Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

While we're on the subject of electrical shock...

Posts

While we're on the subject of electrical shock...

#1

While we're on the subject of electrical shock...

John E

>The post below reminded me of a problem I've been meaning to ask about. I have a Craftsman contractor tablesaw, and if my feet are ever wet (for example, working outside and the grass is wet, then come in to cut a board) it shocks the bejeebies out of me if I touch anything metal on the saw. No problems at all with dry feet. Outlet and plug are grounded. Any ideas on an easy fix? Fortunately, it is rarely a problem (paricularly since it seem's like it's never going to rain here in SC again.)

John

Re: While we're on the subject of electrical shock...

#2

Re: While we're on the subject of electrical shock

Dan Donaldson

>Tie a ground wire from the metal frame of the saw to a known grounded point. Also, you might want to make sure there is electrical continuity between the base of the saw and the top. If not, then bond them together.

Re: While we're on the subject of electrical shock...

#3

Re: While we're on the subject of electrical shock

Rick Christopherson

>The "wet feet" problem indicates that there is a voltage between the metal chassis and the "Local" earth. Because of this, it is a little harder to diagnose without more information, or taking some educated guesses.

If your workshop is in an isolated building, then it may be that your "Electrical" ground is not the same voltage as your "Earth" ground. The Earth is not at zero volts, nor is the voltage equal from place to place. If this is a separate building, then code requires that you install a new ground rod, and make sure that this rod is electrically tied back into the main grounding system of the house. The same holds true, but not a requirement, if the shop is just located a long way away from the load center but still attached to the main building. It is not terribly uncommon for there to be a voltage difference between the ground wire and the local earth ground.

The next issue relates to the common mis belief that Ground and Neutral are the same, and therefore interchangeable. It is possible that somewhere in your system the ground wire and the neutral wire were reversed.

Finally, it is possible that even though the saw has a grounded plug, it doesn't mean that someone hasn't disconnected the ground wire. You should be able to trace the ground wire from the main panel all the way to a chassis ground screw on the saw. A missing ground will cause the chassis to float to a higher voltage even of there are no shorts or other electrical connections.

Re: While we're on the subject of electrical shock...

#4

More info...

John E

>Shop is in the basement, and the saw is only about 10 feet from the load center. House (and of course, electrical system) only about 4 years old, but the saw is about 10-15 years old. I bought the saw new, so if it's screwed up, it came that way :) I've checked the ground at the outlet, and it's good. Apparently there's some type of short in the saw, but I don't really know how to track it down.

Also of note, the saw did the same thing at our old house, so I would imagine that effectively rules out any problems with the "house wiring".

I've thought about the ground wire from the chassis idea, but have concrete floors, so I'm not sure how to accomplish that.

Thanks,

John

Re: While we're on the subject of electrical shock...

#5

Re: While we're on the subject of electrical shock

Chuck W

>If you own a VOM you could measure the potential between the saw table top and ground. This should be 0 volts or close to it if the saw is properly grounded. There may be a problem in the motor where something is not isolated from ground. Or it could be a bare wire touching, maybe in the switch.

Re: While we're on the subject of electrical shock...

#6

Re: More info...

waroland

>If you have a VOM meter check continuity between the ground pin on the saw plug to the chassis of the saw. It should read real close to the same reading when the meter leads are shorted together, check it in several places including the top. If you don't have a VOM meter, you should get one they are not very expensive.

Re: While we're on the subject of electrical shock...

#7

Re: More info...

Rick Christopherson

>OK, since the ground at the outlet seems to be fine, then the problem likely resides between the saw's plug and the chassis.



  • Did the saw come with a plug on it when you bought it new? Many

    do not, so it is possible that when the plug was installed on the saw's

    power cord, the ground wire was not connected, or was reversed with the

    neutral (120 volt saw). If this is anything other than a moulded (one-piece) plug,

    then I suggest opening the plug to check the wires.


  • Where the power cord enters the motor junction box, the ground

    wire (green) should be connected to a chassis grounding screw (also

    green).


  • If you have a continuity tester, unplug the saw and check for

    continuity between the ground prong on the plug and the metal tabletop.

    If you do have continuity, then you may be too quick to eliminate house

    wiring problems.
If the saw was properly grounded and there was a short in the wiring, this would typically trip the circuit breaker, so a short is not quite as likely. Furthermore, the ground wire would still prevent the chassis voltage from elevating.

Re: While we're on the subject of electrical shock...

#8

Re: While we're on the subject of electrical shock

Brian in Brighton

>I would look close into the wiring box on the motor. It is likely that the ground screw is not connected well. Also check the continuity between the motor housing and the saw frame. Perhaps the paint is keep the gound poor and the problem only shows up when you have a better ground than the machine. If so, tie a new ground wire from the motor frame to the machine frame and scrape off the paint where you do it. The continuity between the motor frame and the chassis frame should be 0.

Brian in Brighton.

Re: While we're on the subject of electrical shock...

#9

This is very, very dangerous.

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>Unplug and do not use this saw until you find and correct the problem. I'm surprised you're alive; you must get along well with the man upstairs. Nothing except the wiring and motor is supposed to carry current. It only takes 5 milliamps of current to arrest your heart.

Establishing a ground connection (which you don't have now) will not solve the problem, it should simply cause your circuit breaker to trip (thereby saving your life). You either have a short circuit, a reversed ground and neutral, or, if you're wired for 220, a reversed hot and ground. I'm not a professional elecrician, so there may be other explanations, but I'd start with these.

Re: While we're on the subject of electrical shock...

#10

Re: This is very, very dangerous.

Nathan

>I agree with you that it's best to be on the safe side. The saw is definitely not properly grounded, and if he can't check himself he should have someone look at it. That said, the problem could be just that some part of the saw is not grounded, not necessarily a real and present danger of electrocution. Can't the shock current be coming from a build-up of static electricity from flying sawdust in and around the saw?

Re: While we're on the subject of electrical shock...

#11

More info for anyone interested...

John E

>I spent some time checking things out last night, and am still baffled. Checked the outlet again, and ground is fine. (Voltmeter showed 120+ volts from hot to ground and hot to neutral). Also, there is continuity between the tabletop and the motor and base of the saw. There is also continuity between the ground prong on the chord and all metal parts of the saw. Chord came factory installed, if your interested. Also, the shock can happen anytime the saw is plugged in, not just running, so I don't think the motor is "inducing" any kind of voltage in the frame when it's running (have seen this explanation in the past). Again, the problem happens ONLY if wet feet. It's fine any other time - not even a tingle. Obviously, the easy solution is just don't use the saw with wet feet, but I'd really like to make sure this isn't anything bad. (But I don't plan on paying an electrician a bunch of money to look at a saw that's not worth much - hope to upgrade one day)

Re: While we're on the subject of electrical shock...

#12

Re: More info for anyone interested...

Dan Donaldson

>Sounds like the ground for the circuit and the "ground" are not at the same potential. It might be interesting to drive some kind of a ground rod near the shop and measure from the circuit ground to that one.

I worked on a problem sorta like that many years ago. The complaint was that if you sit in the bathtub and touch the faucet, you would get a tingle. It also happened in the kitchen it you touched the faucet. We found that there was enough voltage between the pipes and the drain to cause the problem. We fixed it by bonding the pipes and the drainage system (this house had cast iron drains, not pvc) together. We brought the issue to the attention of the power company, and it turned out that the ultimate problem was a bad ground on one of their poles and a ground fault in the electric boiler of a house down the road. It was inducing ground currents through the earth ground system and the house we were working on was directly between the pole with the problem and a nearby pole with a good ground, so it was part of the path of the ground loop. Weird stuff

Re: While we're on the subject of electrical shock...

#13

Re: More info for anyone interested...

Rick Christopherson

>John,

Unfortunately, using a multimeter to diagnose a ground problem may not always give you reliable results without a few extra checks. The continuity test you did on the ground prong to the metal chassis is probably the most reliable indication that the saw is not your problem. My original thoughts back when this discussion started were leaning toward a house wiring problem, but when you said the house was so new, I didn�t want to go down that road needlessly.

See if you can check the voltage from the saw�s top to various other tool grounds in the shop. I am guessing that you will show nearly zero volts to any other tool chassis. If that is correct, then the individual circuit grounds are also not the problem.

What remains is how well your house�s grounding system is connected to the Earth itself. There are a couple of possibilities.

  1. You have a poor grounding connection at the ground rod.
  2. You have a poor grounding connection at both sides of your water meter.
  3. You have poor soil, and the grounding electrodes (ground rod plus water pipe) are insufficient for the soil conditions.
  4. You have an excessively large leakage current in your grounding system, which is elevating the ground voltage of the soil near your ground rod.
The first two are relatively easy to check. This is also a case where you want a digital volt meter if possible. Check all of the voltages between both sides of your water meter, the ground rod itself, and the chassis of the main load center. All of these should have a voltage less than 1 volt on a digital meter.

Items 3 and 4 are a little harder to check. For item 4, you would need a clamp-on ammeter that you can place around the ground wire that is leaving your load center and going to the ground rod and water meter. You should have some current flow through the ground wire, but not an excessive current. I checked mine a couple of years ago and I was surprised to see that it was somewhere between 10 and 15 amps. I would actually consider this to be toward the high end depending on the total load of the house.

Checking item 3 requires a good Earth ground that is isolated from your home�s grounding system. For simply testing this theory, maybe even a long screwdriver driven into damp soil would be sufficient.

If you are getting affirmative results for either 3 or 4, then you may want to consider adding one or more additional ground rods to your system, especially near your shop. Each new ground rod needs to be connected back to the main ground rod with a #6 copper wire. In some parts of the country, it is not uncommon for multiple ground rods to be required as the norm, due to poor conductivity of the soil.

Re: While we're on the subject of electrical shock...

#14

See, now this is why...

John E

>I was a chemistry major in college. Chemical reactions make so much more sense. Electricity is just too "hocus pocus" for me. I have a friend who is a mechanical engineer, and he has the same opinion.

This is also why I love woodcentral - thanks for all of the help!!

John

Re: While we're on the subject of electrical shock...

#15

Re: More info...

LoftGuy

>Hi,

John earlier said:

"Also of note, the saw did the same thing at our old house, so I would imagine that effectively rules out any problems with the "house wiring".

Possibly the same grounding situation existed at his previous house, as well, or could the saw still be at fault?

lg