without having the machine in hand, but I agree that it is very likely a hardware problem. If so, if you go to all the trouble of reformatting and manage somehow to reinstall the OS you will still have the same problem. That you are not getting a blue screen error message is typical for some problems - remember, to display an error message means the system has to be stable enough to catch and pass an error condition to a low level software routine to display the error text on the screen.

A typical problem is with bad memory. On high-end graphics machines, we often ran into hardware stability issues with mismatched memory - someone would install simms from two different sources and they sometimes would not play well together.

I'm not familiar with the Microsoft memory test you mentioned - we always used and recommended running Memtest86. You have to create a boot disk to run this one and it is doesn't miss much. It's a free/public domain program but I see one web site selling a bootable CD (http://www.memtest86.com/). I also found a site still providing free downloads (http://www.memtest.org/). The binary version can be copied to a bootable floppy or CD; the ISO version can be dumped to a CD to create the bootable CD. If the Microsoft memory diagnostic works the same way, I'll bet a nickle they just packaged the open source memtest86 with the MS name!

If you have the resources, another common memory test is to temporarily replace the memory with known good modules from another machine. Another old memory trick is to remove modules one at a time - if a problem is with one the system may run with it missing. This is not possible on some motherboards (they need to work in pairs), but occasionally swapping the modules will be revealing if the problem goes away or the symptoms change.

As also mentioned, a faulty power supply is a common cause and difficult to catch in the act even with a good scope. Fortunately, you can replace the power supply inexpensively and see if that fixes things. Power supplies are pretty good these days, but if the power is iffy in your area (voltage transients) a UPS unit can do wonders.

A display card (or other card) can also cause reboot problems. The diagnostic routine here is to simplify the system as much as possible (remove all unnecessary cards), then temporarily substitute a different display card. Unfortunately, this is easier said than done unless you have a stack of hardware on the shelf or other machines to rob.

One simple thing I've done which has fixed hardware problems like this - reseat all connectors, cards, and chips in the system. Connectors can fail over time from oxidation/corrosion on contacts. Reseating simply involves removing and reinstalling each component. This action tends to scrape away any oxidation. For example, pull out the power supply connector and push it back in. Remove each card and reinsert it. Unclip each memory module (carefully) and reinstall. If there are any chips in sockets, push them down with your finger or thumb (they can work loose with heat cycles) - if they don't push down a bit, I pry them up slightly and push them back. I can't tell you how many computers I've fixed over the years with my finger!

Unfortunately, there are other motherboard problems that are harder to diagnose and typically repaired by replacing the motherboard. These days it is often cheaper to replace the computer. If you have to go that route, since your HD directory system appears fine, you can likely remove and temporarily connect your old hard disk to a new computer and copy much of your existing data.

And as for backup, what used to be so difficult in the past (with piles of floppies, CDs, or ack, tapes, is easy now. Buy an inexpensive USB or firewire external HD and copy everything you don't want to lose. I was so paranoid when I used these computers to make a living that I rotated between seven such drives. After I retired, I cut back to three! :)

BTW, since starting with computers in the mid 70s, I've developed some of my own theories about how to manage computers. One of my hardware rules is to never shut off a machine. Each time it heats up and cools down, things can be physically stressed on cards and even within components. Along with that, I make sure I have sufficient air flow - I'd add fans as necessary moving air across drives and components (my tower case 3D graphics/video machines might have every slot full, fully loaded with memory, and up to eight hot drives). And as mentioned, always power from a UPS.

JKJ

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

#6

Another possibility

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I've had a computer at home shutting down for no apparent reason, turned out to be that the CPU fan/heatsink were so dirty with dust that they didn't cool the processor enough, and the motherboard had a CPU temperature threshold shutdown level that shut down the PC instead of burning the CPU. However, since at least the Pentium IV, Intel has a mechanism that throttles down the CPU to prevent overheating, so this might be a dead end. Still, it costs nothing to check the fan and heatsink...

The more I think about it, the more the power supply looks like the culprit. We have a PC at the office that kept busting its SCSI drives for no apparent reason. Turned out it was the deficient power supply that caused the problem. The bad part was that the drives that conked out were in a four-drive RAID-0 array... No data lost, but a major PITA...

Let us know how it comes out...

DC

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

#7

About memtest

Bill Howatt

>The original program was memtest86 and it was available free. It fell into a period of no development and essentially became obsolete for newer boards. I'm not sure how it came about but another free one became available and it is called memtest86+ from www.memtest.org . It is maintained, looks similar to the original memtest86. Its current version is 1.70. The old memtest86 was taken over and brought up-to-date and they are selling a version but may have a free one as well.

I always use memtest86+.

Bill

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

#8

Re: About memtest

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Some Linux distributions (such as Ubuntu) have a memory test program available when booting with the CD. It doesn't affect anything on your PC unless you go on and decide to install Linux itself.

I had a problematic PC not long ago, and I suspected that the memory was at fault. The tech guy at the store installed the module in a new motherboard, plugged it up, then booted Ubuntu and ran the memory test. It is very thorough, taking something close to 15 min. to complete the rest.

In my case the memory was fine, it was the motherboard that had failed...

DC

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

#9

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG) *LINK*

Dan Mitchell

>I haven't read all the detailed responses completely so I apologize if someone has already suggested this, but it could be your motherboard is one of the thousands which is plagued with defective, leaking capacitors. I had a 2001 vintage Gateway with this problem which displayed the symptoms you refer to. I replaced the caps and all was well. PC was still running fine when I built my present machine last year. I've included one link on the subject, you can probably find others as well. This site has good images of leaking caps to help you determine if this is your trouble, as well as kits of capacitors for a number of boards. In my case, I ordered the caps I needed from Mouser electronics (http://www.mouser.com/index.cfm?handler=home), another option is http://www.digikey.com/, either of which should be cheaper than a kit. Pretty easy to do, if you can use a pencil soldering iron.

Hope this helps,

Dan


Bad Caps

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

#10

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi John,

I haven't read all the replies, but when my computer was doing exactly the same thing, it turned out that the breaker on that particular circuit was going bad. I had even gone so far as to plug the computer into a different outlet. Unfortunately it was on the same circuit.

Another possibility is the power supply.

Gary

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

#11

Thanks for the replies

John T in MD

>Many thanks to all who replied.

I tried reseating the cards and chips, and that didn't seem to change anything.

The capacitors all LOOKED ok, but i'm no expert on things electrical, and there COULD be a bad one in there that I can't recognize...

I downloaded and ran Memtest, and it failed to find any problems after 2 full passes.

I'm starting to suspect its the power supply fixing to go bad. Guess I'll just wait for it to fail and replace it.

Going to install a new hard drive and back up my primary drive, just in case...

Thanks again for all your replies.

Regards,

-John-

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

#12

Good Suggestion, Denis

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>Along with the CPU heatsink as a possible culprit is the thermal paste that interfaces the CPU and heatsink. If it has any voids or has diried out and separated it will cause the CPU to shut down due to overheating. It will be random sometimes during a search for a webpage. I recently had this problem and it turned out to be the thermal paste that had void in of about 1/4" dia.

Radio Shack sells this paste.

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

#13

Re: Thanks for the replies

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>If it's the PS that's defective (and it could very well be, given the apparent age of your machine it would be no surprise) I would change the PS right away. Because on top of the shutdown annoyance there's the risk of damaging your equipment, as it has happened to me.

DC

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

#14

Re: What constitutes a failure?

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>If the machine stops in the middle of what I'm trying to do, then that's a failure. Power supplies are cheap!!!

In fact, so are new machines. You can buy a new one for about the cost of a new handplane, although it won't last you nearly as long as that LN beauty...

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

#15

Re: What constitutes a failure?

John T in MD

>Hi Glen - Yes, I agree that when the computer craps out in the middle of doing something, that IS a failure.... I actually call it something else, but "failure" is more politically correct....

I appreciate your reply, and will probably replace the power supply when my aggravation level reaches DEFCON 4....

But I don't agree that replacing the whole system is warranted - yes, a new computer can be had for relatively little cash, but there are other reasons to hold onto what basically still works. Computers (and most other technological devices, most egregiously cell phones) are not really disposable items, and shouldn't be treated as such. There are real environmental impacts to building and disposing of these "modern marvels", and just because it would be cheaper to toss it and get a new one, doesn't make it right or OK in my book.

OK, rant mode is off.

I really appreciate your response and opinion - but my life work relates to environmental conservation, and you hit that nerve.

May your cuts always be straight, and your steel always be sharp.

-John-

Re: OT-Computer Reboots at Random (LONG)

#16

Other thinkgs to check

Derek

>There could defintely be software problems.

For example, you could have a problem with Norton - I used it for a number of years and gave up re-installing it periodically when it started causing problems. I had to uninstall it and re-install it. Many people had this problem with it.

You could have a problem with the file system. Have you run scandisk on your system? Have you defragmented it? You need to do this in Safe Mode on the boot partition.

Have you run the File Signature Verification tool? This will check many Windows files.

Is Windows up-to-date? Have you gotten all of Microsoft's patches?

It is even possible that one of your device drivers is corrupted.

Have you removed everything from your Windows startup that you can live without? I have found that CCleaner is good for this.

As far a power supply goes - do you have a digital volt meter? You can measure the actual voltage. If the voltages are within spec, you could still have a problem but if they are out you know you do have one.

Does the problem really happen randomly? Does it happen more frequently when the computer is warm? Intermittent hardware problems very often occur when the temperature is high since the circuits run more slowly and particular logic may fail if it runs too slowly (usually RAM or CPU).

If all else fails, try reinstalling Windows from scratch - then you need to reinstall all of your software. Make SURE you back everything up first - you should do this anyway.

Good luck ! These problems can be hard to trace.