Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

electrical shock

Posts

electrical shock

#1

electrical shock

eliot d

>I have a lamp in my shop with a metal shade. Yesterday, I happened to touch it(while it was on) with my right hand and touched my Jet Mini lathe bed( which was plugged in but not running) with the other hand -- and I got a shock. The plug for the lamp is not grounded, but the lathe is grounded. Can you figure out what happened and what I should do about it (besides avoid touching both at the same time.)

Re: electrical shock

#2

Re: electrical shock

Robert Henderson

>Sounds like (to a non-expert) you have the hot wire on the lamp going to the shell of the socket. Or the plug isn't polarized and you plugged it in the wrong way.

Re: electrical shock

#3

Re: electrical shock

Larry Clinton

>Sounds like your lamp is defective and that one side of the wire coming into the lamp is shorted to the metal. If you have a volt meter, you can check the lamp. First set the meter to a scale that will read 120V AC (or higher). Then insert one lead of the voltmeter into the ground lug of an outlet (the ground lug is the round hole below or above the 2 parallel slots) in the shop and the second lead to the lamp shade and other metal parts. NOTE: Sometimes the lamp cords will plug into a receptacle two ways - Since it is not a grounded plug you can try measuring the voltage and then see if you can insert the plug by turning it over. If it will insert the 2nd way it will check ok (no voltage) but should still be fixed as neither side of the line in should be conductive to any part of the lamp but the bulb. If the voltmeter reads ANY voltage, you will have to take the lamp apart and check the wiring. You can also check the lathe in the same manner to be sure it is wired correctly. If any voltage shows on the meter the lathe is wired incorrectly, but this is highly unlikely as touching the lamp and the lathe should not shock you even if the lathe were wired wrong as the lamp is not grounded.

Re: electrical shock

#4

Lamp needs repairing!!

Bill Howatt

>There is a high probability that one of the lamp connections is touching the metal part of the socket and thus energizing all metal parts in contact with the socket shell.

Most likely the wire that attaches to the "threads" on the bulb (the socket shell) is the problem. If the plug was polarized and properly wired and plugged into a properly wired receptacle the neutral wire would be touching and since it is also at ground potential, you wouldn't have been shocked. It is still broken though!!! You probably don't have a polarized plug or it is wired wrong so the hot wire is on the shell rather than the center contact. In the pre-polarized plug days this happened 50% of the time a plug was inserted (can go in either way) and if the lamp wiring is in good shape it doesn't matter, even if it isn't ideal.

You can take the socket apart and see what's going on. You may need a new socket if the insulating sleever or other parts are bad. sometimes it is just a strand of wire touching from the connection screws. The lamp insulation could also be cracked where the wire enters the lamp. An ohmmeter/voltmeter is handy for checking these things especially after repairing so you don't have to do a "shock-test" in the electrical sense of the word.

Anyway, get it fixed or throw it out.

Bill

Re: electrical shock

#5

Re: electrical shock

Barry Irby

>Elliot, You can buy an electrical plug tester at a Borg for 3 or 4 dollars, 10 or 12 if you want to get on that will do GFCI outlets. Its good to start by testing the outlets and making sure both are wired correctly.

If you have a meter, you can test eh outlets manually. There should be three openings. Two slots and a round or horseshoe shaped one. One of the slots is wider/taller than the other. The round or horseshoe shaped one should be the ground, the wider slot the neutral, and the narrower slot the hot. With you meter, there should be Zero volts between the ground and the neutral. There should be about 120 volts (+/- about 5%) between the hot and the neutral and between the hot and the ground. If this is not correct, you have to start by repairing the outlets. If the wider slot is hot, you have "reversed polarity" in the outlet.

The lamp may have a polarity plug. One prong wider than he other, forcing you to plug it in only one way. If plugged in properly, the only thing "hot" on the lamp should be the little tongue or contact in the bottom of the socket. The threaded shell should be neutral and the rest of the lamp should not be attached to either one. With the lamp plugged in but turned off, test from the threaded shell to the neutral in a proper outlet. Should read ZERO. From the threaded shell to the hot in a proper outlet should read 120 volts+/-. The exterior parts of the light should read Zero to both the hot and the ground. With the lamp's switch on It should read 120 volts from the little tongue to either ground or neutral and it should still read Zero to any of the exterior parts.

Where polarity is important is on a lamp. To get a shock, you should have to stick your finger into the socket and touch the contact on the tongue int he bottom of the socket. If the polarity is reversed and the threaded socket is energised, it is potentially dangerous. As you unscrew the bulb, the threads are energised until the bulb is removed. In a properly wired lamp, and soon as the bulb breaks contact with the little tongue, nothing is energised.

It sounds like at the very least you have reversed polarity. It also sounds like there is stray current on the exterior of the lamp. There may be wires inside touching some part of the metal housing they should not touch.

Re: electrical shock

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Ground fault in the lamp.....

Jesper, Denmark

>You have a ground fault in the lamp. Not enough to short it, but something like a frayed wire or loose connecton between the wire and the socket.

Yopu need to find it and fix it. It can be anywhere inside the lamp.

This is what ground fault relays are protecting against - not a bad idea to get one.

Re: electrical shock

#7

The end is near...!

Rick Christopherson

>Well OK so that's a bit of an over reaction, but I think some of the postings might be as well. You didn't provide enough information for people to forewarn of death and doom. :)

It is entirely possible for nothing to be wrong with either your light or your lathe to experience a slight shock. (We also don't even know what type of lamp this is.) From the tone of your message, I get the impression that you did not receive a full 120 volt zap, so that leaves two possibilities, and both are relatively minor.

The first possibility is simply that you are far enough electrically away from your main load center that you will have a voltage difference between the neutral and ground, and for some reason, this lamp has the chassis tied to the neutral wire (which is improper). If your workshop is running off of a subpanel, then this is extremely likely. There is nothing you can really do about it, except to ground the lamp.

The second possibility is that the lamp shade is isolated (as it should be when no ground wire is present) and current flowing through the lamp's conductors is inducing a voltage in the shade. In this case, there is nothing wrong with any of the wiring, except that the metal components of the lamp should have been grounded with a 3-prong plug. For example, if this was a ceiling fixture, then it was designed to be grounded, but someone installed it without a ground.

Without knowing more about the type of lamp, it is hard to say, but my first thought is that this is a lamp that was supposed to be grounded, but someone installed it without a grounding plug.

Re: electrical shock

#8

Re: electrical shock

eliot d

>Thanks for all the responses. I appreciate it.

Re: electrical shock

#9

may be nearer than you think

JohnKJordan in East TN

>It is also possible the shock was slight due to low contact resistance, but the next one might be more exciting.

My experiece with this: some years ago we had a student working in one of our optical labs who happened to touch one of the steel optical tables with one hand while touching something else (a ground elsewhere in the room) with another. He experienced a slight shock. On investigation, I found that months earlier an electrician had wired an extension cable for a 220v device from a 440v outlet. He had wired it incorrectly, putting a high voltage on a ground wire (if I remember correctly). It was amazing that it wasn't discovered earlier and a miracle that no one was injured. (It's a very bad thing to kill a student on the job.) If the student had made better contact (e.g., had sweaty hands), the shock would not have been slight.

JKJ

Re: electrical shock

#10

Re: may be nearer than you think

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>I've seen the metal grid for a suspended ceiling hot from the installer shooting a nail into the black conductor of an NM feeder.

Re: electrical shock

#11

Cool, you could drive BumperCars in there :)

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>

Re: electrical shock

#12

Re: electrical shock ; the plot thickens

eliot d

>Indeed the polarity of the plug was reversed. So I fixed it. Then I plugged the lamp in, with the lamp off, and found no voltage between the threaded shell and the neutral part of the outlet. BUT, there was about 14V between the exterior of the lamp to the neutral part of the outlet and about 38 V to the hot part of the outlet. So I took apart the lamp and checked it carefully. It's simple enough and all looked O.K. But there's still these potential differences between the outside of the lamp and the socket with the lamp plugged in and the switch off. By the way, the outlet is a GFI.

Re: electrical shock

#13

Re: electrical shock ; the plot thickens -more

eliot d

>The plot continues to thicken: I checked another metal gooseneck lamp in my shop. This one, too, shows about the same potential difference between the exterior of the lamp and the socket holes.

Re: electrical shock

#14

That's the stray voltage I was talking about

Rick Christopherson

>This is part of the reason why I was commenting on people overreacting to this information. When they see the word "shocked" they automatically assume that it is a short from hot to chassis, and in your case, this is not the situation.

That's not to say that a person should ignore the possible causes with a more hazardous outcome, but ignoring the non-miswired causes results in people not considering all of the other possibilities, which is exactly what you have encountered in your case.

As I stated in my original posting, you have an inductively- or capacitively-coupled metal component on your light that is the result of it not being grounded. Reversing the polarity of the plug has probably reduced this effect, but it cannot eliminate it unless you actually ground the metal component. This stray voltage is not the result of a miswired condition, and the only way to eliminate it completely is by grounding the metallic components. This will bleed of the stray charge that is normal for ungrounded components in a ground-isolated device.

At this point, I am guessing that you have used a high impedance digital voltmeter to measure the voltage from the isolated metal frame to the conductors. In most cases, this stray charge is low enough that simply using an analog voltmeter with a lower impedance bleeds off this stray charge to the point that no voltage is recorded.

To repeat what I stated previously, if you want to eliminate this completely, then you need to install a 3-prong plug on the lamp and ground the otherwise isolated metallic components.

Re: electrical shock

#15

Re: That's the stray voltage I was talking about

eliot d

>Rick, I cannot tell you how impressed I am! You must be some sort of genius! I just didn't bother to tell you all that, in fact I first used a digital multimeter, and then , just for laughs, I re-tested with an analog tester -- and sure enough, there was no effect. But I had no idea why. Just thought it was less sensitive. So should I not worry about it? Or should I ground the lamp? Or should I throw the thing away and get a grounded lamp?

What is your field? Does it in fact have to do with electricity?

Re: electrical shock

#16

Re: That's the stray voltage I was talking about

Rick Christopherson

>Thanks Eliot, I am glad you got it worked out. No, there is no reason to worry about this lamp any further. Even though the impedance of an analog voltmeter is lower than a digital voltmeter, it is still extremely high, so getting a zero reading means you have effectively no voltage at the metal (I assume it is a reflector) of the lamp.

When the lamp is turned on, then there will be slightly more charge on the reflector, but even this should be trivial. You could see if you can feel any charge when the lamp is on, but it is not something to worry too much about, and is just a matter of comfort. If you find yourself needing to touch the reflector frequently, then it is your option if you want to add a small ground wire, but this may be more work than it is worth.

Yes, I do have a background in electricity. If you want to learn more about electricity, a good start is my article Electricity in the Woodshop at: http://www.waterfront-woods.com/Articles/Electricity/electricity.htm

Re: electrical shock

#17

That's why

Dan Donaldson

>I still like the old Simpsom 260 VOM. It would load the circuit enough to prevent the high impedance readings that don't mean anything. It was also nice for watching slow moving trends. It is a lot easier to watch a needle oscillate than to try to see what is going on with a digital.

Interesting thing; we used to have some hp precision analog rms voltmeters with the mirrored scale. They got some digital versions, and if you read the specs, the digital was not as accurate as the analog for the type of stuff we were measuring. (related to pink noise and crest factor ratings.)

Re: electrical shock

#18

Re: That's the stray voltage I was talking about

eliot d

>Rick, Thanks again. You and the others were a great help. Believe it or not I have degrees in physics and mathematics.( But I could never figure out where the electrons would go in a circuit diagram once the circuit became at all complex.) I will read your link carefully. Just glancing at it, I can see that it is well -done. The analogy with the helium balloon on a string is great. Can you say why the amount of impedance in the meter is so important?

Re: electrical shock

#19

Analog Vs Digital Meters

Rick Christopherson

>

Can you say why the amount of impedance in the meter is so important?
As long as you brought up my previous analogy of the helium balloon, I will use that again here. Let's say you want to measure the height of the balloon, so you tie a piece of knotted string to the balloon and count the knots as the balloon rises. If the string is thick, it will weigh down the balloon enough that the balloon will not rise as high, or will simply fall to the ground when you attach the string. The lighter the string, the more accurate a measurement you will get of the actual height that the balloon will tend to fly unimpeded. The analog voltmeter would be analogous to using a thick string, while a digital voltmeter is analogous to using a fine silk thread.

The impedance (aka resistance) of the voltmeter will actually drain away the charge that you are trying to measure. An analog voltmeter needs to have a lower impedance because there needs to be some current flowing through the meter to make the needle move. The needle in an analog voltmeter is a galvanometer, which is kind of like a current-controlled motor, except it doesn't make a complete revolution. A digital voltmeter needs less power out of the tested circuit in order to sample the circuit. As I am sure you already know, you cannot measure something without impacting the thing you are trying to measure. For this reason, a digital meter is more accurate than an analog meter.

What Dan Donaldson stated is a common statement made by many electricians because the voltmeter will bleed off the voltage they are trying to read. In a case such as yours, that is fine, because you want to show that the voltage is just stray and not a real problem. However, on the opposite approach, this would tend to mask a floating ground situation that you may be searching for in the first place. Consider the problem discussed in the thread directly above this one. If that person is trying to determine if his saw was properly grounded using a voltmeter, the analog meter would indicate that it was, but a digital voltmeter would (possibly) say otherwise.

Personally, I typically find it more important to locate a non-grounded voltage than to identify if the voltage can be bled off easily. But I also come from an electronics background as well as an electrical background, so I also need to be able to measure small signals that cannot be measured with an analog meter without changing the signal I am trying to read.

Re: electrical shock

#20

Scary, but I had the same though!

John E

>

Re: electrical shock

#21

Re: Analog Vs Digital Meters

Dan Donaldson

>Both have a place. The digital can show that voltages are present, but the analog can help to see if it is a high impedance ground. From an impedance standpoint, digital meters are more "accurate", but from a measurement perspective, not necessarily so, especially with noisy ac signals. I spent 25 years designing oem communications equipment where NBS traceability was very important and we found that some of the digital equipment was not as good as the old analog stuff. From the perspective of this thread, you are absolutely correct, but digital is not always better ;-)

Re: electrical shock

#22

Yep, analog has its advantages…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> It was also nice for watching slow moving trends.

It's a lot easier tuning for peak (or minimumm) on an analog meter. Think transmitter or amplifier tuning, but there were plenty of other applications in RF where that's important.

A good example in the woodworking world was the digital level introduced about ten or fifteen years ago. Man was that thing hard to use. It was very difficult to get something level with it because there was only one, very narrow range where the indicator would not show either a left or right arrow (the indicator for which way was up, so to speak). You really had to sneak up on it because there was no trend to guide you. Not surprisingly, that methodology didn't last long.

Rod

Re: electrical shock

#23

Re: Analog Vs Digital Meters

eliot d

>I'm afraid that you have confused me. If there is some subtle stray voltage, then, from what you have explained to me, it would seem that one should test with the more accurate of the meters. So go for the digital. I'm getting the impression, now, that the stray voltage in my case is there but that I can see it only with the digital meter but not with the analogue meter. In other words, I'm fooling my self into thinking that there is no risk with the analogue meter. What am I missing?

Re: electrical shock

#24

Re: Analog Vs Digital Meters

Rick Christopherson

>No, you are not confused. However, it is just a matter of degree. If you used a digital meter to check the voltage between your shopvac hose and ground and found several tens of volts, would you even give it a moment's thought about using the shopvac anymore? Of course not, because you know that as soon as you touch the hose, the charge is dissipated, and the charge builds up slowly enough that you don't even know it is there most of the time. The mechanics of how the charge is introduced vary, but the amount of charge is trivial in either case.

Re: electrical shock

#25

Re: Analog Vs Digital Meters

eliot d

>What do you think would happen if I checked for current flow instead of voltage differential between the exterior of the lamp and ground? I haven't tried it yet.